ArtsAutosBooksBusinessEducationEntertainmentFamilyFashionFoodGamesGenderHealthHolidaysHomeHubPagesPersonal FinancePetsPoliticsReligionSportsTechnologyTravel
  • »
  • Education and Science»
  • History & Archaeology

Compare/Contrast of the American and French Revolutions

Updated on January 21, 2014

Bloodshed. Gunfire. Cries of victory. These are the themes that characterized the eighteenth century, which was described as “The Age of Revolution.” Two of the major revolutions of the eighteenth century, the French and American revolutions, are often compared because of their similar causes, a desire for independence and freedom, but these revolutions effects were entirely different; one was prosperous, the other chaotic.

King George III
King George III | Source

The causes of the American and French revolutions were similar in that both peoples desired freedom from an oppressive monarchy. By the 1700s, the colonies in North America still belonged to the British, but these colonies had grown completely independent, even from one another. However, they were not viewed as such by England. The British Monarchy cared for money, power, and politics, and the colonists could be used as means to those ends if necessary. Indeed, England confirmed these sentiments with a heavy taxation campaign that nearly crushed the Colonists, financially. Gathering together, the colonies sent proposals, letters, and delegates to the British Parliament to repeal the taxes, but the British government persisted. After all of the legislation that left the colonies poor and miserable, the final straw was the Tea Act, a political scheme to give the British-based East India Company a North American monopoly on tea. When the tea was shipped to the colonies, it remained, unloaded, in the harbor for twenty days, until rebels, disguised as Native Americans, boarded the ship and tossed all of the tea into the harbor, an event later deemed “The Boston Tea Party”. John Adams described the event as, “so bold, so daring, so firm, intrepid, and inflexible, and it must have so important consequences, and so lasting, that I can’t but consider it an Epocha in History.” 1 After the events of the Boston Tea Party, the British government cracked down more firmly than ever, sending British troops into private homes, closing the harbors, removing the right to vote for local officials. They attempted to isolate Boston, thinking it was center of dissent in the colonies, but the rest of the Colonists supported Massachusetts and would not bend. A local leader named Paul Revere began to gather the local militia, in order to display their willingness to fight the British troops if they were to fire upon the colonists. Eventually, the British did fire upon the colonists, the shot heard ‘round the world, and the war had begun.

Boston Tea Party
Boston Tea Party | Source
Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette
Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette | Source

Similarly, the French also experienced oppression from their monarchy in the form of taxes. Socially and economically, France was separated into three estates: the Clergy, the Nobility, and the Beugoise. The Clergy paid no taxes, the Nobility paid a tiny fraction of taxes, and the rest of the tax burden was left on the poorest members of French society. During this time period, King Louis XVI reigned. A weak and indecisive king, he was not respected by the people, and his wife, Marie Antoinette was not endeared either, as her gluttonous, lavish lifestyle was envied and despised by the poor. In France men named philosophes, Enlightenment thinkers like Voltaire and Diderot, wrote witty satires, exposing the ineptitude of the French government.2 These men were progressive thinkers, who often leaned toward democratic socialist ideals and removed religion in favor of reason. The philosophes, along with the American Revolution, gave the French proletariat an aching desire for the independence and equality revolutionary thinkers touted. During the American Revolution, Louis XVI sent heaps of monetary aid to Americans. Louis XVI also had also been engaged in several other wars, then, and by the time a severe famine occurred in 1788, France had spent all her money away. Louis XVI was forced to tax the Clergy and the Nobility. While voting on the new tax reforms, the Beugoise wanted the vote be counted individually, meaning each person in each estate received one vote. The other two estates, however, wanted the votes be counted by body, meaning the Clergy would receive one vote, the Nobility would receive one vote, and the Beougoise would receive one vote.3 Knowing that this unjust method would result in the Clergy and the Nobility coming out on top yet again, the Beougoise left the meeting. Later, when attempting to meet again, the Beougoise found their meeting room locked and therefore migrated to a tennis court to hold their meeting.4 There, they decided they were through with the French government, and called themselves the National Constituent Assembly, claiming they would be the provisional government until the French people could form an official constitution. In an attempt to disband the dissent in the Third Estate, Louis the XVI pretended to agree with their ideas for reform, all the while setting up troops around the perimeter of Paris.5 Tension began to build. Eventually, Louis showed his true colors when he dismissed a beloved finance minister who was pro-reform. Immediately, riots broke out in the Paris streets, and people began to search for weapons to fight off the French soldiers. Richard Thames says in his book The French Revolution,“...a cry went up: “To the Bastille!” This ugly old fortress had once been a prison for political offenders. Now it contained only seven prisoners. But it was a symbol of royal power. It was stormed and taken, to the delight of the mob.”6 The mob took over the government of Paris within days, and cities and villages all over France followed suit. The French Revolution, like the American, was incited by a government who cared more for the nobility than the working class, and who paid for its escapades with its people’s money. However, the revolution had only just begun, its effects would be even more radical!

