Reading: Ben Macintyre, A Spy Among Friends: Kim Philby and the Great Betrayal, New York: Random House, 2014
An affably deceptive figure.
Ben Macintyre, A Spy Among Friends: Kim Philby and the Great Betrayal, New York: Random House, 2014, p. p. 570, ISBN: 978-0-8041-9449-5
In my former job I was once asked to write to Philby's assistant Patrick Seale, also Philby's replacement as Observer correspondent in Beirut. I suppose my already existing interest in the labyrinthine affairs of Lebanon and the Middle East was heightened by this episode, but a prior interest in Lebanon is hardly a prerequisite for being impressed by Ben Macintyre's book on Kim Philby.
This historical biography, then, which reads like a novel in places, is the story of the British diplomat and MI6 operative, Harold ('Kim') Philby (1912-1988), who, having been recruited by Soviet agents while studying at Trinity College, Cambridge in the early 1930s, proceeded for the next 30 years or so to spy for the Soviet Union. The book complements Anthony Cave Brown's 'Treason in the Blood', an account of Kim Philby's life which drawn on his heredity in relation to his father St John Philby, colonial administrator turned Saudi adviser, who was once jailed for anti-British statements. Kim Philby's name will always be associated with Guy Burgess and Donald Maclean, whom he himself recruited to the Communist cause, and who defected to the Soviet Union in 1951, being eventually followed by Philby himself in 1963, when his past was catching up with him.
It is a riveting read, told from the standpoint of his friendship with Nicholas Elliott, fellow MI6 agent, who had long defended him from charges of being a spy and who only in the early 1960s became finally convinced of his complicity with the Soviet Union and famously confronted him In Beirut, where he worked as a journalist, in early 1963, evincing from Philby a limited confession.
What happened next is intriguing. Amazingly, even after the escape of Burgess and Maclean, an old boy network of public school alumni led by Nicholas Elliott seemingly protected Philby and had even recruited him back into MI6. When strong evidence against Philby eventually emerged that not even Elliott could ignore, Elliott — according to Macintyre — not only offered him an immunity deal from prosecution, but also facilitated his escape from Beirut to the Soviet Union. Macintyre offers the explanation for this by way of contrasting the treatment of Philby with that of George Blake, also a Soviet spy in MI6, because — claims the writer — Blake, jailed for 42 years, was not from the same social class as Philby.
This interpretation will doubtless find a resonance among many readers, not least in the US, where some leaders of the intelligence services had become deeply suspicious of Philby in 1951, then serving as a diplomat in Washington, DC. Certainly, FBI Direct J. Edgar Hoover was known to have been incandescent that someone such as Philby, responsible for the betraying of many damaging secrets to the Soviet Union, could be allowed to escape prosecution.
Whether I myself buy this interpretation, I am not sure. Interestingly, Philby's limited confession in 1963, received by MI6, specifically excluded spying after 1949, the year when he had moved to the US: thus, to the Americans MI6 could claim conveniently — if implausibly — that his affairs were purely a British internal matter.
This instance of British institutional evasiveness does indeed ring true.
June 30, 2015
Other of my hubpages may also be of interest
- Reading Peter Edwards, Delusion: The True Story of Victorian Superspy Henri Le Caron, Toronto, Ontar
The spy was seemingly driven by the desire for money; whether also motivated by a sense of justice is less clear. The spymaster was driven by police duty and antipathy toward Irish nationalists.
- Reading: General Rick Hillier, A Soldier First, Toronto, Ontario: HarperCollins Publishers, Ltd., 20
General Rick Hillier, A Soldier First, Toronto, Ontario: HarperCollins Publishers, Ltd., 2009 ... There is much in these memoirs of retired Canadian General Rick Hillier to which I warmed. These aspects must surely include his sense of pride in...
- Reading: W. H. Thompson, Sixty Minutes with Winston Churchill, London: Christopher Johnson, a Review
Recollections from Churchill's bodyguard which reveal incidents, including an event which could have led to the firing of Churchill from the War Cabinet - not unlike the Maxime Barnier affair in 2008