jump to last post 1-21 of 21 discussions (30 posts)

Who is the best NFL quarterback of all time?

  1. Marla Rose profile image86
    Marla Roseposted 4 years ago

    Tell me who is your favorite all time NFL quarterback!

    1. Suhail and my dog profile image88
      Suhail and my dogposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Jim Kelly. I am surprised why he is never mentioned as even one of the greatest QBs of all the time. Kelly led the Bills to four consecutive Super Bowls, from 1991 to 1994, but lost all four to three different teams. In 2002, in his first year of eligibility, he was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
      Jim Kelly's number 12 is the only number ever retired in Buffalo Bills history. In 2009, Kelly was elected to the Buffalo Bills 50th Season All-time Team.

  2. 0
    oldandwiseposted 4 years ago

    It would be a toss up between John Elway and Joe Montana.Both great quarterbacks.

    1. Reality Bytes profile image93
      Reality Bytesposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Joe Montana for now.  Tom Brady will exceed Joe in a very short time.

  3. Stevennix2001 profile image82
    Stevennix2001posted 4 years ago

    Joe Montana, but Tom Brady could surpass him with a couple of more super bowl victories. big_smile

  4. Shawn Scarborough profile image82
    Shawn Scarboroughposted 4 years ago

    Johnny Unitas is the best QB of all time.  He threw for over 40,000 yards and 200 touchdowns in an era when defenses had the advantage and the running game was much more prevalent.

  5. weestro profile image81
    weestroposted 4 years ago

    Can't argue with Unitas or Montana.  Shawn I think you will agree it was not Babe Laughenberg!

    1. Shawn Scarborough profile image82
      Shawn Scarboroughposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Weestro, it definitely was not Babe Laughenberg.  LOL

  6. I am DB Cooper profile image67
    I am DB Cooperposted 4 years ago

    My favorite is Jim Kelly. The best ever is Peyton Manning. As I've said before, those Colts teams from the past decade and a half were not even average -- they were bad, yet they still were winning 10+ games just about every season because Peyton Manning was such an incredible quarterback. His career will likely end with only one Super Bowl championship, but I don't think anyone in the NFL has done "more with less" than Peyton Manning.

  7. SoManyPaths profile image60
    SoManyPathsposted 4 years ago

    Montana for me.  Brady 2nd but when you look at a teams talent you could argue Brady dies it with non-stars while the other QBs have valid spectacular weapons. I agree you gotta love Peyton too. Brady has more but I love Peyton's audibles and his down-to-earth attitude.  just a regular guy

  8. prettydarkhorse profile image63
    prettydarkhorseposted 4 years ago

    Terry Bradshaw!!

  9. Evankovach profile image61
    Evankovachposted 4 years ago

    I think it's impossible to compare across the different eras of the NFL as it becomes an apples and oranges argument.  Obviously the NFL has become a pass friendly league in the last decade which will certainly favors the likes of Brady, Manning, etc. Guys like Unitas succeeded at a time where defense and running the football were dominant in the league.

  10. 0
    Sooner28posted 4 years ago

    Like Evan just said, it is hard to compare across different decades because rules have changed.  Defenders cannot jam receivers all the way down the field like they used to, and many of the rough hits, like helmet to helmet, are now illegal.  What would Johnny Unitas be like in the NFL today?  Or Terry Bradshaw?  I do, however, think that a good measure would be consistency.  Who, after the learning curve all rookies face is overcome, played at a high level and led their teams to the playoffs and the Super Bowl throughout the individual's entire career. 

    Some quarterbacks that come to mind are Joe Montana, Brett Favre, Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, and Bart Starr.  Joe Montana won four Super Bowls and had a cumulative 16-7 record in the postseason.  If I were forced to choose, I would go with Montana.

    1. 910chris profile image74
      910chrisposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      I would have to go with Bart Starr. Then Joe Montana.

  11. MarkRFox profile image84
    MarkRFoxposted 4 years ago

    Tom Brady

  12. MarkRFox profile image84
    MarkRFoxposted 4 years ago

    You should ask this in question form, instead of a forum.