Tennis Court Oath
Tennis Court Oath | Source

After the bloodshed of the Revolutionary War, America was formed through the Articles of the Confederation and later the Constitution, and the effects were astounding as America grew and expanded, but not without consequences with the Native Americans. Once America was established as its own, independent nation state, it no longer needed to appeal to Britain’s political micromanagement in their relationships with the Native Americans. While some Native Americans managed to integrate into society, the vast majority were forcibly moved into the Midwest by President Andrew Jackson. African-american slavery also thrived, creating tension between pro and anti slavery states, which would escalate into the Civil War years later. Despite these black spots in American history, the decades after the Revolution were prosperous. Americans gained a substantial amount of land from the French during the Louisiana Purchase, and they also continued to expand West for many years. Quickly, America became one of the richest nations in the world. The Civil War united the states and rid the country of the strict dividing line creating during the Missouri Compromise, an imaginary, legislative line dividing slave states from non slave states.7 After the abolition of slavery, America truly fulfilled the promise of equality detailed in the Constitution. The United States continued to be a beacon of justice and a major world power into the twenty first century.

Louisiana Purchase
Louisiana Purchase | Source
Maximillien Robspierre
Maximillien Robspierre | Source

In France, the effects of the revolution were and new government was quickly taken over by radical revolutionists called Jacobins, who sought to completely overthrow the economic, religious, and social orders in France. They created a new calendar, the first day of the year being the anniversary of the Revolution, and attempted to purge Christianity from society. Along with these reforms came the ghastly Committee for Public Safety, a sham whose job was to murder anyone suspected of supporting anti-revolutionary ideals. This killing spree was known as “The Reign of Terror.” Heading this “committee” was Maximillion Robespierre, who was eventually executed by the French people. 8His death rallied the Thermidorian Reaction, a movement by the French citizenry back to what the Revolution initially stood for: freedom and prosperity. Unfortunately, the French people went a bit too far back, allowing Napoleon Bonaparte to take the French, political stage. Napoleon called himself the “Emperor of France,” a sneaky loophole as the French people said they would never have another king. Involving France in the Napoleonic Wars, Bonaparte reverted France back to an imperialist monarchy. However, after several failed attempts, France would one day fight a revolution that would stick, and the great country remains a democratic world power today.

The American and French Revolutions were similar in their causes: an oppressive government and an inherent goal of freedom and independence. However, their effects differed greatly. Where America continued to prosper, France’s post-revolution years were chaotic and bloody. Studying these two revolutions can help us identify the victories and failings of past revolutionaries toward their oppressive situations.

Emperor Napoleon
Emperor Napoleon | Source

The causes of the American and French revolutions were similar in that both peoples desired freedom from an oppressive monarchy. By the 1700s, the colonies in North America still belonged to the British, but these colonies had grown completely independent, even from one another. However, they were not viewed as such by England. The British Monarchy cared for money, power, and politics, and the colonists could be used as means to those ends if necessary. Indeed, England confirmed these sentiments with a heavy taxation campaign that nearly crushed the Colonists, financially. Gathering together, the colonies sent proposals, letters, and delegates to the British Parliament to repeal the taxes, but the British government persisted. After all of the legislation that left the colonies poor and miserable, the final straw was the Tea Act, a political scheme to give the British-based East India Company a North American monopoly on tea. When the tea was shipped to the colonies, it remained, unloaded, in the harbor for twenty days, until rebels, disguised as Native Americans, boarded the ship and tossed all of the tea into the harbor, an event later deemed “The Boston Tea Party”. John Adams described the event as, “so bold, so daring, so firm, intrepid, and inflexible, and it must have so important consequences, and so lasting, that I can’t but consider it an Epocha in History.” 1 After the events of the Boston Tea Party, the British government cracked down more firmly than ever, sending British troops into private homes, closing the harbors, removing the right to vote for local officials. They attempted to isolate Boston, thinking it was center of dissent in the colonies, but the rest of the Colonists supported Massachusetts and would not bend. A local leader named Paul Revere began to gather the local militia, in order to display their willingness to fight the British troops if they were to fire upon the colonists. Eventually, the British did fire upon the colonists, the shot heard ‘round the world, and the war had begun.

Boston Tea Party
Boston Tea Party | Source
Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette
Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette

