Amazon Kindle 3 vs Sony PRS-950 Review

Which ereader is the best?

I've been doing a lot of research into ereaders lately, annoying my friends and family by borrowing theirs for a few hours so I can see what the differences are and which is the right one for me.

Two of the top ereaders at the moment are the Amazon Kindle 3 and the Sony PRS-950. They are actually similar in a lot of ways, and they both use e-ink technology on pearl screens, which make them better for reading text than some other tablet-like devices, such as the iPad and iPad 2.

Let's take a look at some of the differences between the Kindle 3 and the Sony PRS-950:

The Sony PRS-950

Here are a few of the things that I thought the PRS-950 did better than the Kindle 3:

  • 7 inch screen instead of 6 inch screen. That might not seem like a huge difference, but remember that screen size is measured on the diagonal, so the Sony actually has 28% more screen real estate than the Kindle.
  • Touchscreen. This is a biggie. I have found myself on more than one occasion trying to touch something on the Kindle screen, only to remember it doesn't have that function.
  • Great for note-taking or doodling on ebooks.
  • Quality aluminum construction. It just felt like better build quality in my hands.
  • User development community. There are a lot of folks working to create tweaks to make the PRS-950 even better. The Kindle 3 is more locked down and any significant chances come from Amazon.

And now some PRS-950 cons:

  • It's expensive. The best price I found was $299. That significantly more than the Kindle 3 -- even the more expensive version with 3G. Sony has to charge a higher price because they don't get a big cut of the ebook sales like Amazon. Amazon can sell their Kindles at cost or even at a loss, because they know Kindle owners will buy lots of ebooks from Amazon.
  • Fonts aren't as crisp. When comparing the same pdf file on both ereaders, the Kindle looks fantastic while the PRS-950 fonts look a little fuzzy around the edges.
  • Less zoom options. This can be a problem with some pdf files, which need to be scaled down for the smaller screen. The Kindle 3 of course needs more zoom options because it has a smaller screen, so maybe this isn't as big of a deal as I imagine.
  • Notes cannot be exported natively. Not out of the box. The Sony e-reader community is working on it, and they have figured this out on other Sony e-readers.

The Amazon Kindle 3

The Kindle 3 is much cheaper than the PRS-950, but it still does some things better, including the following:

  • Crisp fonts. I don't know how they do it, but even on pdf files they look amazing.
  • Incredible battery life. I'm amazed that an electronics device can work for so long on one charge.
  • Fonts are changeable in some file formats. Unfortunately, pdf is not one of them.

Some things I didn't like about the Kindle 3 included:

  • No touchscreen. This isn't just about convenience, because the way that it chops up some pdf pages makes them unreadable when using a scroller, where if it was touchscreen the page would flow and wouldn't need the e-reader to cut it into sections.
  • Pictures are a problem in many formats, including pdfs. If you like reading graphic novels on an ereader, I can't recommend a Kindle 3.
  • The keyboard is large and clunky.
  • Amazon is opposed to the third-party development community. They want to control what can be done with their devices. You should be aware of this before buying one.

So is the Kindle 3 or Sony PRS-950 the better e-reader?

In the end, the Sony PRS-950 is the better e-reading device, but there is a significant cost difference. Look at the pros and cons of each device and if you think they're close for your needs on everything except price, the Kindle 3 might be the best pick for you. As of this writing, the difference in cost was over $100.

More by this Author


Comments

No comments yet.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working