# Walnut Lumber-Has it always been hard to find?

## Walnut Lumber-This is why it's so hard to find.?

Before the industrial revolution and before China became a developed nation walnut lumber has been hard to find. It does not grow in large numbers or populate an entire forest. It is a solitary tree that grows alone. The Confederacy had problems finding the manpower to mill enough walnut lumber for gun stocks. Old walnut lumber furniture is still very hard to find.

Walnut trees produce a poison deadly to animals, humans, other plants and other walnut trees. The Walnut tree produces a substance known as “Jug lone”. Many plants find it difficult to grow near a walnut tree because of it. Trees such as pine, birch, cherry, rhododendron, red pine and apple will not grow anywhere near a walnut tree due to the toxin. Plants such as blackberry, blueberry, tomatoes, peppers and potatoes won’t grow near walnut either. Even walnut won't grow near other walnut trees due to the toxins in the roots. The toxins from a mature walnut tree can reach a radius of 200 feet. Walnut is like the black widow of trees, and is very hard to find.

It is toxic to work with walnut lumber for humans. Saw mill operators have known about the toxic properties of walnut dust since the first water powered saw mill cut up a walnut tree. Very few sawyers will mill walnut lumber for this very reason.

Walnut is also very heavy and difficult to move around and work with. Since it grows all by itself there are no mills set up to deal with large quantities of walnut like there are for pine and others species. It is also prone to cracking if not dried and aged correctly. Walnut trees are often huge in size and the wood within is very dense and difficult to cut. Once down the logs are often anything but straight so the wood is difficult to make into dimensional lumber such as 2x4’s and other standard building materials. When walnut lumber is handled and dried correctly it makes absolutely beautiful furniture, flooring and gun stocks. It is impervious to weather and insects and has that wonderful dark rich color. Just one more reason it is so hard to find.

## Finished Walnut Table

## Walnut lumber Slabs

## Walnut Dealer

## Interview with a Walnut Sawyer

I finally found a walnut lumber sawyer Ray Gregory up in Blue Ridge, Georgia willing to answer a few questions. I asked him why he felt there is such a shortage of the walnut lumber on the market. Here are some of his answers;

- Why is Walnut lumber hard to find and so expensive when you do? "Well one huge reason is fuel cost. Walnut trees grow by themselves and live for a long time. When I find an old walnut tree it is often many miles from here. I can easily spend over $300 on fuel to fall the tree, cut it up, load it and unload it at my mill. This is before any milling or drying cost. Inventory and storage is also a costly expense. The last thing anyone wants is to have hundreds of dollars wrapped in inventory. It is no secret the building boom has slowed. I have an inventory of walnut but not as much as I used to stock in the past."
- How much more difficult is walnut lumber to mill than other species. "It's no more difficult to cut than any other hard wood and we use breathing protection for all species. What makes it more difficult is drying it correctly so that it does not crack. Most people buying walnut are building fine furniture and cracks are not acceptable."
- Is China buying up all of our walnut lumber. "I doubt it, it's just one of those products that is difficult to do anything with on a large scale. I don't sell to too many exporters if any."
- Is Walnut lumber going to run out soon. "Well if you plant a walnut in the ground today it won't be a descent size Walnut tree for about 100 years. I personally know of thousands of board feet of the stuff whenever I want to go cut it but there is only so much left"

## Black Walnut being milled at Moose Mill Works

## Must Walnut is milled by small back woods mills

## Lean Inventory Management in the Walnut Lumber Industry: Examples and Applications

## 420-148

Henry Quesada-Pineda, Assistant Professor, Wood Science and Forest Products, and Business and Manufacturing Extension Specialist

## Introduction

One of the most difficult aspects of any manufacturing system is to control inventory. Keeping the right amount of inventory is not straightforward, so managers need to address the issue in a proper way. In wood products industries around the United States and in other countries, the problem seems to be the same: From lumber storage all the way to finished product, large quantities of inventory are piled up in the system.

Could this inventory accumulation be damaging performance? The simplest answer is from the point of view of “lean thinking.” Lean thinking is a philosophy that encourages the elimination or minimization of any form of waste. Excessive waste in a system adds costs to the final product and, most likely, customers are punished for the inefficiency.

