Compare Online Image Hosting: Flickr vs Picasa
Everyone loves taking digital photos. It's fun and easy. If you are an avid web surfer or blogger, you may have stumbled upon an image hosting site. The 2 most popular image hosting services today are Flickr and Picasa. While they are focused on image hosting, they do offer limited video hosting. Both Flickr and Picasa start you off with a "free" account and they give you the option to upgrade later. Let's look at what each service has to offer. Why should you use an image hosting site? How do they work? And most importantly, which one is best for you? I have used both Flickr and Picasa and I will go over the advantages and disadvantages of both.
First, let's start with Flickr. Flickr is the go-to image hosting site that had naturally replaced photobucket as the leading service provider for free image hosting. Flickr is owned by Yahoo! and is very popular amongst young bloggers and photography enthusiasts. You can view other people's photos by tags, location, date, and even sort them by the camera they used to snap the picture. Flickr allows for a and puts a big emphasis on social networking. By tagging your photos and sharing it, you can get many views and comments. For a casual user like myself and those who are wondering what Flickr and Picasa is all about, let's look at their free service.
With Flickr's free service, you are allowed 100MB of uploading
per month each month. In theory, you can have unlimited storage with
a free account but in my opinion, I hit the bandwidth cap in 1 day.
Not something I was happy about. Anyone with a good 10 plus MP digital
camera will quickly reach the upload cap in a single day of moderate
shooting. In order to throttle your available bandwidth, you have to
either upload fewer files per month, re-size your picture to a smaller
resolution, or both. You are also allowed 2 video uploads limited to
90 seconds each.
Flickr gives you the option to upgrade your account for $25 per year. With a "pro" account, you get unlimited uploads and storage, unlimited sets (folders), access to the original file, stats for your account, HD playback option on your videos and unlimited video uploads (though still limited to 90 seconds). Flickr makes uploading and sharing photos social. People are encouraged to make their pictures public so others can search for them and add comments too. The social aspects of Flickr also comes with it a set of strict community guidelines such as no profanity, nudity, and hot-linking. Also you cannot use Flickr for commercial purposes. This means no using it to make money.
Picasa is the direct alternative to Flickr. Picasa is owned by Google
which seems fitting since Google and Yahoo! have been competing against
each other since the early years of the web. Picasa offers much of the
same features as Flickr but they branch off in their intended purpose.
For the free account, Picasa start you off with 1024 MB of storage which equates to a little over a GB. Unlike Flickr, Picasa does not have a bandwidth limit. This means you can use it all up in a single day if you wish. Picasa allows you to access your uploaded pictures in it's original quality. This means you can re-download your picture and have it the way you upload it rather than a scaled down version.
Picasa is also more flexible than Flickr. Since it is owned by
Android powered devices and other Google services offer near seamless
integration. For example, if you have an Android smart phone, it is
very easy to take a picture on your phone and upload it to Picasa. No
need to mount your phone's SD card and transfer it to your computer
in order to upload it to Picasa. To be fair, there are third party apps
on many smart phones that allow easy upload to Flickr but having Picasa
integrate into Google accounts is a sweet deal if you are a heavy Google
user. You can create contact groups such as friends and family on your
Google account and share certain albums to certain groups. This makes
it easy to control which people view what photos. Create a group for
coworkers and only allow them to see non-personal pictures. Best of
all, these contact groups stay with your Google account and sort in
related services like Gtalk.
You can upload pictures to Picasa and Flickr through your browser but Google offers Picasa as a program you can download. Picasa runs on Windows XP/Vista, Mac OS X, and Linux. The program is very good. It allows you to upload pictures in batches much like ftp. You can literally upload hundreds of pictures with a few clicks. The program also can re-size the photos on the fly optimizing it for web. For example if you want to upload an 8 MB picture and only have it for the web, you can upload your picture with Picasa and tell it to re-size your picture accordingly. This makes uploading large amounts of photos easy.
There are third party programs you can download that have both Flickr
and Picasa API's. This basically means you can do batch uploads with
other programs but out of the 2 image hosting services, Picasa is the
only one so far that offers a dedicated program they officially support.
This is really great! So far I have not had any big complaints on my
Linux version of Picasa.
