Breastfeeding | A French vs. American Perspective

French and American mothers approach breastfeeding very differently. While American mothers are encouraged to breastfeed for as long as possible, for French women the emphasis leans towards getting back to their former shape.

Source

Growing up in the melting pot that is New York City, I was constantly exposed to cultural diversity. One neighbor was Greek, one Chinese while another was Italian, just to name a few. Familiarity with multiple cultures was normal to me. I found the cultural interplay to be fun and fascinating. While one day at my Greek friend’s house enjoying baklava and the next day I would taste fresh homemade egg rolls from my Asian friend’s Mom, and on yet another day, I would overhear a debate about what makes a perfect pasta sauce and how to sliver a clove of garlic. This diverse exposure made me curious about the origin of these and other cultures and later in my life, inspired a passion for international travel. After college, my first European tour was only good enough to whet my appetite for further learning and understanding of the cultures of the world. I have often heard it said that as human beings, underneath the outward differences, we are all the same. This idea is something I consider and reconsider, but I am still not so sure.

I have observed that our cultural experiences, especially those of our childhood, DO make us different, even at the core. This is because we see the world very differently and make choices based on these views. This concept is underscored in the parable of The Blind Men and the Elephant. In this story six blind men are asked to determine what an elephant looked like by feeling different parts of the elephant's body. The blind man who feels a leg says the elephant is like a pillar; the one who feels the tail says the elephant is like a rope; the one who feels the trunk says the elephant is like a tree branch, and so on. They are all touching the same animal but experience and describe it differently. Each individual is able to see the world as a different experience based on their perception of what the world is and this is a metaphor for life.

The idea of differing perceptives presented itself to me recently while flipping through the pages of French Vogue Magazine with a French American friend of mine. Many photographs in this iconic Women’s Fashion Magazine reveal bare breasts. Just seeing this might surprise any American who is accustomed to a more puritanical choice of images from American media. Comparatively, there are no topless women in American Vogue Magazine, but the differences between French and American women don’t end here. My friend also mentioned that the emphasis on maintaining a woman’s body is so great that even after having a baby, French Women are discouraged from breastfeeding as this would negatively affect the firmness of the breast. If a French woman does breastfeed it is typically for a brief period of time. Most French women will have stopped breastfeeding by time they leave the hospital.

The French believe that breastfeeding causes the breasts to lose their youthful erotic shape, although American experts believe that it is heredity that determines the shape of the breast, not breastfeeding. The French priority is on the sexuality of a woman’s body, with more per capita lingerie shops than any other country, spending time feeding a baby instead of caring for sexual appeal goes against Parisian priorities.

The differences between the American style of Parenting and the French doesn’t end here. Along the same lines, French women are also encouraged to space themselves from their baby which is the opposite of the American encouraged 'attachment style' of parenting which is greatly encouraged here in the states. Here are some other parenting differences:

France
United States
 
Up to 7 day hospital stay
24-36 hour hospital stay
 
Feed on a schedule
Feed on demand
 
Minimal breast feeding
One year of breastfeeding recommended
 
Difficult to find a nursing bra
Nursing bras readily available
 
Start solid food early
Delay solid food
 
Free physio sessions to regain waistline abs and kegels
Women are on their own getting back in shape
 
Get back to your pre-pregnancy body quickly
Allow time to get back to your shape
 
Breasts are primarily sexual
Mixed feelings about breasts
 

It is fascinating to think that two cultures can do nearly the opposite thing with the belief that they are doing what is right. Maybe the women in each country could learn from one another. American Mothers could benefit from more support and time to heal from pregnancy and French women could lose the stigma that longer term breastfeeding seems to carry.

The different attitudes toward breastfeeding and a woman’s body are only a small part of the varying attitudes towards sexuality in general between French and American women. Recent studies have shown that French women are more sexually active even after they reach age 50 than their American counterparts and that French men and woman remain in longer term relationships than Americans.

