Nokia Phone Cameras E7 v N9 v Lumia800

Panorama of Kirkstall Abbey- E7

Posted this, because I think the big win for EDOF is the Panorama photo :)
Posted this, because I think the big win for EDOF is the Panorama photo :) | Source

Macro From E7, N9 & Lumia 800 Indoors

E7 Macro
E7 Macro | Source
N9 Macro
N9 Macro | Source
Lumia Macro
Lumia Macro | Source

Reason for post

So this post was inspired by a few things, firstly, during his review of my Nokia N9, Steve Litchfield , @stevelitchfield on Twitter, appeared to have issues with the macro photography mode on my phone in the video review he did.You basically have to hold the virtual camera button until the focus point turns blue, but as Steve rightly stated, a camera phone REALLY should have a physical camera button ! So, anyway, I thought I'd check it out ? Secondly, as pointed out to me by @mobileyog on Twitter , I have three of Nokia's operating systems on my current phones, Symbian on the E7, Meego on my N9 and Windows Phone Mango on my Lumia800, and as I haven't posted anything new for a while, and the most popular piece I've done was a camera comparison, I thought I'd do another one, comparing how the different OS's and cameras performed.

Phones Show Review of my N9 - http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=iWipaFX9Myc

Both the N9 and the Lumia, as far as I know, have the same camera unit, an 8 Megapixel Auto Focus unit, however the Lumia has a physical camera button, demanded by Windows Phone, and the N9 has a virtual 'button' on the screen within the camera app, the E7 also has an 8 Megapixel camera, but it is EDOF (extended depth of field) which means it is in effect fixed focus and through software everything from about 30cm out should be in perfect focus, this however makes mcro photography almost redundant !! Some people like EDOF, some hate it, I quite like it, as I'm not the greatest photographer in the world, as you'll see if you continue to read on !!

More Indoor Macro going down E7, N9, Lumia

E7
E7 | Source
N9
N9 | Source
Lumia
Lumia | Source
E7
E7 | Source
E7
E7 | Source
N9
N9 | Source
N9
N9 | Source
Lumia
Lumia | Source
Lumia
Lumia | Source

Also as all three phones have recently had somewhat major software updates (Nokia are doing rather well in the SW update field lately !!) I was also interested to see if any improvements had happened in the camera dept with my phones, certainly the camera menu in the E7 seems different and the whole of the UI seems a bit quicker in the N9 ? I tried to take screen shots of the camera menus, but only the N9 ones worked, so I haven't bothered posting them !

So anyway, here are the pics from the three phones, I've tried to compose them as closely as possible to each other and taken them in different lighting conditions, some inside and some outdoors on a sunny afternoon, and as Nokia camera's are something of a buzz word at the moment with the recent announcement of the Nokia 808, I thought a few pics may be appropriate :)

Default and macro shots in Calverley Woods

E7
E7 | Source
N9
N9 | Source
Lumia
Lumia | Source
Kinda 'Macro' Crocus E7
Kinda 'Macro' Crocus E7 | Source
Macro Crocus N9
Macro Crocus N9 | Source
Macro Crocus Lumia
Macro Crocus Lumia | Source
Clara Drive Through the E7
Clara Drive Through the E7 | Source
Clara Drive Through the N9
Clara Drive Through the N9 | Source
Clara Drive Through the Lumia
Clara Drive Through the Lumia | Source
Farmhouse E7
Farmhouse E7 | Source
Farmhouse N9
Farmhouse N9 | Source
Farmhouse Lumia
Farmhouse Lumia | Source

Kirkstall Abbey Leeds

Abbey Cafe Gardens E7
Abbey Cafe Gardens E7 | Source
Abbey Cafe Gardens N9
Abbey Cafe Gardens N9 | Source
Abbey Cafe Gardens Lumia
Abbey Cafe Gardens Lumia | Source
Sign to Abbey Park E7
Sign to Abbey Park E7 | Source
Sign to Abbey Park N9
Sign to Abbey Park N9 | Source
Sign to Abbey Park Lumia
Sign to Abbey Park Lumia | Source
Abbey E7
Abbey E7 | Source
Abbey N9
Abbey N9 | Source
Abbey Lumia
Abbey Lumia | Source
Macro Crocus E7 (kind of !)
Macro Crocus E7 (kind of !) | Source
Macro Crocus E7 (kind of !)
Macro Crocus E7 (kind of !) | Source
Macro Crocus N9
Macro Crocus N9 | Source
Macro Crocus N9
Macro Crocus N9 | Source
Macro Crocus Lumia
Macro Crocus Lumia | Source
Macro Crocus Lumia
Macro Crocus Lumia | Source
Weir on the Aire E7
Weir on the Aire E7 | Source
Weir on the Aire N9
Weir on the Aire N9 | Source
Weir on the Aire Lumia
Weir on the Aire Lumia | Source
Abbey Ruins E7
Abbey Ruins E7 | Source
Abbey Ruins N9
Abbey Ruins N9 | Source
Abbey Ruins Lumia
Abbey Ruins Lumia | Source
Tilting Abbey E7
Tilting Abbey E7 | Source
Tilting Abbey N9
Tilting Abbey N9 | Source
Tilting Abbey Lumia
Tilting Abbey Lumia | Source

Conclusion

Well my unskilled and unprofessional opinion is, that all three phones can take a decent photo in decent light and set to auto, the E7 is easy to use, but not much good, as well documented, with close ups, but seems a little better with Belle, and that of my two AF phones, for some reason, the N9 seems to take better photos overall and that there may be some more work needed on the SW front, which is apparently due to arrive shortly. The other thing I learned is that it really helps to get a decent photo if you have some skill and imagination, and maybe practice is something that vastly improves ALL cameras ?

Thanks for reading


Minor update, took a few more shots, just with N9 and Lumia and posted to Flickr today, the Lumia didn't fair as well with macro !!

http://www.flickr.com/photos/stephenquin58/sets/72157629630594531/

More by this Author

  • Nokia CC-3046 Hard Cover, Buyer Beware
    4

    Nokia CC-3046 Hard Cover-Buyer Beware This is a brief review of the Nokia CC-3046 Hard Case for the Nokia 808 PureView phone, some of you may have read the prequal I wrote as I got my 808, which I love, and...


Comments 3 comments

Suyog 4 years ago

Good post. I also had issues with macro mode on N9 but somehow they are no more. May be PR1.2 update solved it.

Being more camera centric user , I want best of camera in phone. So my year old N8 beats all. Waiting for 808 now :)

Overall looking at pics , I agree N9 is winner.


carman58 profile image

carman58 4 years ago from Leeds, Uk Author

well thanks for reading and commenting Suyog, cheers :)


Jodi 3 years ago

Super invromatife writing; keep it up.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working