Robert the Haunted Doll

"Robert did it."

While haunted doll stories are not uncommon, the case of The worlds most Haunted doll as many call him, or Robert the ghost haunted Doll of Key West, Florida, is unique in that so many claim to have witnessed his evil first-hand.

Visitors who have seen him claim to have witnessed his expression changing into a menacing smirk, once a plumber fled, claiming he heard the doll giggle.

One of Robert's favorite activities is to prevent his picture from being taken. Visitors have more then often openly reported a variety of camera malfunctions and Robert's favorite trick is to black out his own photo, while leaving the remaining film unharmed. He frequently creates electric and electronic fluctuations and has been said to move his toy lion from one knee to the other and to tap on his glass display case.

In what many speculate was actually an act of revenge, a Bahamian servant gave his son, Robert Eugene Otto a doll made of a wire frame, cloth, straw, and most likely, a soulstone. This type of enchantment in some voodoo practices involves a small crystal being placed into an object, thus imbuing it with power by taking a soul of its own.

When Anne left, she left Robert locked in his upstairs room, and put in a lease agreement that 'Robert must at all times remain the sole occupant of the attic room', or the contract was void. This remained true up until her death in 1976. The first new reports were from a plumber working after Anne left. The plumber reported:

Future occupants reported hearing noises upstairs including footsteps, laughter, and crashes, and upon inspection, found that Robert had moved position from where they left him. At this time, usually he would only cross his arms, move or cross his legs, or move from chair to chair. The occupants were so disturbed by this that they locked him in a sea chest in his room -- thus staying true to Robert the Doll welcomes you to the Customs House each October where he waits in his glass case, perhaps sucking on peppermints that the Custom House staff place beside him to keep him content. And He loves his pepermints.

Robert's House aka "The Artist House"
Robert's House aka "The Artist House"

Robert's Legend

The dark story of Robert the Haunted Doll began near the turn of the century when the family of eccentricKey West artist Robert Eugene Otto took up residence in the famous Artist's House in the heart of the city. Affluent and well-travelled, the Ottos found the easy and unhurried lifestyle of the Florida Keys most agreeable. They settled in with their young son and a large staff to wait on their every need.

Local legend holds that the Ottos were stern people who held their son to rigid expectations and expected strict obedience from their staff. It is said that the Ottos took on a Jamaican woman as a nurse for young "Gene," as they called him, and it was she who spent the long hours with him while his parents travelled the States and other parts of the globe. But the idyllic relationship was not to last, and the story is told that the nurse got on the bad side of Mrs. Otto and was promptly dismissed. But before she left the household she gave a gift to her favorite charge -- a hand-sewn stuffed doll, made in the likeness of young Gene. A slightly imperfect replica who Gene took to immediately.

The doll was christened with Gene's first name, Robert, and from the moment he received him from his Jamaican nurse, Gene never let the doll out of his sight. It went everywhere with him and was often seen accompanying the boy on day trips into town, both neat little gentlemen in pressed white sailor suits sitting perched among the Otto servants or straggling along behind Mrs. Otto as she shopped.

At meal times Robert sat in his own little chair beside Gene who would sneak little bits of food to Robert out of the sight of his parents. At bath time Robert would assume his spot on a dry towel while Gene soaked and played with wooden ships and corks in his nightly ritual. And when it came time to settle in for the night, Robert was tucked neatly in beside the drowsing boy ready to accompany him even into his dreams.

Soon, however, the relationship between Gene and his doll took on a troubling aspect. Gene could often be heard playing joyfully in his toy room one moment and then, after a solemn silence, the sound of low conversation would trickle down to the servants' ears, first in Gene's boyish voice and then in an entirely different tone. Sometimes Gene's voice would sound agitated, but the responding voice only sounded insistent, and it was these moments that began to trouble first the servants and then Mrs. Otto most. On occasion the concerned mother would burst in upon her child and, oddly and unexpectedly, find her son cowering in a corner of the room, and the doll perched in a chair or on the bed, seemingly glaring down at the boy.

Eventually, the disruption to the household left the playroom and the nursery and it became evident to all who lived in the household that something just wasn't right about the little doll and the odd hold it seemed to have over the youngest resident.