One of the major sources of waste is the accumulation of inventory in your system. Not only is the money already paid for the inventory, but also for the holding cost involved. In the case of work in process (WIP) and finished inventory, you need to add other costs, such as labor and indirect costs, to the cost of raw materials.

Cost is not the only factor. With accumulated excess inventory, your lead times might be getting longer and your customers will have to wait longer for their products.

Either way you look at it, it makes sense to understand the basics of inventory control. This article will go through the basics using some real examples and applications in wood products industries.

## How Important Is Inventory Control?

Inventory decisions are risky and they make a large impact throughout the supply chain (Bowersox, Closs, and Cooper 2005). Without proper planning, a manufacturing company can run out of raw material, negatively impacting the company and its customers. Likewise, overstocking of raw materials, work in process inventory, or finished goods could also hurt the company’s profitability. Wood products industries should carefully plan and manage inventory. There are some fundamental issues that need to be considered when planning inventory for wood products manufacturing firms.

- Raw materials are the first and foremost form of inventory. At a wood products manufacturing site, raw materials in multiple forms, including logs, lumber, composites, or chips, are transformed into higher value-added products. Wood products firms need to carefully design their warehouse or storage facilities for the special requirements of this biological raw material. In some locations, weather-related factors could affect log supply. To prevent “log starvation,” a company may employ a strategy of stockpiling that requires extra space, additional handling, proper identification of species and harvest date, and special care to prevent log degradation. Figure 1 shows an example of a log with extensive mechanical and biological damage that might have occurred from poor inventory management.
Figure 1. A log with extensive mechanical and biological damage due to improper inventory handling conditions.

- In most wood products industries, the accumulation of inventory is more notorious in the form of work in process inventory. In most cases, WIP is used as a buffer to compensate for poor scheduling and production planning practices. It is important to mention that an excessive amount of WIP not only affects cycle time and throughput, but also the profitability of the company because WIP has by now absorbed raw material, labor, and overhead costs. Figure 2 shows WIP accumulation in a secondary wood products facility.
Figure 2. Realized raw material, labor, and overhead expenses rapidly decrease profits in the form of work in process (WIP) accumulation.

- Most wood products manufacturing firms work under the “make-to-stock” (MTS)
^{1}strategy, because demand spurts and supply bottlenecks make “just-in-time” production unfeasible. Stocking excessive amounts of finished wood products such as lumber, plywood, veneer, OSB, MDF, I-joists, or furniture reduces profit because storage costs for these inventory goods are significantly more than the cost of raw materials or WIP inefficiencies due to greater costs already absorbed. - The purchase price of raw materials is not the only cost to consider when planning inventory. In addition to the purchase price, there is also the cost of setting up an order and the cost of holding or maintaining inventory.
- Finally, you should provide the highest level of service to your company’s customers while maintaining the least possible amount of inventory in stock. The concept of inventory is strongly related to the lean-thinking philosophy. In a perfect “lean” world, inventory would not exist because it ties up cash and other resources. However, we have learned that in the wood products industry, inventory is needed to compensate for variability and uncertainty. Therefore, inventory is unavoidable in order to balance against uncertainty — not just in the form of raw material, but also in the forms of WIP and finished goods.

As seen in the previous section, inventory planning involves the consideration of the three types of inventory (raw material, WIP, and finished goods), inventory cost issues, customer service rates, and process efficiency. Overall, the goal is to balance the need for inventory in every stage of the process against the uncertainty.

With this consideration in mind, the purpose of this article is to address the most fundamental question in inventory planning: How much should be ordered if we want to keep the company as process-efficient (lean) as possible and with the highest possible achievable customer service rates?

^{1} An inventory point where customers expect to be able to obtain parts or products without delay.

## Important Definitions

The definition of a lean inventory policy requires clarification of certain terms. We define the following important terms that are necessary to accomplish our goal:

**Setup cost:** The cost associated with placing an order from a supplier. Every time an order needs to be placed, the company will spend some time and money placing it. Also, it might take more than one person to place an order, and lack of a well-planned ordering system can be very time-consuming and inefficient. Keep in mind that the more often orders are placed or replenished, the higher the total inventory costs. Counterintuitive to this consideration, the fewer orders placed, the more inventory will be needed to meet demand.