Google offers upgrades for Picasa's service in a slightly different
way Yahoo! has done with Flickr. If you want to upgrade your Picasa
account, you are only offered storage since you don't have a bandwidth
cap. When you buy storage, instead of buying storage for your Picasa
web photo albums, you buy storage that is shared with your Google
For example, if you purchase 20 GB of extra storage, this is shared
with Gmail, Picasa Web Albums, and Google Docs. Think of the upgrade
as a Google account upgrade. There are several upgrade plans to choose
from. If we are to compare it to Flickr's yearly upgrade, you would
have to buy 80 GB at $20 plus 20 GB at $5 for a total of 100 GB of
for $25 per year.
Picasa's program policies is similar to Flickr's. No porn, hateful, illegal, violent, spam, and impersonations allowed. Unlike Flickr, you are allowed to monetize your pictures with the exception of commercial pornography. It seems like Flickr Is rated PG while Picasa is holding a PG-13 rating.
While there are many apparent similarities, Flickr and Picasa aim
at a slightly different audience with slightly different needs. Flickr
clearly is focusing on the social aspect of photo sharing while Picasa
aims for ease of use and convenient integration with Google services
and Android. For the free service that each provide, I do find Picasa
to win over Flickr. This is mainly due to the 100 MB monthly bandwidth
limit compared to the unlimited bandwidth you get from Picasa. While
you have a 1 GB cap of storage space on Picasa and no limit on Flickr,
it would take you 10 months to break even with Picasa and surpass it
from there on. Another thing that I found annoying was the limited
you get from Flickr compared to Picasa. Why do I have to upgrade to
get access to my pictures at their original file size? This is like
a bully stealing your lunch money and then dangling it over your head
insulting you with it.
For the paid service, I would rank Picasa above Flickr also but not without a second look. You do get unlimited bandwidth and storage with Flickr while 100 GB of shared storage with Picasa but this battle only benefits Flickr if you plan on uploading over 100 GB of pictures per year. The ease of use of Picasa and integration with Google accounts is the deciding factor for me. It's just much more convenient. Plus if I am uploading over 100 GB of pictures and I'm not allowed to make money out of it then that seems rather pointless to me. I'm not too big on the social aspect of Flickr and that factor doesn't sell it for me. Also, I won't even consider the video upload service as I find it laughable that Flickr only allows 90 second clips. We have Youtube or Vimeo if we want a video host. In my opinion, I think Picasa wins over Flickr in both the free and paid version of their service. Google has been doing quite well in the last few years. It's one thing to say, "Whatever Google touches turn into gold." But it may also be true that Google only touch things that are golden. Is Picasa one of them? Thank you for reading.
- Which buy? Canon 7D vs Canon 550D vs Canon 60D
Overview As time progress, cameras become more powerful and compact (And heck even a hole lot cheaper) to the point where considering three products in three different price range becomes almost impossible...
- Panasonic Lumix DMC-FH22 Review
The class of compact digital cameras is crowded and the competition is fierce. With all the choices of compact digitals, the Panasonic Lumix FH22 is an honorable point and shoot that delivers great quality...
- Sony Cybershot DSC W350 Review
In the market of compact digital cameras from $150 - $200, the competition is fierce. As consumers, we luck out because big manufacturers like Canon, Nikon, Panasonic, Sony, and etc are competing for our...
- Best Video Hosting Service: Youtube vs Vimeo For Embedded Streaming Video
There are many comparison reviews done on many different streaming video services. Youtube and Vimeo are 2 of the top video hosting services. They offer the option to insert embedded video onto a blog or...
- Compare Online File Storage: Rapidshare, Megaupload, Hotfile
If you are an avid web surfer like me, you may have stumbled upon file sharing sites such as Rapidshare, Megaupload, and Hotfile. How exactly do these uploading sites work and why should you use them?...
- 4 Easy Principles On Making Money With Hotfile
Hotfile is a great file hosting site. Not only do they offer you virtual storage at a low yearly fee but if you become a premium member, you also have the option of making some extra money. How it works is...
- How to Download Multiple Files From Rapidshare, Megaupload, Uploading, and Hotfile
If you are a frequent Internet surfer, you may have stumbled upon file hosting websites such as Rapidshare, Megaupload, Uploading, and my favorite, Hotfile. These site offer virtual on-line file storage....
More by this Author
All across America, businesses everywhere are offering the convenient service of free wifi. Wireless Internet access which used to be considered a luxury is now becoming a standard complimentary service offered with...
First and foremost, when I say Wordpress, I mean a self hosted blogging/cms platform. I don't mean the free Wordpress blog you can get at wordpress.com. Although Hubpages says that writing hubs is not blogging, the two...
Which is the best shampoo for getting rid of and preventing moderate dandruff?