Amazon Cloud Drive vs SkyDrive vs Dropbox

Now that Amazon has entered the market for consumer cloud data storage, there are three main contenders to consider, if you want to back your files up safely online.  They all have elements in common, as well as differences and different emphases.  It really depends on your needs as a user, and only you can decide where you're going to cloud your stuff.

Dropbox

Perhaps the best known is Dropbox, where you can sign up in minutes and get 2GB of storage for free.  For many users not backing up large media files, 2GB is fine, but you can gain additional blocks of 250MB up to a maximum of 8GB, by referring people - in fact if you click here  you can help me boost my storage and grab some yourself too!  If 16GB is still not enough you can also purchase additional storage, of up to 100GB per year, which is $200.  This should accommodate most of your home movies, and Dropbox also offers a back-up feature (also chargeable), and allows you to retrieve deleted files.  It's a comprehensive service that can serve the needs of most consumer users, with the range of paid and free options available, but Dropbox also offers one huge advantage over its competitors - the ability to synch with more than one computer.  If you use different machines at different locations, such as at home and at work, or you need to view or edit documents on a mobile device or tablet, this could be the clincher for you.  And for mobiles, there are a wide range of apps covering most major platforms.  You can even use it to transfer files to other users easily and freely.

The downsides to Dropbox?  Well, once you reach the 108GB threshold that's it - you can't add further increments at any price, at the present time.  Of course that is a LOT of storage, and isn't likely to be a problem except to media professionals or developers.  You have to work with their folder system, which might conflict with yours - it's really best used for individual files you might want to work on remotely.  Also lots of users have problems with iTunes when synching across multiple devices - again it's a file structure thing, there are workarounds, but if you need to back up serious amounts of media a different service might be better.

Window Live SkyDrive

A fairly recent offering from those folks at Microsoft, Windows Live scores big on ubiquity - if you want to use cloud storage to share files with other people, chances are they already have a hotmail/Windows Live account, so won't need to install or download a thing to facilitate that.  It's very easy to use, aimed at an entry-level consumer much like their IM, and it offers bespoke viewing options for videos and images.

It's free storage is a generous 25GB, and you really do get the feeling this service is aimed at family/consumer media files, though not feature length home movies as individual file uploads are capped at 50MB.  There is not currently any option to purchase or score larger amounts of storage, or any separate backup arrangements.  

However if you want to send clips of the grandchildren on the beach to a trusted network of messenger contacts, this is very simple and intuitive to use, and it does offer a good chunk of storage for free.  It also integrates smoothly with all related Windows Live services, including the Office Online.  It can be frustrating not to be able to see under the hood and control the files as much as you can with Dropbox, but it's serving a slightly different market and purpose.

Amazon Cloud Drive

The newcomer to the consumer cloud storage market is the familiar brand Amazon.  But it's no rookie, having provided its S3 solution to developers (many working on Amazon apps) for some time.

Amazon Cloud Drive is heavily oriented at music lovers, as it comes with an integrated companion app, Amazon Cloud Player - currently available as a native Android app and a webapp, so you need never store another MP3 on your smartphone!

The official free storage allowance is a mere 5GB when you register, but as soon as you buy one Mp3 album from Amazon.com you get a bonus 25MB, which makes things get a whole lot more interesting.  And it's upwards from there, offering scalable paid for services (at around 50% of the Dropbox rate) up to 1TB allowances.

Although it's a new service, many people will be drawn to the recognisable brand and reputation of Amazon, and clearly their hope is that they will also be lead to use Amazon for media purchases in future as well.  The rivalry between Amazon and Apple is far from a secret, and this explains why there is no app available for iOS users - who's holding things up isn't clear, but Apple have done this kind of thing before, in fact the Cloud Drive webapp won't even launch in Safari.  

Who know's what negotiations are afoot behind the scenes and this could change - pioneering early adopters will rave about the massive amount of storage available, but they'll have to cope with the rough spots being ironed out, whilst the rest of us sit back and wait and see.  

Making the choice is a matter of personal preference - if the music streaming is the big deal for you then the new Amazon offering definitely looks very interesting, but if lots of free space and easy set up beckons then give Skydrive a whirl.  But if synching across multiple devices is the big pull for you, then *for now* only Dropbox will do.  Of course, you could have multiple accounts - if your life segments neatly that might work, or you could tie yourself in knots remembering which files are synched where... whichever you go for, the potential opportunities for consumer cloud storage are now more interesting and diverse than ever before.  And greater competition can only benefit the consumers involved.

More by this Author


Comments 8 comments

WoodsmensPost profile image

WoodsmensPost 5 years ago from Arizona

Interesting hub. I use Dropbox and this is the first I have heard of the Amazon cloud drive. I also have an iPhone so the Dropbox app is great. I may give Amazon a whirl with the 5GB space because the music could always be transferred to a PC then uploaded to my Apple products. Cool thanks for the useful information.


StarCreate profile image

StarCreate 5 years ago from Spain Author

The Amazon one is really new... it'll be really interesting to see whether Dropbox now up their free storage in response ;-)


BRODEL 5 years ago

As for Amazon Cloud Drive, make sure you read the TOS..

"

5.2.Our Right to Access Your Files. You give us the right to access, retain, use and disclose your account information and Your Files: to provide you with technical support and address technical issues; to investigate compliance with the terms of this Agreement, enforce the terms of this Agreement and protect the Service and its users from fraud or security threats; or as we determine is necessary to provide the Service or comply with applicable law.

5.3.Security. We do not guarantee that Your Files will not be subject to misappropriation, loss or damage and we will not be liable if they are. You're responsible for maintaining appropriate security, protection and backup of Your Files.

"


StarCreate profile image

StarCreate 5 years ago from Spain Author

WHEW - that is scary Brodel, thanks for sharing and publicizing. They don't market as a backup service, so 5.3 is fair enough, to an extent. But I don't think I want them accessing my stuff 'as [they] determine is necessary'... no, I don't think so.


acisni 5 years ago

Great hub - my choice is Dropbox - very easy to use and works well. i use it between laptop and pc so the sharing feature is handy. More than enough storage for me at the moment. ps I keep photos separately using Picasa - for free also!


Disposed 5 years ago

Has to be some compromise brodel. You cant expect a company to just dish out a multi million dollar service for free without some sort of kick back.


skear profile image

skear 5 years ago from Kansas City

Nice writeup on the topic! I've been a fan of dropbox for a while but I had no idea they have a limit of 108GB. I'm reluctant to store all of my data in the cloud because I feel like I'll lose control of my data and get stuck paying increasing fees.


StarCreate profile image

StarCreate 5 years ago from Spain Author

@Skear, at least with Dropbox it's constantly synched between the two - so you never transfer stuff away and lose it. Faced with growing competition though I'd be surprised if Dropbox don't raise their storage limits for both free and premium services. Data just doesn't get smaller, and it never will!

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working