ArtsAutosBooksBusinessEducationEntertainmentFamilyFashionFoodGamesGenderHealthHolidaysHomeHubPagesPersonal FinancePetsPoliticsReligionSportsTechnologyTravel
  • »
  • Education and Science»
  • Sociology & Anthropology

Hans Christian Andersen: The Little Mermaid

Updated on February 13, 2017
TolovajWordsmith profile image

Tolovaj is a small publishing house specializing in literature for children. The theory of fairytales is one of our passions.

Posters of Little Mermaid are still in demand

E. S. Hardy: The Little Mermaid
E. S. Hardy: The Little Mermaid

Hans Christian Andersen and Original Little Mermaid

The Little Mermaid is one of the most popular fairy tales in the world, and very likely the most known story for children with unhappy ending. It actually depends which version are you familiar with. Or what do you consider as a happy ending. Today majority of American readers or viewers know her as Ariel, the name given by Disney Company.

Disney changed a very personal narration by Hans Christian Andersen into family fun with some classic romantic elements. They made a great job, but the depth and occasional darkness of original Little Mermaid was replaced with showy music scores and predictable outcome.

Ops, did I use the word original? We have to say few words about that term too.

(Intro image: Evelyn Stuart Hardy, all used images are in public domain)

From Folklore to Pop Culture

Undine by Arthur Rackham
Undine by Arthur Rackham

Disney designed Ariel after Andersen's tale, but Danish writer was also inspired by today less known novella by Friedrich de la Motte Fouque. This German romance was one of the most popular stories in 19th century and although today not considered as material for children George MacDonald once used it for his famous definition of fairy tale.

But Undine is far from being an original work of art as well. La Motte Fouque's most famous writing is actually rewritten legend about Melusine, a water sprite who married a knight on condition he doesn't see her on particular day in the week (Saturday). What was her secret? She changed her shape on this day to be a mermaid. This so called shapeshifting was very popular in folk tales and legends (just think about werewolves, frogs turning to princes, the tale about The Belle and The Beast, ...) and is still very popular in today's culture (think about vampire sagas).

So here we are: a traditional tale, known in many variations, written as a classic love story, and than reshaped as a story for kids with strong personal involvement. I believe the secret of success of The Little Mermaid lies right here. Andersen wrote it in very special state of mind. It's actually his personal story of unrequited love. It became an endless source of guesswork for historians and an immense inspiration for generations of artists.

The Little Mermaid by Hans Christian Andersen in Book

Although you may know the story from the adaptation, Andersen's fairy tale offers much more than Disney on several artistic, dramatic and emotional levels. If we limit the comparison to only the main goal of the major character, we can note a Little Mermaid is on the quest for eternal soul while Ariel is just looking for a husband. Or: one is a tragic romance and the other kind of reality show.

The Little Mermaid (Illustrated)
The Little Mermaid (Illustrated)

This edition is illustrated by some of the greatest names in the history of books for children: Anne Anderson, Harry Clarke, Arthur Rackham and others offer unique look into imaginary world of the greatest storyteller.

 

Why is the character of little mermaid so special?

She is one of the most memorable characters in the world literature and definitely not a stereotypical lady in trouble waiting for the prince on the wild horse. On contrary - she is the one who saves him, despite the fact he marries other woman.

This is even more important if we think how many stereotypes are present about girls and women in the folklore.

Andersen's mermaid is brave and curious, what gives her a very special place on the list of best tales for kids ever.

To be honest ...

Image by Henry Justice Ford
Image by Henry Justice Ford

I already mentioned Little Mermaid is courageous, brave and inquisitive, what is not so often in western folklore. But on the other side, just to be honest, cautionary tales, like The Little Red Cap or The Bluebeard share at least some similar characteristics with her. Especially curiosity is often portrayed as a rich source of all sorts of danger.

It's interesting to note how mermaids changed their role in the history. They were at first praised for their role in nature (bringing fertility to the soil near water), but later more and more used by storytellers to scare children from the rivers and similar bodies of water. We all know water as one of the biggest risks, not just because of possibility of drowning, but also because different predators love to hide near water waiting for their pray.

Illustration by Anne Anderson
Illustration by Anne Anderson

Similarities between H. C. Andersen and Little Mermaid

There is well developed theory about this fairy tale actually being a love letter of author to his friend who got married (it was written around the time of wedding). In this article we'll try to focus only on similarities of the characters: the fictional mermaid and author himself:

1. Both are fascinated with the world up there. Although they are both of royal origins (Andersen believed he was illegitimate son of a king), they craved to become important in different, more glamorous world which is apparently reserved for upper class.

2. Both of them experienced the lost of voice. We know how Andersen entered the world of theater thanks to his beautiful tenor just to be excluded when his voice changed (puberty). As an already established writer he didn't care about the voice anymore, but he was still very concerned about his writing as an ultimate communicating tool. He was aware of his problems with grammar (these persisted to the very end of his life) and still afraid of being abandoned.

We can also add his problems with expression of his feeling to people he loved and we can clearly see how little mermaid resembles him.

3. There is a very touching part of the story where we find out how prince treats his friend. He likes her and even let her to sleep in front of the doors of his bedroom. This looks more like a treatment for a pet, not a friend, and it certainly echoes the way how Andersen himself felt on many occasion when he was included in high society, but always left somewhere at the doors.

