LG Dishwasher Review: I Got a Lemon!
A New LG Dishwasher! What Could Possibly Go Wrong?
I was excited to get a new dishwasher. My wife and I picked out a great looking unit at Lowe's. It had stainless steel exterior, and a stainless steel tub inside as well. It had "LoDecibel" 48dB Quiet Operation, nice looking purple plastic trim on the dish racks, and a "Smart Diagnosis" feature which unfortunately I had to use within the first week of owning the new dishwasher.
What could possibly go wrong with a brand new dishwasher? Plenty, as you'll find out. I should mention that this was a brand new dishwasher. It was new in the box, not a returned item or a "scratch and dent" sale item. The dishwasher was delivered new in the box, and the Lowe's delivery guys even unpacked the dishwasher for me.
I installed the unit very carefully, intending for it to last a very long time. Its useful life was less than a week as it turned out.
Problems with My New LG Dishwasher
1. Strange Sounds
The first problem I noticed with my new LG dishwasher was fairly minor and I was willing to live with it. Even though it was advertised as being quiet, it made some strange noises. I guess technically the dishwasher may have been quiet if measured with a sound meter, but the noises it made were distracting. It sounded sort like a helicopter taking off or something. Even though my old dishwasher was louder, its sound was more consistent and blended into the background better. The LG made some chopping and rattling sounds that were hard to ignore. But I was willing to try.
2. "tE" Error = Temperature Error
So I was willing to ignore some obnoxious sounds, but the "the" error could not be ignored. After starting my 3rd load of dishes in the brand new dishwasher, it beeped and displayed "the" error code on the display. The "the" error caused the dishwasher to stop running. I figured it was probably something minor that would be cleared by turning the power off and back on. Since I had just finished installing the unit, I had the manual handy and checked the "the" error code. It stands for Temperature Error. The recommended action is to call for service.
Bad news. Is a 3 day old dishwasher already broken down!? It would start to fill with water, and the "the" could would come on after about a minuite. I decided to turn it off and try again. "the" error again. Another try to I got another "the" error. I did see that the LG has a Smart Diagnosis feature, so I downloaded the LG app on my cell phone. You can push a button on the dishwasher and it makes sounds like an old-fashioned modem. You can hold the phone near the dishwasher when it is playing its diagnostic data and you can get a diagnostic report. This report also confirmed that the unit had a Temperature Error and that the next step was to have the unit repaired.
Some research on the internet showed that the "the" error could be caused by a bad thermistor, a bad computer board, or by a faulty cable in the cable harness. I called LG to report the problem, and they scheduled a repairman to stop by. The time window was between 8am to 5pm. I'm glad they could narrow that down so I could plan my day...
3. Leaking Water!
I called the local repair shop the next morning to try to find out what time they could check the dishwasher. The repairman was able to stop by in the early afternoon, and I drove home to meet him. When I arrived home, I found water on the floor behind the dishwasher.
I was surprised to see water leaking behind the dishwasher. Since the water hook-up was on the front, I expected to see a leak there if I didn't get the supply line tightened up enough. But why would there be water leaking out the back of the dishwasher? Good thing the repairman was on the way.
Good Advice from a Dishwasher Repairman
When the repairman arrived, I briefly mentioned the 2 major problems: the dishwasher would not run due to the "the" error, and there was a puddle of water in back. The repairman decided to check out the puddle of water first. He could see it leaking. He slid the dishwasher out and tipped it at a 45 degree angle so he could check out the bottom. He checked it out from inside as well and said that it was leaking around the sump.
The repairman couldn't find a way to tighten or adjust anything to stop the leaking- he would probably need to order parts to repair the leaking. Yikes!
Next he put the unit back in place and investigated the "the" error. Sure enough, it happened again. He said he could take it apart and try to isolate the problem, but first he asked how long I had owned the unit. I replied about one week. Next, he asked if I knew the return policy of the store where I bought it. This was a great question, and make me realize that a smart thing to do would be to return the unit and get something different. LG paid for the service call since the unit was under warranty but I decided not to have the repairman work on it and exchange it for another dishwasher instead.
I called Lowe's to explain the situation and they said to come in and pick out a different one. I made it clear that I was interested in looking at other brands, and the appliance manager said that was fine.
Replacing the LG with a Bosch
After checking around, I decided that Bosch was one of the most reliable brands around. A couple houses ago, I installed a Bosch dishwasher and really liked it. I also talked with an appliance repairman who said that Bosch was at the top of his list for the most reliable dishwasher brands.
The only trouble I have with Bosch is pronouncing the name. I used to think it was pronounced to sort of rhyme with "post", but I think it is supposed to rhyme with "tosh" as in macintosh.
Anyway, I decided to replace the LG with a Bosch and hauled the broken unit back to Lowe's to exchange. I really wanted something in stock that I could install right away. I had lots of dishes piling up since I did not have a working dishwasher. Unfortunately, Lowe's did not have any Bosch in stock. It would take 4 days or so to get one in.
Next, we tried Best Buy. I have a Lowe's card that I use to get 5% off and Best Buy has a 5% rewards program. I would rather have the cash discount that rewards points, but at least they have something. The thing Best Buy did not have, however, was Bosch dishwashers in stock. This was not going very well...
I called up a local appliance shop. They had several models of Bosch in stock, so we headed over. This place had a great showroom, and the sales people there really seemed to know their stuff. The prices were a little higher, but we found a Bosch model there that was priced lower than at Lowe's or Best Buy. This was turning out OK after all.
Testing the New Bosch Dishwasher
I am running the second load in the new Bosch dishwasher now. It does not make distracting sounds like the LG dishwasher, and so far there are no error codes or leaks. It is worth noting that the sound level rating on the LG was 48 dBA and the sound level rating on the Bosch is 44dBA. The way that the dBA scale works, this means that the sound level from the Bosch is less than half as much as the LG.
This dishwasher does seem sturdier and is much quieter than the LG. I thought they both did a good job of getting dishes clean.
One thing that I noticed when installing the Bosch is that the water supply hook-up and electrical hook-up are the back of the unit. You can see this in the photo of the back of the Bosch.
Most dishwashers, including my troubled LG, have the supply lines running under the dishwasher with the hook-ups on the front. Having the hook-ups in the back makes more sense. You can still slide the unit out to work on it, so this works fairly well.
Instead of using wire nuts to connect the electrical supply, you can use an appliance power cord that clicks into place in the back and just plug this into an outlet. This power cord was not included with the Bosch- I had to run to the store to pick this up when I realized that it was not included.
The Bosch did include the water supply hose. So I can return the appliance cord that uses wire nuts to connect and the dishwasher water hook-up hose that I bought to install the LG and get about $30 back.
What I Learned From the LG Dishwasher Problems
1. Don't repair a new appliance that has multiple problems- you may be better off exchanging it if you are still within the appliance store's return period.
2. Call the manufacturer and have the manufacturer pay for a repairman to come out if the appliance is still under warranty.
3. The sound ratings on dishwashers (dBA) may not capture how quiet they seem in your home. The LG model made a lot of distracting sounds even though it was rated as a quiet model.
4. Small local appliance stores may be able to compete with the "big box" stores- but do you homework to make sure you are getting a good price. The service and selection they provide may be better than a big box store that sells lots of other things in addition to just focusing on appliances.
5. If you can get 5% off at Lowe's using their credit card, this is better than getting 5% rewards points at Best Buy since the rewards points are only good at Best Buy. Cash is good anywhere :-)
6. Talk to an appliance repairman about what appliance brands they would recommend. This may help you avoid getting a "lemon".
© 2015 Dr Penny Pincher