I don't agree with the 2 links to a single domain per hub rule but nevertheless I still play by the rules.
I'm trying to cooperate because I don't want my account banned. I've been a member for over 10 months and I've never done anything wrong on hubpages. No spam, nothing.
Anyway I submitted this hub once after I made some changes but was sent the above email.
Since you cant see it with the hubpages link, I dug up Googles cached result.
Please tell me what is wrong with the hub so I can make the necessary changes.
12 Month Internet Millionaire - Is It Good.
To me it has only 2 links to the domain (It originally had 3 like you would see here but I took out the one in the middle)
All the content is original - its a freakin' review for crying out loud...so I am allowed outbound links.
How is it overly promotional when I'm reviewing a book? Am I not supposed to talk about the book?
I have a feeling someone at hubpages doesn't like me!
Count again. (I'm looking at your actual Hub) More carefully if you still see 2.
Oh come on, kpfingaz! Fix the Hub and resubmit it for review.
Oh ok. My bad.
I did fix it. Maybe I didn't save it.
What about the other hub? I know it has 4 links in it. Two redirect to one domain and the other two redirect to two different domains...so three domains.
Is it because they are all Clickbank domains?
Whats the difference between Clickbank and Amazon?
Clickbank and Amazon are both single domains. Linking to different pages on a single domain still count towards your link limit.
I'm sorry you feel defensive. Please don't take the flagging personally. And remember, you came into the forums asking for other hubbers to help you figure out what was wrong with your hub, and they did so to the best of their ability. Nobody has personally attacked you, only offered opinions as to what might be violating the HP rules...
I've heard this refrain several times since I started working at HubPages, usually on the forums from someone who hasn't bothered to email me directly to ask what was wrong with the hub in question or request further clarification.
I do NOT have it in for anybody. I knew when I took the moderation job that it might make me unpopular with some users. Since I've been hired for a job that didn't exist before, and was covered by several other team members in their spare moments, there's a large amount of backlog--hubs that have been in violation for months, even up to a year or more, without being flagged. And of course, I come in and start digging through the backup, and I look like the bad guy, coming in and imposing the rules where things have been let slide.
What you need to realize is that, even if your hubs have been up for months without setting off a flag, that doesn't mean it doesn't break our rules, or that you shouldn't have to bring them into compliance when asked. Nor do a large number of flags in a short period of time mean that I "have it in for you," or "don't like you," as has been implied on this and several other threads. It simply means I'm working through the long queue of things that have piled up over the last few months, as HubPages rapidly expands.
Please also keep in mind that I look at hundreds of hubs a day, and I am human, so there are times when I may make a mistake, in which case I work to correct it as soon as it's brought to my attention.
kpfingas, I have the same problem. I wrote an original article (took me three hours) and had two links to a web page. Of course I got the Email. So I then asked about it in the forum under help heading. Several people kindly answered and said put the article on the forum so they could look at it. I did that. Now! my question, the answers and the article are gone from the forum. Total BS. Fred
Fred - You had 2 Hubs moderated. 1 doesn't exist anymore (you must have deleted it), and the other I restored and published. It looks like there were 3 links via the RSS capsule, but that's fine since you didn't link to the same domain in the body of your Hub.
I don't see any record in your user history of a forum post deleted - did you post it under a different account?
I think your problem might be that you are using Clickbank hoplinks.
Clickbank is considered a "bad neighborhood", and as I understand it the thinking is that links from HubPages to Clickbank will damage everybody's traffic in the long term, as search engines are the ones who decide where the "bad neighborhoods" are, and they don't discriminate between individual Hubbers. If some of us are linking out to Clickbank, all of us will suffer.
I suggest you send an email to the team and ask if this is the issue.
If it is, you will need to host the bulk of your review on another domain, and use your Hub to send traffic to it - for example, have a Hub that is a "reviewography", linking out to your reviews which are on article sites, a blog, or Google pages.
You can ensure people go there to buy through your link by adding a bonus, like the big guys do. It's recommended anyway, for best results as an affiliate.
Clickbank is not a "bad neighborhood".
A bad neighborhood on the Web is any website that uses any dirty tricks to try and increase their site's rankings or do harm to customers reading the site. These include:
installing viruses or malware
breaking other laws
These sites get delisted from Google. Clickbank does none of these things and is a PageRank 6.
Not only is Clickbank listed all over Google, but it also gets one of those prime listings at the top of the page that you see them do for major websites (including Hubpages) . It's that second set of 8 internal links directly underneath the index page link that indicates other pages. They don't do that for bad neighborhoods. They only do it for the top sites in the search engine.
