The Effects Of Aggression On Sports Performance
How Does Aggression Affect Sports Performance?
On a regular basis, when we watch or take part in sports we're exposed to acts of aggression. Whether it's the young soccer player who decides to make a vicious tackle against the defender whose play have been frustrating him all game, or watching archive coverage of the legendary Lawrence Taylor sacking another Quarterback. Sport is full of acts of aggression.
This article hopes to provide insights into the effects of aggression on sporting performance by providing an insight into the subject through sports psychology, as well as addressing the effect that an audience can have on performance in terms of whether a home court, field or stadium can make a noticeable difference to team or individual performances.
What Is Aggression? (Gill 1986)
is a behaviour
involves causing injury or harm
is directed towards a human being
The Effect Of Aggression On Performance
Whilst in many sports the use of legitimate force is within the rules of the game. This assertiveness is required in many sports where a degree of physicality is required for success. Whether in ice hockey or soccer, the hustle and bustle between players will always remain a key part of the sport's nature.
As frustration on field (or off) often leads to hostile aggression this can heighten levels of physical arousal which can be productive to improved performance in some sports or take them out of their zone of optimum functioning for arousal.
Is the below video an example of aggressive play by Nottingham Forest legend Stuart Pearce?
Aggression Or Intent? Stuart Pearce
Were Stuart Pearce's Challenges Aggressive Behaviour?
What do you think? Were Stuart Pearce's Challenges Aggressive Behaviour?
Situational Factors Which Influence Sporting Aggression
In terms of sport-specific aggressive behaviour a large proportion of the research carried out has been related to situation specific factors. (Cox 1998)
- Environmental temperature
- Perception of a victim's intent
- Fear of retaliation
- Structure of the game
Cycling On A Hot Day
The Effect Of Environmental Temperature On Aggression
We can all feel a degree of frustration when the mercury rises significantly as conditions become uncomfortable. Baron and Bell (1976) found that by taking a cooling drink reduced the impact of high ambient temperatures on aggression levels.
In laboratory based experiments the effect of environmental temperature has been found to be curvilinear with performance levels increasing to an optimum point before a visible decrease in performance as shown below.
The Relationship Between Temperature And Aggression
Perception Of A Victim's Intent In Sport
As a general rule: If an athlete perceives their opponents intent is to cause harm or injury they are more inclined to act with aggression towards their opponent. If a rugby player thinks that their opponents rough and overly physical play is intended towards causing harm to them their response will potentially be influenced by their level of a aggression
Fear Of Retaliation. Aggression and Counter-Aggression
If you're going to pick on an opposing player to take out some aggression on it usually makes sense not to target their biggest, toughest, hard as nails defender known as "The Enforcer" or something of a similarly authoritative nature.
Fear of retaliation can inhibit aggression shown towards an opponent out of both fear andf respect. Players are often less likely to indulge in unsportsworthy play if they're likely to get exactly the same back in return. Aggression can lead to counter-aggression. Some individuals thrive off this challenge- Others choose to avoid it completely.
Fear Of Retaliation In Soccer
Game Structure In Sports
There have been a number of game related variables which highlight aggression within sports game structure.
- Points Differentials
As differences between playing teams scores increases, so does the build up of frustration that can lead to aggression. When scores have been tied aggression is most often minimally shown between competing teams. Sport's rules for aggressive play (such as the red card in soccer for reckless behaviour) indicate that players and coaches will do their utmost to control frustration and potential aggressive behaviours.
- Home or Away
Is home court really an advantage? It has been noted that professional soccer teams have a tendency to show more aggression when playing away. However for Ice Hockey aggression has be shown to have little difference between home and away teams. There are a number of factors affecting home court advantage in sports which are highlighted further down the page.
- Participation outcome
As shown in the frustration aggression theory. Losing teams are seen to have signifcently heightened aggression levels when compared to their winning opponents.
- League position
Generally the lower a team falls in a league standing point the greater the level of aggression shown. Just imagine the aggression levels at Derby County when they achieved the lowest ever points score in a Premiership Football season back in 2007/2008
- Periods of sporting play
In multiple-period play sports it has been shown that incidence of aggressive behaviour increases over the course of the game. Whilst the lowest number of incidents occur in the first period.
Strategies To Reduce Aggression In Sports
If coaches, parents, managers and athletes want to control aggression it is within their power to do so. Unfortunately not all aggression is discouraged. In some environments coaches have been known to applaud aggressive rule breaking behaviour in the belief it increases ticket sales and adds an element of fear to opposing teams who make the visit. Sadly such behaviour at a high level has a tendency to filter down to lower levels and to youth development. Poor behaviour by a sporting icon breeds a culture of aggression.
Controlling And Reducing Athlete Aggression
It is vital for coaches, managers, parents and athletes to consider the following best practices:
- Non-aggressive behaviour models should be reinforced to the athlete.
- Severe penalties should be enforced for aggressive behaviour from coaches, parents, managers and all athletes.
- Positive reinforcements of non-aggressive behaviours should be administered to encourage future behaviours.
- Referees and coaches should be encouraged to attend workshops on aggression management for the implementation of long term best practice.
Controlling And Reducing Spectator Aggression
There are a number of ways rowdy and aggressive behaviour by spectators can be curtailed at sporting events which can be considered.
- Sporting events to be promoted as family occasions.
- The media should not glamorize aggression in sports.
- The media should be held responsible in the case of developing a degree of friction and hatred between teams and opposing fans.
- Spectator aggression must incorporate suitable punishments which reflect the magnitude of the crime.
- The sale of alcohol at events should be limited
Home Stadium Advantage
Home Game Win %
Home Court Advantage In Sports
The table right showcases home court win percentages across major US sporting leagues with Major League Baseball figures since 1903 although NFL figures are only from 1966 and require further year on year analysis to clarify strength.
Arguably the most plausible explanation for the home court advantage in sports has to be that of a supportive audience. Could a supportive audience energise the home team? Or inhibit the abilities of the away team?
Baron, R. A., Bell, P. A (1976), Aggression and heat: the influence of ambient temperature, negative effect, and a cooling drink on physical aggression. J Pers Soc Psychol. 33(3):245-55.
Cox, R. H., (1998) Sport Psychology: Concepts and applications, 4th ed, Boston MA: McGraw-Hill.
Gill, D.L., (1986) Psychological dynamics of sport, Champaign IL, Human Kinetics
Moscowitz, T. J., Wertheim J, L., (2011). Scorecasting: The Hidden Influences Behind How Sports Are Played and Games Are Won. Crown Archetype