4. The mermaid is dreaming about immortality just like Andersen himself. Death, religion and the quest for immortal soul were important part of Andersen's life, what is obvious frm his diaries.

5. For the final touch we can extrapolate similarities to another important writer who was also very popular but always on the margins of society - Oscar Wilde used Andersen's tale about the mermaid as inspiration for his Fisherman and the Soul, where he made interesting twist. Instead of using a love story as a starting point in quest for soul we learn about love being the reason for lost soul.

Do you believe the title character was actually author himself?

See results

Controversy

It seems this lovely fairy tale is not only inspirational, it is endless source of controversies as well. When Andersen died, Disney took over. In the case of Ariel (with sequels) we can find many controversies, but the main problem with the movie adaptation is probably how the main character is not satisfied with her friends, her relatives and her body. She wants to become the part of very different world (which is completely unknown to her) and she is willing to sacrifice her major talents for that.

She also without any hesitation leaves behind her old life, just like Andersen left when he moved from Odesse do Copenhagen.

On the other side prince judges her only by her look, they never talk, what is definitely not the best message for young girls and boys. They didn't stop here. Disney Company even remodeled the main villain - Ursula - to became more fashionable: slim.

Little Mermaid on video

My resources and further readings

Fairy tale can be simple, but when you start to explore them, they can easily turn into very complex projects. Here are only few of my resources and some suggestion on more info for everybody who is interested in H. c. Andersen and his work

What is your opinion about the original Little Mermaid?

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    • TolovajWordsmith profile image
      Author

      Tolovaj Publishing House 2 years ago from Ljubljana

      Sure he was, pstraubie48. From his correspondence it's very clear he wrote is as kind of letter to his unrequited love. But he also wanted to make it attractive for younger audience and with then very popular Undine in mind (he was not happy with it's ending), he wanted to make it more fairy-tale like. This ambivalence is one of Andersen's most powerful charms - he said several times how he always write for kids with parents being present in the same room. He didn't want to make the bored - and he surely succeeded. Thanks for stopping by!

    • pstraubie48 profile image

      Patricia Scott 2 years ago from sunny Florida

      Perhaps Hans was writing the story for an adult audience ??? Could that be? I will freely admit that I am charmed by the modern day Ariel.

      Angels are on the way to you this evening. ps

    • TolovajWordsmith profile image
      Author

      Tolovaj Publishing House 2 years ago from Ljubljana

      I agree with you, Nadine May, Disney made many changes to 'originals' and the story too often became on-dimensional, but we have to admit they are masters of show business and they promoted many classics this way too. Thanks for stopping by!

    • Nadine May profile image

      Nadine May 2 years ago from Cape Town, Western Cape, South Africa

      I definitely favor anything written by Hans Christian Andersen over Disney's version any day, but that does not mean that I do not like some of the Disney films. If an original fairytale is being re-edited for a commercial purpose, then the depth of the tale is often lost. That is just my opinion.

    • TolovajWordsmith profile image
      Author

      Tolovaj Publishing House 2 years ago from Ljubljana

      It's good approach too, peachpurple:) Well, I must say, since I started to explore backgrounds of the stories, I have even more fun!

    • peachpurple profile image

      peachy 2 years ago from Home Sweet Home

      I only watch the mermaid cartoon, never thought deeper, tq

    • TolovajWordsmith profile image
      Author

      Tolovaj Publishing House 2 years ago from Ljubljana

      You are right, TonyPayne, stories are often twisted, and I like to make a step further - trying to find how these changes reflect our society. I also believe majority of fairy people is based on real people or other living beings, just distorted with time, perception, etc. Thanks for stopping by!

    • TonyPayne profile image

      Tony Payne 2 years ago from Southampton, UK

      It is amazing how stories can be twisted, especially when they are modernized and turned into movies.

      So many stories like this date back hundreds of years, if not thousands of years. I sometimes wonder if Gnomes, Pixies, Elves and other Fairy folk are based on creatures that actually existed once upon a time.

    • TolovajWordsmith profile image
      Author

      Tolovaj Publishing House 3 years ago from Ljubljana

      @Richard1988: Isn't interesting how can be the same story presented differently?

    • Richard1988 profile image

      Richard 3 years ago from Hampshire - England

      I know the book better than the film - I know they have very different endings though!

    • TolovajWordsmith profile image
      Author

      Tolovaj Publishing House 3 years ago from Ljubljana

      @asereht1970: Books are in general better, but sometimes a movie makes the best promotion of the book.

    • WriterJanis2 profile image

      WriterJanis2 3 years ago

      I prefer the Disney version because I'm a big Disney fan and I love the music from the movie.

    • asereht1970 profile image

      asereht1970 3 years ago

      One of my favorite fairy tales by Hans Christian Andersen. I love the book more than the film.

    • TolovajWordsmith profile image
      Author

      Tolovaj Publishing House 3 years ago from Ljubljana

      @WriterJanis2: I am fine with Disney too, but still prefer Andersen.

    • TolovajWordsmith profile image
      Author

      Tolovaj Publishing House 3 years ago from Ljubljana

      @Lorelei Cohen: Thanks for this kind words!

    • Lorelei Cohen profile image

      Lorelei Cohen 3 years ago from Canada

      I love all your articles. Each is so attractively displayed and so thought provoking. You never disappoint me.