More troubling were the inexplicable events that began to occur -- glassware and silverware thrown about the dining room, servants locked out while on their nightly rounds, clothing torn up and bedding in rooms long unused disturbed and crumpled on the ground. Most troubling, other beloved toys belonging to young Gene began to turn up mutilated and brutalized while deep in the night there was the sound of giggling.

Of course, young Gene was blamed for committing mischief and was soundly disciplined by his parents. On each occasion the boy took the punishment but not without first pleading and insisting each time that "Robert did it!" Although his parents never believed this, it didn't take much protesting to convince the servants, and the staff turnover at the Otto house was understandably high. At one point, concerned relatives attempted to intervene and on the recommendation of a great aunt, Robert the Doll was taken from young Gene and sent to live in a box in the Otto attic. One night later the aunt was found dead in her bed, the victim, it was believed, of a stroke, but immediately following her untimely demise, Robert once again took up his place at Gene's side.

Gene Otto never left the family house and when his parents finally died he was left there to live unhindered, with Robert by his side. Unlike most mature men of his age, Gene never put away this particular childhood relic -- later it would be suggested by some close to him that the doll would not allow Gene to abandon it in such a way. As Gene got used to life "alone" at the Artist House, Key West began to talk -- and not about the living resident they knew to be there.

Stories abounded of the sounds of giggling and maniacal laughter coming from "the Turret Room" -- the Victorian corner of the house that Gene had inhabited as a boy. This had now become Robert's domain, or so it was said, and everything there -- the furnishings, the curtains, the "tolerated" toys that Robert had not destroyed all were left as they had been in Gene's childhood.

Servants were kept sporadically and even the most stout hearted of them didn't stay for very long at the Artist House. Finally, the staff dwindled altogether to a couple that came in for a few hours a day; while the wife cooked Gene's meals the husband would tend to minor chores around the house. But both would be long gone before sunset, and neither would venture into the Turret Room or near that end of the house no matter how they were threatened or cajoled.

Soon, the needs of manhood (at least temporarily) over rode the attachment to childhood and to Robert the Doll when Gene Otto took a wife. The marriage was troubled from the start, not the least because Gene insisted on Robert accompanying the couple everywhere.

Gene Otto died in 1972.The home was sold to a new family, and the tale of Robert had died down...

But Robert waited patiently up in the attic to be discovered, once again. The 10 year old daughter of the new owners. Was quick to find Robert in the attic. It was not long before Robert unleashed his displeasure on the child... The little girl claiming that the doll tortured her, and made her life a hell.. Even after more than thirty years later, she steadfastly claims that " the doll was alive and wanted to kill her."

A Small Documentary on Robert the Doll

Robert's New Home

Still, tourists who visit the Artist House today say Robert, dressed in his white sailor's suit and clutching his stuffed lion, is not necessarily "attached" to his new home, as they have reported the sounds of giggling and small scampering feet in the empty rooms where the tour guides feared to take them. Sometimes children on their way to school pass the Artist House and flee in terror from the face of Robert peering down from the Turret Room windows. Doors are still found unlocked, windows left slightly open in the areas that Gene and Robert frequented all their lives.

But his displeasure at being a display item at the East Martello Museum seems unceasing. Employees at the museum continue to give accounts of Robert being up to his old tricks still today. Visitors are chilled by the sight of him. One woman was disturbed to find that the expression on the doll changed right before her eyes. "One minute he was smiling, then he was frowning and mad," she said.

Other visitors who try to take a photo of the famous doll have been disappointed to find black frames instead of photos. Digital cameras are useless and the lighting in the area where Robert now "lives" is consistently bad, despite the musuem's repeated attempts to provide more illumination. Of course, "Robert did it" is still the motto when things go bump in the night, and no member of the museum staff wants to be the last to leave at night.

Each October, Robert the Doll goes to stay in a glassdisplay case at the Custom House in Key West. Musuem curators say that this is the best chance to "meet" Robert and that anyone stopping by should not fail to introduce him or herself to the doll. Stories from those who failed to show this little courtesy are numerous, such as the woman from Orlando who reports that Robert, or something like him, followed her home after a Custom House visit. She reported that the silhouette of the doll was repeatedly seen in her bedroom window and throuhgout the ordeal of that night there seemed to be no electricity in her bedroom, although lights remained on in other parts of the house.