Similarly, the French also experienced oppression from their monarchy in the form of taxes. Socially and economically, France was separated into three estates: the Clergy, the Nobility, and the Beugoise. The Clergy paid no taxes, the Nobility paid a tiny fraction of taxes, and the rest of the tax burden was left on the poorest members of French society. During this time period, King Louis XVI reigned. A weak and indecisive king, he was not respected by the people, and his wife, Marie Antoinette was not endeared either, as her gluttonous, lavish lifestyle was envied and despised by the poor. In France men named philosophes, Enlightenment thinkers like Voltaire and Diderot, wrote witty satires, exposing the ineptitude of the French government.2 These men were progressive thinkers, who often leaned toward democratic socialist ideals and removed religion in favor of reason. The philosophes, along with the American Revolution, gave the French proletariat an aching desire for the independence and equality revolutionary thinkers touted. During the American Revolution, Louis XVI sent heaps of monetary aid to Americans. Louis XVI also had also been engaged in several other wars, then, and by the time a severe famine occurred in 1788, France had spent all her money away. Louis XVI was forced to tax the Clergy and the Nobility. While voting on the new tax reforms, the Beugoise wanted the vote be counted individually, meaning each person in each estate received one vote. The other two estates, however, wanted the votes be counted by body, meaning the Clergy would receive one vote, the Nobility would receive one vote, and the Beougoise would receive one vote.3 Knowing that this unjust method would result in the Clergy and the Nobility coming out on top yet again, the Beougoise left the meeting. Later, when attempting to meet again, the Beougoise found their meeting room locked and therefore migrated to a tennis court to hold their meeting.4 There, they decided they were through with the French government, and called themselves the National Constituent Assembly, claiming they would be the provisional government until the French people could form an official constitution. In an attempt to disband the dissent in the Third Estate, Louis the XVI pretended to agree with their ideas for reform, all the while setting up troops around the perimeter of Paris.5 Tension began to build. Eventually, Louis showed his true colors when he dismissed a beloved finance minister who was pro-reform. Immediately, riots broke out in the Paris streets, and people began to search for weapons to fight off the French soldiers. Richard Thames says in his book The French Revolution,“...a cry went up: “To the Bastille!” This ugly old fortress had once been a prison for political offenders. Now it contained only seven prisoners. But it was a symbol of royal power. It was stormed and taken, to the delight of the mob.”6 The mob took over the government of Paris within days, and cities and villages all over France followed suit. The French Revolution, like the American, was incited by a government who cared more for the nobility than the working class, and who paid for its escapades with its people’s money. However, the revolution had only just begun, its effects would be even more radical!

After the bloodshed of the Revolutionary War, America was formed through the Articles of the Confederation and later the Constitution, and the effects were astounding as America grew and expanded, but not without consequences with the Native Americans. Once America was established as its own, independent nation state, it no longer needed to appeal to Britain’s political micromanagement in their relationships with the Native Americans. While some Native Americans managed to integrate into society, the vast majority were forcibly moved into the Midwest by President Andrew Jackson. African-american slavery also thrived, creating tension between pro and anti slavery states, which would escalate into the Civil War years later. Despite these black spots in American history, the decades after the Revolution were prosperous. Americans gained a substantial amount of land from the French during the Louisiana Purchase, and they also continued to expand West for many years. Quickly, America became one of the richest nations in the world. The Civil War united the states and rid the country of the strict dividing line creating during the Missouri Compromise, an imaginary, legislative line dividing slave states from non slave states.7 After the abolition of slavery, America truly fulfilled the promise of equality detailed in the Constitution. The United States continued to be a beacon of justice and a major world power into the twenty first century.

Map of the Louisiana Purchase
Map of the Louisiana Purchase | Source
Maximillien Robspierre, leader of the Jacobins.
Maximillien Robspierre, leader of the Jacobins. | Source

In France, the effects of the revolution were and new government was quickly taken over by radical revolutionists called Jacobins, who sought to completely overthrow the economic, religious, and social orders in France. They created a new calendar, the first day of the year being the anniversary of the Revolution, and attempted to purge Christianity from society. Along with these reforms came the ghastly Committee for Public Safety, a sham whose job was to murder anyone suspected of supporting anti-revolutionary ideals. This killing spree was known as “The Reign of Terror.” Heading this “committee” was Maximillion Robespierre, who was eventually executed by the French people. 8His death rallied the Thermidorian Reaction, a movement by the French citizenry back to what the Revolution initially stood for: freedom and prosperity. Unfortunately, the French people went a bit too far back, allowing Napoleon Bonaparte to take the French, political stage. Napoleon called himself the “Emperor of France,” a sneaky loophole as the French people said they would never have another king. Involving France in the Napoleonic Wars, Bonaparte reverted France back to an imperialist monarchy. However, after several failed attempts, France would one day fight a revolution that would stick, and the great country remains a democratic world power today.

The American and French Revolutions were similar in their causes: an oppressive government and an inherent goal of freedom and independence. However, their effects differed greatly. Where America continued to prosper, France’s post-revolution years were chaotic and bloody. Studying these two revolutions can help us identify the victories and failings of past revolutionaries toward their oppressive situations.

Emperor Napoleon
Emperor Napoleon | Source

Comments

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    • profile image

      Howard Schneider 3 years ago from Parsippany, New Jersey

      This Hub is a wonderful comparative analysis of the two predominant revolutions of the 18th century. Very thorough, Mason. Thumbs up.

    • kenneth avery profile image

      Kenneth Avery 3 years ago from Hamilton, Alabama

      Mason,

      This hub was:

      Intelligently-written; Presented professionally and with such passion. I voted up and away. You deserved it.

      You are so good. I urge you to keep writing no matter what.

      And never quit. For any reason or anyone. Deal?

      I cordially-invite you to check my hubs and be one of my followers.

      I would love it.

      Sincerely,

      Kenneth/ from northwest Alabama

    • profile image

      abraham lincon 3 years ago

      good

    Click to Rate This Article