Marco Polo Truth or Lies
The History of Marco Polo and his World Travels
I'm not going to go into details about what Marco saw or where he went - precisely because the book is so well known, even today in 2011.
Anyone can read his book - there are links to the book on Gutenberg in the resources section.
Marco Polo did not draw any maps and he used only the time taken to travel as his measurements, He did not do any actual measurements or even make any estimates for distances.
This lens is made purely to debate whether or not you think Marco Polo told the truth, or whether he lied (or exaggerated) about his travels.
Image Source - Italian stamp of Marco Polo
So what did Marco leave out?
Some experts say that Marco Polo never travelled all the way to China, that those stories he wrote about, are second and third hand stories gleaned from other travellers.
In which case - what did he do and where did he go for those 25 missing years? Is it possible that he (and his father and uncle) were in a jail cell somewhere with other people who told him these stories. When he got back to Venice, he is repeated these stories from memory and claimed them to be his own travels? That is one possible scenario.
Other experts say that he did go to China because some of the details are incredibly accurate and he can only have known about them because he saw them for himself.
Archaeologists say he missed out a lot of details about Chinese life that should have been commented on. Details such as the use of chopsticks, women having bound feet, the Great Wall and drinking green tea. None of those details are mentioned whatsoever. Why not?
But then Marco Polo also says at the end of the book - I have not written half of what I have seen and heard - so maybe those details were just some of what he chose not to write about.
Then there are those who say that Marco himself spoke the plain unvarnished truth, and his cell mate Rustichello - who was a writer and a romantic at heart, and who was also prone to exaggeration - maybe Rustichello exaggerated these claims, and not Marco himself?
Anyway, the question is - What do YOU believe? As stated in the book - did Marco Polo tell the truth or was he a liar?
Image source - Marco Polo - Wikipedia Commons license
Books by and about Marco Polo
Before we go any further....
Further down this lens I will be offering information for both sides of the debate. So before we get into that - I want to know what you think right now,
Do you think he was telling the truth and writing down mostly everything he personally saw?
Or do you think Marco was telling lies, and writing down other peoples stories?
Was Marco Polo telling the truth or telling a pack of lies?
Yes, he was telling the truth
Did Marco Polo really go to China?
Image Source - Goodreads
F. Wood's Book - Did Marco Polo Go To China?
A Critical Appraisal by I. de Rachewiltz
In this book, first published in 1995, Frances Woods states her belief (theory) that Marco Polo most likely did NOT go to China, and indeed, probably never even traveled past Constantinople. She states her reasons for making this claim.
Dr Igor de Rachewiltz is a history professor at the Australian National University in Canberra, Australia. He refuted Ms Woods book by writing an article in defence of Marco Polo saying that Yes Marco Polo did go to China and lists reasons as to how and why certain omissions in Marco's book are NOT lies. You will have to read the link to find out what he said.
Mike Yamashita also went to China (in 2004) to investigate and to find out if Marco really did go to China and just how these "important omissions" could have occurred. (see videos below)
Just recently - last month in fact (August 2011) - an article appeared in the Telegraph Newspaper (of the UK) saying that archaeologists now feel that Marco Polo never actually went to China. It is far more likely, they said, that he picked up stories from other travellers.
Marco Polo Map
Map originally created by Encyclopedia Britannica.
I found it on this blog - My Adventure in China
Movies and DVDs about Marco Polo
Marco Polo - Truth or Lies? - National Geographic Magazine investigates
There is a 3 part episode and then the same episode is repeated as a 2 parter. This series was made and aired in 2004. But there are also other parts as well - for example the Introduction and being in Venice, as well as the Great Wall and the foot binding. The one thing that we do know is true - these are all done by the same person - Mike Yamashita.
Marco Polo - idealized as a Scholar
Mosaic of Marco Polo located in Genoa, Italy
Photograph by Michael Yamashita
Marco Polo was not educated. He could not read or write although he obviously had a good memory. But the Italians have idealized him as an educated scholar and traveller and they made this mosaic of him. Part of the reason why he has been idealized, is because there are very few personal facts about Marco Polo. It is this lack of personal data which makes it very difficult to ascertain what sort of character Marco Polo had - what his morals were and what previous experience he had with factual reporting.
Image source - Copyright to National Geographic Magazine 2001 .
Marco Polo - TV series - 1982
Back in 1982, a miniseries aired on TV. It starred a young actor named Ken Marshall as that historical traveller - Marco Polo. This series is now almost 30 years old. For those of you who have not seen this series - Now is your chance.
The first episode (The Prologue) is in 6 parts.
The second episode is in 4 parts.
Marco Polo - TV series - 1982 - Continued
1982 TV miniseries continued
Episode 3 - Journey to China - in 6 parts
Episode 4 - Adventures in China - in 6 parts
Marco Polo - TV series - 1982 - Continued
1982 TV series continued
Episode 5 - Court Intrigue - in 5 parts
Episode 6 - Last Days in China - in 5 parts
Have you changed your mind?
Now that you have seen, heard and read the evidence, have you changed your mind?
Do you still hold the same view about Marco as before?
Please add a comment stating whether you have changed your mind or not.
Is Marco Polo a liar or is he telling the truth?
Marco is a liar
Marco Polo Resources
- The Book of Marco Polo
The Travels of Marco Polo by Michael Crouch 2001
- Marco Polo and his Travels
Silk Road Foundation
- Interactive Quiz map about Marco Polo's Travels
Answer 20 quiz questions to travel to China and back again
- Marco Polo and the New World
Some people even want to claim that Marco Polo visited the New World, not Asia.
- The Travels of Marco Polo
- Mysteries of History
In Defence of Marco Polo