Asymmetric Information and Market for Lemons
Human beings are playing their life with the instrument of information. As a behavioral science, information on various aspects is very relevant for economic analysis to consider the role of information. Almost all of the foundational ideas of economics are based on a perfect market system, since economists believe that it could bring a better economic condition. Under a perfect competitive market system, it is assumed that, all the economic agents (consumers, sellers, producers etc) have perfect knowledge about their economic interventions. Thus perfect competitive market destroys all the possibilities for exploitations and unethical practices.
When we look at many economical issues, we can see that, each issue is covered with multilevel aspects. Thus the study of various aspects of an issue is significant. When social scientists analyze issues by looking from multilevel views, the information and its management can’t be neglected. Today each of the economic agents wants information about prices, quantity, quality, return from investment, profit and capital variations it is known to all that, there is no perfect competitive market in the world. So there arise the issue of asymmetric information and which causes for the unethical practices as well as exploitations in the economy. By meaning, asymmetric information refers to a condition of lacking of knowledge among different economic agents on a particular good or service. Sometimes, a particular party may have more knowledge than the opponent party while making transactions. So there is a possibility for exploitation and if so it will surely lead to the failure of market mechanism.
The Cost of Asymmetric Information
Unlike a perfectly competitive market, other types of markets are creating costs either directly or indirectly to some parties. Very often, here asymmetric information creates such exploitations. Some of the illustrations can be used to prove such type of market failure or generate costs.
The existence of asymmetric information in insurance market is very often. Insurance market mainly consists of two economic agents, insured persons and insurance companies. Insurance may be based on certain terms and conditions and which aims the protection of interests of both the agents. Here the most valuable information is the health condition of the people who are going to take insurance. But generally, insurance market experiences the prevalence of asymmetric information since the insured persons have more knowledge than the insurance company about the health status. Sometimes, fake medical documents may used to fool the insurance company. In fact, there exists higher probability for the market failure in the insurance market.
Another real case of the existence of asymmetric information is with the labor market. There will be employees and employers. Here the matter is associated with the productivity of workers. The level of production capacity will be different from worker to worker. But only each employee knows more about their own potentiality and productivity. So the availability of information regarding the workers; ability will be different to employees and employers. So the employment market or the recruitment process may become failure because of asymmetric information. In modern corporate world, employment market is dealing through employment agreements. Thus the prevalence of asymmetric information may lead the labor market into labor contract issues and other types of legal issues. The cost of it will be much higher especially to recruiting companies.
A common case of asymmetric information can see in general commodity market. There will be two agents, consumers and sellers. The availability of information regarding commodities such as quality, price etc may be different to each of these agents. Generally sellers have more knowledge about commodities than the consumers. Very often, consumers can evaluate the quality of commodity after consumption. At the same time producers or sellers know more about the commodity and its quality. This type of asymmetric information may create burden on consumers. In certain cases, producers may offer warranty or guarantee services for the commodities. But it can only seen in the commodities produced by reputed companies. From the view of consumers, there type of services enhances the confidence on the commodities. In fact, a considerable amount of asymmetric information can be seen in the general commodity market.
Here, we shall focus on the economics of information, and the theory of market for lemons.
Are secondhand commodity markets provides quality products?
Market for Lemons
The idea of market for lemons was developed by a Nobel Laureate in Economic Science, George Akerlof. It is based on the analysis of asymmetric information in the second hand goods market. He used secondhand market of cars. Suppose you bought a car by spending $24000. After two-three weeks you changed your decision with the first car. You have no complaint with the quality of the car. But now you just want to change the brand as a part of your prestige. Then you approached a secondhand market for selling your car. Here the market will be under the condition of asymmetric information. The seller (you) know the actual condition and quality of the car since the seller driven it for a while. The seller expects a price of at least $22000since it has good quality, not used more and the seller is also able to transfer the benefits of guarantee and warranties. Now analyzing the same situation from the view point of a buyer, they may think that it is a secondhand car so it quality can’t be assured as like a first quality car promises. So he will be ready to buy the car only at an average level of price in the secondhand markets. So he will be ready to buy it only at a price of $18000 to 20000. In the similar case, the prevalence of asymmetric information may lead to the underestimation of the price and quality of the commodities. Now the theory can also be analyzed based on a secondhand market where large number of commodities is exchanged.
Suppose there are two types of cars in a secondhand car market. One group is good quality cars and the other group- is b low quality cars. Since it is a secondhand market, people will be ready to pay only an average price for the cars. The prevalence of asymmetric information causes to the under estimation of good quality cars and over estimation of low quality cars. Further, the expectation of price for good quality cars will be higher. This situation will force the sellers of good quality cars to withdraw from the market. So supply of cars will be lower and the price will also go down since only low quality cars are available. Now some sellers who are selling comparatively good quality cars than the very low quality cars will also be encouraged to withdraw from the market. In fact, in this secondhand market, asymmetric information created every problem. The low quality cars destroyed the availability of good quality cars in the market.
Market for lemons is one of the examples of a market system where asymmetric information prevails. Simply, the asymmetry in the availability of information regarding a commodity among different agents creates many problems. As mentioned above, it may sometimes lead to the overvaluation or undervaluation of commodities. That means asymmetric information may lead to the failure of market mechanism.