Visiting Carcassonne, France, with its hilltop fortifications: be impressed with the imagination of Viollet-le-Duc!
Absorbing historical vibrations
One of the most impressive sights in the South of France is the fortified City of Carcasonne (French: Cité de Carcasonne), in the Aude department; I shall hereafter refer to the French term. Set on a hilltop in this city in Aude department, much of what may be seen today is the work of architect Eugène Viollet-le-Duc (1814-1879).
Here we must pause. Because we need to be clear that this architect's concept of 'restoring' structures was not necessarily that they should revert to a former state in an historically accurate way.
In the mid 19th century some politicians wanted to demolish what was left of Carcasonne's Medieval fortifications. Oh, no you won't, said a lot of people. In due course the imaginative Viollet-le-Duc received the task of euphemistically 'restoring' these fortifications. When some people realized that Viollet-le-Duc was actually following his own inner, imaginative lights rather than necessarily trying to make them reflect accurately how the Cité de Carcasonne had looked in the Middle Ages, they questioned whether he should pursue this path. Oh, yes I will, was the response of the redoubtable Viollet-le-Duc; the task took years to accomplish, and consumed a large budget in doing so.
Anyway, the end result is very impressive: 52 towers — many of them with conical roofs — and two rings of fortifying walls. So admire the sight, as I did; but just remember, though, that it's the architect's imagination that you might be admiring, and not necessarily exactly what the Cité de Carcasonne looked like in the Middle Ages.
In cultivating Medieval architectural form, I suppose the mindset of Viollet-le-Duc represented the 19th century architectural equivalent to the popular 'Renaissance Fayre' movement, especially widespread in North America. In this sense: it is all very attractive and impressive to dress up in elaborately tailored Gothic apparel, but what you see is not necessarily representative of historical accuracy. (How far this analogy can be applied, I am not sure.)
Interestingly, Carcassonne did not become part of France until 1659, although there had been an intermittent presence of the French kingdom prior to that date. A Roman settlement existed on the site. Prior to 1209, the noble Trancavel family acted as vassals of the counts of Toulouse or Barcelona, until the vigorous — notorious? — Simon de Montfort (1160-1218) captured the city.
In the past century and a half, the main conflicts have seemed to revolve around ideas about architectural conservation. Or re-creation. Or historical fabrication. Or whatever you want to call it.
January 8, 2013
Also worth seeing
In Carcasonne itself, there are Carcassonne Cathedral (French: Cathédrale de Carcassonne ) and the Basilica of St. Nazaire and St. Celse (French: Basilique Saint-Nazaire-et-Saint-Celse ), both Medieval structures.
How to get there: United Airlines flies from New York Newark to Paris (Aéroport Paris-Charles de Gaulle ), where car rental is available; there are also domestic air services between Paris and Carcasonne airport (Aéroport de Carcassonne Salvaza ), where car rental is also available. The French railroad company SNCF maintains services from Paris to Carcassonne (Paris-Carcassonne: distance: 768 kilometres). Some facilities may be withdrawn, without notice. For up to date information, please check with the airline or your travel agent.
MJFenn is an independent travel writer based in Ontario, Canada.
Other of my hubpages may also be of interest
- Visiting the amazing, Medieval Saint Sernin Basilica, Toulouse, France: Medieval craftsmanship on a
- Visiting Lourdes, France, with its Medieval castle: Pyreneean sentinel perched on a rock
- Visiting Foix, France: with its Medieval castle of the Co-Princes of Andorra
- Visiting Perpignan, France: refracting past sovereignties
- Visiting the Longchamp Palace, Marseille, France: 19th century grandeur, with fine gardens
For your visit, these items may also be of interest
More by this Author
Step into the city of Cahors in the French department of Lot, and it is like a step back into the Middle Ages. The Valentré bridge has linked the two banks of the Lot River since the 14th century. It is...
Close to the Medieval Pont Valentré, Cahors Station building is a striking neo-Classical structure which dates from the early part of the 3rd French Republic.
In the centre of the village, a stone monument bears a plaque inscribed: 'BERGHOLZ GERMAN LUTHERAN SETTLEMENT FOUNDED OCT. 12 1843'. And German Americans, mainly Lutheran, have been there ever since. The monument...