Robert the Doll welcomes you to the Customs House each October where he waits in his glass case, perhaps sucking on peppermints that the Custom House staff place beside him to keep him content. Although the Museum and Customs House don't advertise it, Robert is always in the market for a new home with a nice family and a child who will love him as if her were a REAL boy.

Robert the Doll at the East Martello Museum Key West, Florida

More by this Author

  • "The Mongoose" vs "The Snake"  The Greatest Rivalry In Drag Racing

    This was the battle cry that once stirred excitement in the mid 1960s and early 1970s. The announcer over the radio conjured dramatic visions in a voice-over... in the background you could hear the roar of nitro-burning...

  • 100 Song's Best Lines

    1 All lies and jest, still, a man hears what he wants to hear and disregards the rest. - Simon and Garfunkel, The Boxer 2 All of us get lost in the darkness, dreamers learn to steer by the stars. - Rush, The Pass 3...

  • The Legend of Codex Gigas or "The Devil's Bible"

    The pages are allegedly made from the skins of 160 donkeys, the Codex Gigas, is the world's largest and the most mysterious medieval manuscript. According to the Codex legend, this disturbingly beautiful text sprang...

Comments 40 comments

mistyhorizon2003 profile image

mistyhorizon2003 8 years ago from Guernsey (Channel Islands)

Spooky stuff, and a rivetting read. Thanks. :)

G-Ma Johnson profile image

G-Ma Johnson 8 years ago from NW in the land of the Free

Omg is this really true?? do people really believe this stuff???Well is okay I guess but I have my doubts; though when the kids hear giggles and small scammpering feet...and sucking peppermint sticks...wasn't it?  Kids are special and I have much faith in their i do yours...which you don't even know you have...G-Ma :o) hugs & Peace,,,( yes i am following your every hub to get to know you)  OK?

profile image

jjrubio 8 years ago

I know you got this from the Travel Channel's Haunted Places..LOL

Just kidding!! I saw that story before. It is quite unusual huh, I have lots of weird stories of first hand accounts I have seen with my own eyes that had to do with dolls........Supernatural beings are there...whether we want to admit it or not. But your hub is good!

anonymous 8 years ago


ANONYMOUS#2 8 years ago


Peppermint Thrift profile image

Peppermint Thrift 8 years ago

No wonder Robert's pissed - they dressed him in a dumb sailor suit! I'd be mad too!

bgpappa profile image

bgpappa 8 years ago from Sacramento, California

Interesting stuff.

kyla 8 years ago

so cool

Frieda Babbley profile image

Frieda Babbley 7 years ago from Saint Louis, MO

Okay, this is not something to read very late at night in dim lighting.

Fabulous story and great information. Wow. And great writing, I couldn't stop reading. I like how the videos split this piece up. So have you seen him in real life, since you live in Florida?

St.James profile image

St.James 7 years ago from Lurking Around Florida Author

This is one of those stories that has fasinated me for over 20 years. I remember when my grandmother lived in Key West. She used to tell stories of much of the folklore there.

Frieda thanks for stopping by... I hope those heebee-geebees didn't interfer with your sleep. I love a good spooky story.

sweetoneangel profile image

sweetoneangel 7 years ago from New Jersey

Great story, I found it very interesting.

St.James profile image

St.James 7 years ago from Lurking Around Florida Author

Thank you SweetOneAngel.

KCC Big Country profile image

KCC Big Country 7 years ago from Central Texas

Great story St.James. These are the kinds of stories I enjoy reading. It gives out-of-towners like me a chance to learn about something I would ordinarily never be exposed to. Fascinating stuff. Robert's quite an oddity. Thanks for sharing!

St.James profile image

St.James 7 years ago from Lurking Around Florida Author

Thank you KCC,

The story of Robert and Eugene Otto is creepy, yet fascinating. I enjoy writing about the strange.

JamaGenee profile image

JamaGenee 7 years ago from Central Oklahoma

Creeeeepy....  For sure I'll be sleeping with the light on tonight!

Have you ever been to The Myrtles in Louisiana??

