I suppose that as the saying goes, each to his own, and so following this rule I would say that the Andalucian is great.
Having lived in Spain for many years, I have personally experienced this breed's noble temperament. It is a breed that is brave and doesn't (usually) spook. They are in general quite bomb proof and used in all the noisy ferias and festivities (of which there are many) in Spain.
Many small children ride this breed in their first lesson and eventhough they are quite big horses, they respond and listen to the children beautifully.