You may not like personally care for Clickbank products or the methods that some folks use to promote them, but that does not make their site a bad neighborhood.
I have no personal opinion on Clickbank one way or another. I have seen Clickbank links specifically referred to on these Forums as an issue in terms of "overly promotional".
I will leave it to Jason or Maddie to articulate the official HubPages position on Clickbank, and whether hoplinks are accepted, prohibited or merely discouraged.
I'm sure they may well be an issue when it comes to "overly promotional", but it is frequently mentioned that they are a "bad neighborhood" and since they categorically are not a bad neighborhood as the SEs consider it, I finally decided to say something because this misinformation is repeated frequently.
Whether Hubpages considers them so is another matter, but hubs certainly wouldn't be penalized by SEs for links to such.
You sound like a know-it-all. I hope they don't make you a part of the team.
Don't worry...I'm leaving hubpages.
Clickbank is not considered a "bad neighborhood" - i.e. Hubbers can link to them.
Sometimes some Hubbers get a little too aggressive and put in too many links to clickbank (or other affiliate) offers; that's Overly Promotional and not allowed, naturally.
Go Maddy! People need to remember that a comment on their hub isn't a comment against them personally! And just because "I got away with it before" isnt an excuse in any aspect fo life!
Well done Maddie, I suppose we will all understand you have a difficult job to do and you have my support. Maybe you should ask for a pay rise.
What, what do you mean I am sucking up to her so she won't flag my hubs...oh come on now she won't know its me... what do you mean she can see my photo??? What photo.. hey wait a minute don't press that ....
I'm not prepared to argue our policy with you. Clickbank links all count as a single domain, as do TinyURL or any cloakers we might see. We do not follow affiliate links to see where they lead. It is enough that they are affiliate links. Can't you see how that would be construed as overly promotional?
We encourage the use of revenue capsules vs links, even to Ebay and Amazon sites. For example, a hub may just as well be penalized for an Ebay affiliate feed as for a bunch of Clickbank links spread throughout the text. The capsules are HubPages-sanctioned, designed specifically for that purpose. They are not disruptive or misleading the way that affiliate or SEO links may be.
PS> I apologize. Some confusion caused the original post by kpfingaz that is referred to in my last post to be deleted.
The amazon links are affiliate links. So are the ebay links - all affiliate links....commercial links.
Clickbank links are a single domain? They don't even go to Clickbank.
So can I link to my other Clickbank links using tinyurl?
Won't I still have 4 links on my hub leading to the same 4 domains?
As clearly stated in the email you've been sent, TinyURL and other cloakers count as "wildcards," adding to whatever other links you already have, so they'd still put you over the limit.
At this point, I don't think there's anything to be gained from continuing this conversation. The policies are clearly stated, and I've repeatedly clarified them here. Either revise your hubs to meet our standards, or don't be surprised when your account is banned. It's as simple as that. Thread closed.
by BenjaminB 10 years ago
I find it hilarious that Hubpages pushes the concept of helping new Hubbers yet my Hub which has had very good reception by the community has been flagged for being both overly promotional and substandard.I had 5 social bookmarking links,and 2 other links to free tools absolutely related to the...
by joniki 13 years ago
So I am away for a couple days and come home to hubpages for a nice Easter gift.EVERY ONE of my hubs has been flagged and unpublished. ALL OF THEM??Hubs that have been live for almost a year now with thousands of hits are suddenly against the rules?Was there a major rules change or is someone...
by StuartJ 14 years ago
I just had a hub called as "Overly Promotional". It's not a great Hub, but I can't see how it can possibly fit that description. It's here:http://hubpages.com/hub/super14It is about the Super 14 Rugby Competition and provides many links to sites with info about the teams involved -- links...
by taxman813777 11 years ago
I had 2 links in my hub pointing to different pages of my site and got the following message:Overly Promotional - Solely or excessively promotes another site(s), especially when Hub links all point to one site.This is my first hub and can't understand how many links to your own site you can put and...
by Mary Craig 8 years ago
Wouldn't it be nice if some explanation about the hub came with the above mentioned notices. All you get is the general notice that you hub is overly promotional or substandard and it needs to be fixed. If it is re-submitted and is not fixed properly you could be banned from...
by Peter V 9 years ago
Do you often flag content on HubPages?I see a few hubs everyday that are in English, but poorly written. I hate to flag a hub if someone is just trying to start on HP, but I don't like reading poorly written hubs! What are your thoughts?
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|