According to Alain Giami, director of research at the French National Institute of Health and Medical Research

The French are also less attached than Americans to marriage as the unique option for living together. The French have more “premarital cohabitation,” “nonmarital cohabitation” and even “noncohabiting long-term relations.” This seems to make it easier for men and women age 40 or older to have companionship after having experienced the burden of marriage and cohabitation.

The contrasting views between French and American women on breasts, breastfeeding and in a greater sense, sexuality, reveals how cultural perspectives lead us in making personal choices. Having an open mind to look at and make sense of the cultural differences helps us to learn and understand both ourselves and others more deeply.

© Copyright 2011 Tracy Lynn Conway with all rights reserved.

You can...

  • Learn more about the author Tracy Lynn Conway.
  • Begin publishing for free on HubPages sign up here!
  • Did you find this article useful? Leave a comment below and share your thoughts.

More by this Author


Comments 7 comments

Express10 profile image

Express10 4 years ago from East Coast

Interesting, I never knew that nursing bras were hard to find in France or that mothers get free help regaining their pre-pregancy body. Maybe that's why many of them seem to look so good. I guess we take some things for granted here in the U.S. I will be careful of where I open it if my cousin in France brings back a French Vogue.


Ruchi Urvashi profile image

Ruchi Urvashi 4 years ago from Singapore

Very interesting hub. I gave birth to my baby in Ireland and felt that breastfeeding was not done by most mothers. However, the doctors encouraged it and when I requested for it, there were nurses and trainers to help me.


Tracy Lynn Conway profile image

Tracy Lynn Conway 4 years ago from Virginia, USA Author

Express10, it is amazing how we take things for granted or assume that other people think the way we do. Breastfeeding has gone through it's own changes in the U.S. from the time that formula was introduced up to the present. Thank you for your comment!

Best, Tracy

Ruchi, I am glad to hear that you got the support that you needed in Ireland and thank you for sharing your experience, it is very interesting. After giving birth to my second child and a few days having passed with successful breastfeeding, I was awoken in the night and told to give my baby a bottle since his blood sugar was low. I insisted on simply breastfeeding him again and needed to be very firm, and this helped to raise his blood sugar levels back to normal. As this example shows there is still this idea, at least at this American Hospital, that the bottle was somehow more reliable. Thank you.

Best, Tracy


sweetie1 profile image

sweetie1 4 years ago from India

Tracy Nice hub. In India we usually advise to breast feed as long as possible and keep difference of at least 3 years in between two children so you can brestfeed her as much as you can. About Solids we advise after 6 months and that too like cerelac. In fact In India these days the paeds. are against bottle feeding. In rural India it is not uncommon to see child brest feed even for 2 or 3 years.


Tracy Lynn Conway profile image

Tracy Lynn Conway 4 years ago from Virginia, USA Author

Hi Sweetie1, the breastfeeding customs in India that you have described are very wise. I always think of breast milk as "liquid gold" as it is so nutritionally beneficial to the baby and facilitates bonding. I also think that the 3 or more year spacing is wise as it gives the mother and baby time before the next bundle of joy arrives. I love getting your input and perspective, thank you so much!

Best, Tracy


Docmo profile image

Docmo 4 years ago from UK

Breast feeding is a wonderful thing for mums and children alike- it offers natural contraception during the early stages, causes bonding, delivers all the nutrition for the baby as well as conveying immunity in the early weeks, reduces post natal depression and so much more. I still remember my friend , when asked to write about the benefits of breast milk in med school- wrote all that and then put ' available in attractive containers!' Great hub Tracy!


Tracy Lynn Conway profile image

Tracy Lynn Conway 4 years ago from Virginia, USA Author

Docmo,

That is funny! Breasts might possibly be the most attractive containers, at least to the human eye. You are right about all that it offers, as well as the most magnificent opportunity for bonding between mother and child. Thank you for your great comment and compliment.

Best, Tracy

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working