**Holding cost:** The cost associated with maintaining the inventory. Taxes, insurance premiums, obsolescence, storage space, handling, and information technology expenses are the most common financial aspects of holding costs.

**Unit cost:** The amount of money that is paid to purchase or create one unit of inventory.

**Demand:** The amount of units required in a certain time. It is usually expressed in units per day, units per month, or units per year, depending on the performance cycle a company might use.

**Average inventory:** Figure 3 shows how a simple inventory model works. This graph is also known as the saw-tooth plot. At time zero, an order of 10,000 board feet (BF) is placed with a local lumber supplier. In a perfect world, lumber will arrive instantly and be consumed uniformly for 30 days, at a rate of 333.33 BF per day. On day 30, a new order is placed for the same quantity and it arrives instantly on that day. The amount of lumber ordered every 30 days represents the order quantity or “Q.” The average inventory held is calculated as Q/2. In this case, the average inventory is 5,000 BF.

Figure 3. A simple inventory cycle model.

**Service level rate:** This is a performance measurement set by management that is closely linked with customer service. For example, if a lumber company has a service level rate of 95 percent, this indicates that, on average, 95 orders out of 100 will be filled and delivered on time. The other five orders are backlogged. As we will see later on, the higher the service level, the higher the associated inventory holding costs. Therefore, management should have a clear idea of how much it costs to offer a certain service level to its customers, compared to the cost of maintaining an order backlog.

**Safety stock:** A part of the total inventory that is used to protect the manufacturing system from starvation if the placed order fails to arrive on time. Safety stock works very well to protect against delivery variability — specifically, random demand. An inventory model that uses safety stock to prevent stockouts is more closely related to real world situations. Figure 4 shows an inventory model that uses safety stock as part of inventory policy.

Figure 4. A simple inventory cycle model with safety stock (SS).

Similar to service level, the amount of safety stock is typically determined by management. A statistical procedure is sometimes used that considers historical demand variability and holding costs as part of the calculations.

**Reorder point:** Used as a trigger or flag to set up a new order. To calculate the reorder point (RP), the firm will need to know how much time it takes for its supplier to deliver a new order. Figure 5 illustrates the use of the reorder point.

Figure 5. An inventory model that includes a reorder point (RP) as part of the inventory policy.

For instance, assume that it takes 15 days for the supplier to deliver an order after it is placed. If the daily demand is 333.3 BF per day, in 15 days a total of 5,000 BF will be consumed. If the company wishes to keep a safety stock of 2,500 BF, as shown in figure 5, then new orders need to be placed when the inventory level reaches 7,500 BF. Mathematically, the reorder point can be expressed as

RP = (D x *S*) + *SS*, (1)

where

*D* = demand, *S* = supplier lead time (days),*SS* = safety stock.

## How Much to Order?

Now that we have addressed the most important concepts in lean inventory planning, it is time to come back to the fundamental question: How much should be ordered to keep a minimum stock level without affecting customer service? To answer this question, we will use the inventory costs discussed above to develop an inventory model. Our solution will have to satisfy total minimum costs to be a feasible solution. There are three main cost components that make up the total inventory cost (TIC):

The relationships of the holding cost, setup cost, and total cost are shown in figure 6. In this graph, the green line represents the total incremental inventory cost (as in equation (5)), the red line represents the holding cost (equation (3)), the blue line is the setup cost (equation (4)), the horizontal axis is the number of units, and the vertical axis represents cost. Figure 6 shows that the holding cost (red line) increases as the number of units per order increases. Also, the setup cost (blue line) decreases if the number of units per order increases.

Figure 6. Total cost, holding cost, and setup cost of an inventory model.

Note that the green line has a minimum (look for the lowest point in the plot). This will be the lowest or minimum cost. In figure 6, this point intersects with the horizontal axis at approximately 4,500 (see orange vertical line). This means that if an order of 4,500 units is placed during a time period it will yield the minimum possible cost. Any number of units below or above 4,500 will produce a higher total inventory cost.