St.James profile image

St.James 7 years ago from Lurking Around Florida Author

Thank you JamaGenee!

I have not been to The Myrtles, but I have seen and read about it. There seems to be much evidence about it being haunted. That would be another spooky topic to write about

profile image

Spirit4112 7 years ago

...weird. Enjoyed the reading!

St.James profile image

St.James 7 years ago from Lurking Around Florida Author

Thank you Spirit... I don't think it would be interesting, unless it was weird.

Anna Marie Bowman profile image

Anna Marie Bowman 7 years ago from Florida

Great, now I have another reason to go down to Key West!!! I have to see Robert!!!

St.James profile image

St.James 7 years ago from Lurking Around Florida Author

I'm sure Robert would like to see you, too.

trish1048 profile image

trish1048 7 years ago

Loved this story. I too love ghost stories. My wish one day is to go touring up and down the east coast to visit these haunted places. I had an experience at my old house which I wrote about here on hp. Not as riveting as this one but scary just the same.

Thanks for sharing.

St.James profile image

St.James 7 years ago from Lurking Around Florida Author

Ya know Trish... really I am amazed at how many people have had an experience in some form of a haunting. Yet, so many believe this life time is it, and there is nothing afterwards.

trish1048 profile image

trish1048 7 years ago

Yes, I know. I don't believe this lifetime is it. I half believe in reincarnation because of my love of things Victorian, and my love of law, justice and the criminal element. I tend to think I lived in the late 1800s, or, I was perhaps an attorney or heaven forbid, a criminal in a past life LOL. It's just fascinating to me.

St.James profile image

St.James 7 years ago from Lurking Around Florida Author

In my next life I'll probably come back as a roll og toilet paper... Damn not much different then know (hahahaha)!

Seriously, I understand what you mean. To this day, for unexplained reasons, I hate thing around my neck, and even though I'm a strong swimmer, I have a fear of drowning and I really hate the feeling of being cold.... I gyess they all inner-twine.

rachaelc profile image

rachaelc 7 years ago from Austin

Great read! Gave me chills. The scariest things are the unexplainable. Thanks for sharing a fantastic hub!

St.James profile image

St.James 7 years ago from Lurking Around Florida Author

RachaelC... I'm happy to be able to give you goosebumps. What could scarier than a misbehaving, peppermint sucking, aging doll-child? Thank you for stopping by.

miguel 7 years ago

i like the name robert

alexa 7 years ago

great to read ,gave me all of chill .

St.James profile image

St.James 7 years ago from Lurking Around Florida Author

Thank you both Miguel, and Alexa

nrc 7 years ago

i realy believe that robert the haunted doll is real cause i went to that museum and saw robert and took a picture of him

then i saw his eyes moving like an angry look and id got realy got scared i told the maneger we went to see robert and he was gone so i sweard never to go back in there then when i got home it was sitting in my chair and i scream to death then i called the police and told them what happen and they didn't believe me and i was telling the true robert turned his head around and the police saw robert move and i screamed and a couple weeks later i told my parents could we move and they said yes so i turned 16 and i never saw robert again and i was so happy

St.James profile image

St.James 7 years ago from Lurking Around Florida Author

Thank you for sharing such an awesome first-hand Robert experience NRC!

workopppy man202 6 years ago

ive been there but robert wasn't out when i went :(

Melissa 6 years ago

I'm sooo scared rite know??lol

Bluedragon#13 6 years ago

This story gives me nightmares,

but its awesome.Scary stuff!!!I think its cool.

unity0111 6 years ago

This is like my doll. I have a sailer suit one. And I think its haunted it creeps me out

sxyunicorn 6 years ago

i personaly hate the little creeper; just rip it apart until there is nothing left of him

gigidy gigidy goo 5 years ago


Clare 5 years ago

wow this is a very interesting story i hope one day i can go see robert.

Samuel Darragh 5 years ago

wow! this story is very good i want to go see Robert, i think it would be cool if they made a video at night to really see if we could see him moving or getting up to his tricks. Thank you for the story =)

DHNC 5 years ago

creepy. i will never play with dolls now. Unfortunately theres a samurai doll in my bedroom.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.

    Click to Rate This Article