I've a typical oily skin. tried many facewash, still didn't get rid of oil on my face. So suggest best one out of two above mentioned products., and subscribe your own products based on using experience to get rid of oily skin(men).
I don't know much about either of the two products you mentioned but I would suggest Clinique. The reason being because you can purchase it at a beauty counter in a department store and you can let the consultant know your problems with your skin and they can suggest one that works best. Also, the have great products for all types of skin. Good luck!
You can help the HubPages community highlight top quality content by ranking this answer up or down.