Using Life Rewards in Dog Training
Polite sits at the door
Unlock a world of life rewards for your dog!
Thinking about using life rewards for your dog's training? Yes, it's true that food can be a great motivator for dogs, but there are countless other ways you can reinforce desired behaviors without a need to dig in your pockets for a treat. First off, let me clarify that I have nothing against using food for training. I use food extensively for training and behavior modification. There is nothing wrong with using food if you do so with knowledge. It's almost an art. The secret is being quick enough so your dog knows what you are rewarding for and not falling into the trap of bribing or you'll be stuck with a dog who will work only when food is in sight. While food is very helpful, especially in the initial stages of learning, there are other not-so-well-known rewards you can use once behaviors have established.
All you really need is some basic understanding of how dogs learn and a good grasp on what your dog truly likes. Once these basic concepts are well understood, a vast array of life rewards will unlock and you can use them to your advantage. Let's first take an insight into some basic learning theory, and then, let's take a look at what life rewards you can use for your dog.
An Insight into Dog Learning Theory
If you want your dog to perform certain behaviors, you will have to make sure he receives enough reinforcement so he'll want to repeat such behaviors over and over again and such behaviors become resistant to extinction. In positive reinforcement, we are adding a desired consequence so our dog will feel compelled to repeat certain behaviors again and again. So if you are giving your dog a cookie every time he sits and your dog loves cookies, your dog will learn to associate the act of sitting with the pleasant consequence--the cookie. This means that with time, he will be eager sit more and more because he is eager to get his reward (the cookie).
Rewards in Dog Training,To Each Their Own
Things though can get tricky at times. Your dog is not a robot who will always 100 percent respond in the same ways. Truth is, there may be times where there are distractions or more interesting things going on and he may not be able to respond. He may also be anxious, in fight or flight mode which shuts down his digestive system and the cookie is no longer appealing as a reward. Chances are,if he was trained for some time, he may still sit but he may refuse the cookie. On the other hand, there may be dogs who may care less about cookies. Some dogs may not find cookies that appealing to work for or they may be have tooth pain or simply they may be tired of eating cookies because you offer them every day. So in order to ensure that your dog stays motivated in training, you need to evaluate if rewards are being rewarding enough, if there are any competing sources of reinforcement around and if there are other rewards you can use to your advantage.
Pats on the head: loved or dreaded?
What can be rewarding for one dog, may not be rewarding for another. I remember a few years ago, I was watching a class in one of those pet stores that organize them in a small area. There was a small, very frightened dog who would not take treats like the other dogs. This dog was overwhelmed by the experience of being in such a small area with so many people and other dogs around. So the trainer told the owner to pet the dog on the head as a reward for each time the dog sat. Since the dog was reluctant to sit, the trainer instructed the owner to hold the dog by the collar while putting some pressure so the dog was forced to sit. The moment the dog sat, the owner was to praise and pat the dog on the head as a reward.
The trainer assumed that dog would like the pat on the head so much so to be willing to sit more and more. She probably had seen dogs who responded well to praise and head pats in the past and assumed it would work well for this dog as well. I watched the owner put pressure on the collar and the dog sat, and then the owner praised and pat the dog on the head. The dog tensed and lowered her head every time she pat her. I was not surprised. Not many dogs like pats on the head. Those who do have probably been trained to enjoy head pats though positive interactions and/or associations with food. This dog who was recently rescued simple seemed to dread them. Not only, the praise seemed to have become a signal that the dreaded head pat was about to come, so the dog tensed and cowered even before the owner pat her! It came as no surprise therefore that between the pressure and pats, the dog wasn't getting anywhere in the training. For a good part this was due to the dog feeling highly unsafe, and being unable to cognitively function-- and the pats certainly didn't do anything to make the dog feel safer and want to sit at all. So this is a case where we can demonstrate how praise and pats doesn't work for all dogs.
The Reward/Punishment Conundrum
Another example that comes to mind was a Lab who had a barking issue. The owner was told by a trainer to use a water gun to spray the dog every time he barked. The owner reported it didn't help at all, actually the barking seemed to have increased! When I got to the owner's home, I asked to see the water gun. As soon as she got it out from the drawer, even before she got to squirt it, the Lab was wagging his tail wildly and started barking in a high-pitched tone wit his front legs slightly bent. I understood from the dog's body language, and the tone of the bark, that the dog must have thought his owner was playing. When we discussed this, she recalled how in the past summer he would also bark when the sprinkler system was on, and more precisely, he would bark at it as he tried to catch the spurts of water. So in this case, he was getting reinforcement rather than punishment since every time he barked, he was squirted, something this dog enjoyed! The barking behavior therefore increased (a result of positive reinforcement) rather than decreasing (the goal of punishment).