  13. BLACKANDGOLDJACK profile image83
    BLACKANDGOLDJACKposted 4 years ago

    Hey Marla, who is yours?

    I bet Peyton Manning will be if he ends up with the Dolphins.

    I say Terry Bradshaw. He looks the best naked by far. Right, prettydarkhorse? I'm talking about the movie "Failure to Launch" he starred in. He should have won an Oscar.

    Yeah, Tom Brady did wear a bra and panties in that Victoria's Secret commercial he did with his supermodel wife, Giselle. But he looked so . . .

    1. prettydarkhorse profile image63
      prettydarkhorseposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Terry Bradshaw naked is funny. He is funny as NFL on FOX analyst and he can always predict who will win the next games.

  14. Greek One profile image79
    Greek Oneposted 4 years ago

    Have you ever seen Jessie Palmer 'throw a pass' or 'go deep'??


    1. hobbitinspiration profile image61
      hobbitinspirationposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Tom Brady.  I like his attitude and he does more with less.

    2. 910chris profile image74
      910chrisposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      HA! He use to be the backup QB for the Giants. I think he was behind Kerry Collins when he did his "The Bachelor" show.

  15. Paul Edmondson profile image
    Paul Edmondsonposted 4 years ago

    Montana at four for four.  Brady is right there.  The most underrated may be what Terry Bradshaw did.

  16. Crystal June profile image60
    Crystal Juneposted 4 years ago

    John Elway is my favorite all time quarterback. Although he led the Broncos to Super Bowl victory only twice back to back in 1998 and 1999, he really is an amazing quarterback. He went to the Pro Bowl 9 times and was inducted into the Hall of Fame. I do believe that Tim Tebow can lead the Broncos to the same fate and join the list of amazing quarterbacks.

  17. manlypoetryman profile image71
    manlypoetrymanposted 4 years ago

    Localizing my answer...I would say: Warren Moon with Dan Pastorini coming in second. One of these days...maybe next season...It is going to be: Matt Schaub with TJ Yates coming in second!

  18. BLACKANDGOLDJACK profile image83
    BLACKANDGOLDJACKposted 4 years ago

    Do you think I’ll get banned if I post a picture of Terry Bradshaw’s naked butt? I have the pic right here on my computer. I was going to include it with the pics in my hub entitled, “Why I Love the Pittsburgh Steelers (Top Ten Reasons).” But then I had second thoughts, that being my first hub and all.


    I can’t believe that Crystal June mentioned Tim Tebow in the same breath as these other QBs. I’m still ticked off at God for divinely inspiring Tebow to beat the Steelers in the playoffs this past season.

    1. Greek One profile image79
      Greek Oneposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      if you showed a picture of Bradahaw's butt from the 70s, it could be a violation of the terms of use.

      if the pic is current, it would just be sad

    2. 910chris profile image74
      910chrisposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      You know what they say, the Lord works in mysterious ways!!

  19. Johnrr631992 profile image83
    Johnrr631992posted 4 years ago

    TOM BRADY!!!

  20. erwing1963 profile image61
    erwing1963posted 4 years ago

    Terry Bradshaw hands down!

  21. braxtonkp8497 profile image59
    braxtonkp8497posted 4 years ago

    The best QB of all time for me is Joe Montana.  As kid I hated him because he always won and always won when it counted most.  This was usually against my Redskins.  He seemed to make it look so easy and as a kid always thought he just got lucky.  But now that I am a football coached and have watched more football than most people should, I realize that his luck was skill.  No one can be that lucky.  Perhaps his best moment at least for me was mot the Super Bowl XXIII against Bengals in 1989, but the Monday Night vs. the Broncos in 1994 his last season.  The comeback drive was magic and the memory of it has stuck with me all these years. 

    I'm too young to remember Bradshaw in his prime and and the current crop of NFL QBs is of my generation.  They are good, but I would take Montana over all of them.