ArtsAutosBooksBusinessEducationEntertainmentFamilyFashionFoodGamesGenderHealthHolidaysHomeHubPagesPersonal FinancePetsPoliticsReligionSportsTechnologyTravel
  • »
  • Health»
  • Personal Health Information & Self-Help

The Best Scar Removal Products

Updated on June 22, 2010

Scar removal products have to measure up to a few criteria in order to deserve being called the best. These products must first of all have proven efficacy. Furthermore the product should have anti inflammatory aspects, be hydrating, absorbent, hypoallergenic, must cover the scar, provide warmth and allow oxygen to pass through.

Proven efficacy is important because a part of the reviews are written by advertisers. Furthermore the conclusion of a clinical trial among 97 people with scars who used different scar removal products showed there was no improvement in scar appearance when assessed by physicians. Nevertheless when asked to evaluate their own scars, significantly more people using a certain so called effective product thought their scars were softer and less noticeable.

So when determining which scar product to choose it is recommended to go by advice from trusted sources and/or scientific findings and by evaluating the product traits. The following properties are beneficial to effective scar therapy:


Damaged skin has a tendency of losing water faster. Keeping scars hydrated for a durable period of time appears to improve scar appearance. Many clinical trials and reviews have demonstrated this. Hydration is thought to reduce water vapor loss and restore the homeostatic process in scars.


Inflammation plays a critical role in scar formation. Severe damage of the skin produces inflammation, which results in scarring. Thus, scar improvement requires control of inflammation. Still, no current topical scar product except silicone sheeting can address this concern.


Scar tissue is created by fibroblasts in the dermis that produce collagen. Collagen is known to be broken down by an enzyme called collagenase. Collagenase is stimulated by higher temperatures so warmth benefits the reduction of scar tissue creation. Scientists have found out that an increased temperature, even by 1°C, will significantly increase collagenase production.


A higher blood flow results in an increase in oxygen supply which leads to an improved skin tone. This can be provided by softly massaging the scar and by exercising regularly. Overstretching the scar tissue should be avoided at all times. Tension on the wound or scar is what also appears to be a major factor in scarring.

Covering scars

Covering up scars reduces the tension on scar tissue. A frequently used measure of scar covering is the aforementioned silicone sheeting. Exactly how silicones work has not been determined yet. But the fact many cosmetic surgeons refer to them as 'the golden standard in scar treatment' is another indication for being the best scar removal product at the moment. Recommended by many cosmetic surgeons and dermatologists, clinical studies have proven silicone gel sheeting to be safe and superior to other occlusive dressings like polyethylene or polyurethane.


Although there is no hard evidence on how silicone scar sheets exactly work they cover the scar and are believed or known to hydrate, have anti inflammatory aspects, are absorbent, hypoallergenic, provide warmth and allow oxygen to pass through.

Since hydration is important in scar therapy, silicone sheeting might be best complemented with the daily use of a good hydrating cream and regular massaging.

For extended information, user experiences and links to scientific reports supporting the statements in this article visit the page below. For extended information, user experiences and links to scientific reports supporting the statements in this article visit this best scar removal products page.

Medical Grade Silicone Sheets

ScarAway Professional Grade Silicone Scar Treatment Sheets, 12 Count ( Packaging May Vary )
ScarAway Professional Grade Silicone Scar Treatment Sheets, 12 Count ( Packaging May Vary )

Doctor level silicone sheeting is known for its better quality then some other brands. Scaraway and Neosporin are medical grade, by surgeons and burn centers recommended silicone patches.


Don't Believe The Hype

Wherever you are looking, on websites, forums, and even on places where Md's offer there advice, scar removal myths are abundant. Forget about vitamin E capsules, Mederma, or onion extract because there's no scientific evidence these products work. In fact one study showed Vaseline to be more effective than Mederma in removal of excessive scar tissue.

The only product backed by science are silicone sheets and in lesser amount other types of occlusive sheets such as polyurethane and hydrogel sheets.


    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    • profile image

      SHABI KHAN 6 years ago


    • profile image

      mkstewart 7 years ago

      This is a very informative hub. Nice job. My name is Michele. I was very unfortunate to suffer from extremely bad acne scarring growing up. I TRIED EVERYTHING! Then I found a scar removing cream that showed very quick promise. After 5 months of using the scar cream my scarring became virtually invisible. I was so elated that I felt compelled to create a blog to help others. Too see before and after pictures of me click here:

    • celistina profile image

      celistina 8 years ago

      Very informative. Thanks for this hub and voted up! I've used several scar reduction products before. A good product is this silicon sheet by cica care. Mederma, a scar reduction cream, helps soften scars too.