The Importance of Recognizing Rewards
So every time we want to see behaviors increase, we must be aware of things our dogs find reinforcing. It's wrong to think that one reward works for all dogs! Rewards are not perceived the same way for each dog! In humans, some people would rather work over time to accumulate money to spend on a trip while others would rather invest it. Same applies with dogs, they have different preferences. And when behaviors fail to increase, we must wonder what exactly is happening and if what we think should be a reward is not. Once we understand what our dogs find rewarding, we can then apply those rewards to reinforce wanted behaviors. It's a shame that we have so many opportunities for rewarding dogs using life rewards, and don't utilize them fully. In the next paragraphs, let's see what life rewards are and how we can benefit from them.
Examples of life rewards in dog training
Think about things that make your perk up as his eyes brighten and tail wags in anticipation. Sure, you dog behaves this way every time you get the food bowl, but think more. There are many circumstances in life where dogs act enthusiastically. Dogs are masters in enjoying special moments in life. Take note of these moments and find what causes your dog to perk up in such a way. Is it the anticipation of going on a walk? Is your dog delighted to go in the yard? Is your dog thrilled by going on car rides? Does your dog love belly rubs and is always asking for more? Or does his face lighten up when you are ready to toss a ball? Keep track of all these life events that cause a surge of enthusiasm in your dog. Afterward, put them to your advantage!
What are life rewards? Life rewards are things or situations your dog looks forward to. This is a list of common life rewards many dogs like, but keep in mind what we talked about in the previous paragraphs. To each their own. Dogs are not all the same so keep in mind individual differences.
- Eating from his food bowl
- Stuffed Kongs, bully sticks, bones and other chew items.
- New toys or toys your dog hasn't seen for a while
- Tossing a ball or a Frisbee or anything else your dog love to catch
- Going out in the yard
- Getting his leash put on
- Going in the car
- Getting out the car (if you go to a park or some place nice)
- Getting rubbed where the dog likes it the most
- Having the water bowl filled on a hot day
- Getting attention from guests
- Playing with water
- Playing with another dog
- Chasing wildlife
- Hopping on furniture-- if you allow it
Once you have determined what your dog likes to do, you can use it to your advantage, by asking your dog to perform a behavior and immediately implementing what he likes. So if your dog loves going on walks, ask him for a sit before you put the leash on and then head out the door. If your dog loves the yard, ask him to sit before you open the door and send him out. If your dog loves to fetch, implement a sit/stay and right when he sits, toss the ball. If your dog loves car rides, ask for a sit before you allow him to get on the truck and once you arrive at your destination, if it's a place your dog is eager to go, ask him to make eye contact with you before being allowed to descend. Does your dog jump all over you when you grab his food bowl? Ask for a sit and reward him with the food bowl being put on the floor. You bought your dog a new toy? Hide it behind your back and call your dog. When he comes to you, toss the new toy to reward him for coming.
Soon, you'll discover how many opportunities you have to reinforce desired behaviors. The best part? Since your dog is often very enthusiastic about attaining these life rewards, by making him perform a behavior before being given access to such rewards, you'll be instilling more impulse control. A win-win situation for all!
Alexadry© all rights reserved, do not copy.
Examples of life rewards I use when training dogs at Rover's Ranch
For further reading
- Using Food for Dog Behavior Modification
Giving treats for dog behavior modification is an effective way to reinforce wanted behavior, change emotions, and on top of that, make important chemical changes happen in the dog's brain.
- Differential Reinforcement Schedules in Dog Training
How do you apply differential reinforcement schedules when you train your dog? This article will help you understand how they work and how you can bring training to a higher level.
- Is Your Dog Distracted Outside?
Many dogs are prone to getting very distracted when they are outside. Why does this happen and how can you help your dog focus when he's outside? Tips for getting your dog's attention.
- How to Stop your Dog from Bolting Out the Door
How to stop your dog from bolting out the door the moment you open it? This article and video will show you how to train polite door manners when you take your dog outside using the
- Using the Premack Principle in Dog Training
Learn how to train your dog by using the Premack principle. Reward calm behaviors with life rewards and train your dog to be a more manageable companion using a non-confrontational training method.
- The Four Quadrants of Dog Training
Training a dog can be easy, but understanding the whole dynamics behind it is a whole different story. Understanding learning theory will make you a better trainer and your dog a better trained dog.
- How to Train a Dog to Take Treats Gently
Interested in training your dog to take treats gently? This article will show why some dogs may be