The Savior-Tyrant Dilemma in Frank Herbert's Dune Series
Using Joseph Campbell’s Theories to Understand How Heroes Become Villains
As the Dune series progresses many protagonists become or fear becoming oppressive forces, and Campbell’s monomythic cycle explains how such a transformation happens.
As Dune closes all seems well: a dictator is usurped, the Fremen control the spice and their own destiny, and Paul Muad’Dib has justice for the injuries against his family. Many readers are understandably shocked then as Dune Messiah opens with conspiracy against the Emperor Paul and that there is dissatisfaction even among the Fremen at the course their culture has taken. Paul Muad’Dib is venerated as a messiah but also despised by many who fear his prescience abilities and his autocratic theocracy.
The Wheel of Myth
Joseph Campbell’s studies show that a common mythic motif is the hero who essentially overstays his or her welcome. Someone who once brought a great boon becomes as tyrant by both their increased and dangerous stature and that he or she fights against upcoming heroes who act to revitalize society as they once did.
Campbell points to King Minos who was once a good king, but through abuses of his divine relationships he is cursed to care for the bestial and insatiable Minotaur. Minos becomes a fearsome tyrant as he forces his citizens into slavery and has them sacrifice themselves to the Minotaur’s ravenous hunger. It takes another hero—Theseus—to undo the oppressive carnage Minos brings.
Muad’Dib the Messiah Devil
Paul finds himself in a situation similar to Minos as the church he built to secure his power grows monstrous. Led by his crazed sister—Alia—Paul Muad’Dib’s church establishes creeds and ossified rituals in place of the dynamism and adventurous spirit he showed by becoming leader of the Fremen in the first place and helping them liberate themselves and take revenge against their oppressors.
Paul is slightly better off than Minos, though, for he sees what is happening but believes he is trapped in these circumstances by his prescient visions. He gambles greatly on the birth of his children to free him by becoming the kind of heroes he once was. The tragedy is that Paul looses everything trying to undo the tangle of self-serving institutions that have become Dune’s equivalent to the carnivorous Minotaur. The very people he saved are becoming slaves and victims of his own institutions.
Children of Dune
The stage is set for Paul’s children to succeed where he failed. Alia takes power and turns the empire into an unbearable theocracy ruled by observance to empty rituals suggesting an institutional necrophilia; the love of heroic actions and deeds is replaced by deadening fanaticism that stifles creative growth and turns the population fearful. Paul’s hyper-intelligent children know the trap their father fell into by tying to replace one dictatorship with another. Their situation will require an unthinkable extreme.
Leto, believing he sees where Paul failed, decides the only way to break free of Campbell’s mythic savior-oppressor cycle is to embrace it and synthesize the two roles. Through symbiosis with sandworms he becomes more and less than human—as the Minotaur was—and takes his place as god emperor. His goal is to be so oppressive and crushingly omnipresent that when his reign is undone, all the subjects of his vast empire will never again trust allegedly heroic men such as himself or his father. Essentially everyone must become his or her own hero.
Campbell, Joseph. The Hero with a Thousand Faces. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1973.
Herbert, Frank. Children of Dune. New York: Ace Books, 1976.
Herbert, Frank. Dune. New York: Ace Books, 1965.
Herbert, Frank. Dune Messiah. New York: Ace Books, 1969.
- The Hero of Dune
The protagonist of Frank Herberts Dune and the choices made by Paul MuadDib Atreides are best understood in the context of Joseph Campbells heroic monomyth. In this light he is both heroic and...
- Review of God Emperor of Dune
Given the slow pace and lack of action, Herberts fourth Dune novel does not match the effort of the others.Death of the SandwormsEven though the previous three Dune novels are freighted with...
- Review of Heretics of Dune
The fifth novel in the Dune series is a revival of the action and political machinations familiar to readers of the earlier novels.Recovering from the doldrums of the previous novel, Frank Herbert is back in...