This graphic example would be more helpful if we already knew how many orders (D/Q) need to placed over a time to achieve the minimum cost; however, we do not know that yet. So, how can we order Q units to keep the TIC at a minimum? Again, take a look at figure 6. To determine the quantity Q, examine the intersection point of the holding cost (red line) and the setup cost (blue line). The point intersects with the horizontal axis at approximately 4,500 as it does the lowest point of the TIC. If both curves (holding and setup costs) intersect at the same point as the TIC, they are equal. At this intersection point we have:

The final calculation of the EOQ equation (8) does not include the unit cost C* _{u}* , because quantity does not affect the TIC or incremental price. How can we explain this? Intuitively, we can say that ordering just one unit is the same cost of ordering 10,000 units. Mathematically, this can be shown if you take the first derivative of equation (5) for EOQ. Notice that the first term (unit cost) does not depend on EOQ; therefore, the derivative of a constant is zero.

Let’s take a closer look to the example shown in figure 6 to explain the EOQ concepts in action. This is the case of a small furniture manufacturer that produces high-end office furniture of several hardwood species. We will review the EOQ model for ordering walnut lumber. These are the initial parameters:

*D* = 50,000 BF per year,

*C _{u}* = $4.5 per BF,

*C _{h}* = $1.25 per BF,

*C _{s}* = $250 per order.

If we use equation (8), then we have

This means that every order of walnut lumber should be of 4,473 BF (rounded up). This is the economic order quantity or EOQ. If you divide D by the EOQ, then you know you need to place 11.17 orders/year.

This procedure shows how much to order to keep the total holding and setup costs to a minimum. The EOQ model is very important to establish the basic relationships in terms of cost and how much to order every time. However, the EOQ model relies on a few assumptions that are worth mentioning:

- Demand is constant.
- Lead time from supplier is known and constant.
- Orders are filled or replenished instantly.
- There is no in-transit inventory.
- Unit cost is independent of order quantity or time.

The next section will show us how to calculate an optimal quantity order when considering random demand. This new model is more closely related to a real-world situation, and it requires that the reader have some basic understanding of calculus and probability concepts. We will try to avoid as much calculus and probability as possible.

## The Pencil Vendor Model: Dealing With Variability

This second inventory model will address the case where demand is random and there is a cost associated with ordering too much or ordering too little, using equations and the general model definition from Hopp and Spearman (2001).

To illustrate our second model, we will use a real example taken from a pencil manufacturing facility. The reason to choose this type of wood products industry is because it is a product that has cyclical demand.

This particular firm only manufactures pencils during a portion of the year in preparation for the start of the academic year. The company uses a raw material called gmelina (*Gmelina arborea*), a tropical hardwood that has a harvesting cycle of 10 years. Besides being a fast-growing species, gmelina pencils are easier to sharpen than other wood species. Figure 7 shows a picture of the pencil manufacturing site where this inventory model was applied in order to deal with random demand over a very short period of time.

Figure 7. Partial view of the pencil manufacturing facility.

First, let’s take a look at the cost issues. Remember that we will have to define our model starting with the total inventory cost or incremental cost as we did with the economic order quantity model.

If the EOQ estimate is short of the real demand, D, then profit is lost from a potential sale, or C* _{s}*. If production cost of one pencil is $0.10 and it sells for $0.20 and inventory is lagging, then a lost profit of C

*= $0.20 − $0.10 = $0.10 per unit is incurred. Conversely, if EOQ happens to be larger than your actual demand, then you are going to have tied up capital (money) sitting in excess inventory, or C*

_{s}*. As demand is cyclical, pencil overproduction for next year cannot be supported, so the additional pencils are sold as discounted products at $0.05 per unit, resulting in a loss per excess of inventory of C*

_{o}*= $0.10 − $0.05 = $0.05, which implies that it is less costly per unit to overproduce than to be short of actual demand. A lost sale costs $0.10 per unit, and an overage costs only $0.05 per unit.*

_{o}The following formula is then used to create a new inventory model of units over:

units over = max{*Q* − *D*,0}

This implies that if Q is greater than or equal to D, then the overage is simply Q minus D, but if Q is less than D, then the overproduction is zero, meaning that there was actually a shortage of pencils instead of an overproduction. The following formula is used to estimate a shortage:

shortage = max{*D* − *Q*,0}

This tells us that if D is greater than or equal to Q, then the actual shortage is D minus Q. Otherwise, there is overproduction, so the shortage is zero. Total inventory cost is determined by

TIC = *C _{0}*

^{*}max{

*Q*−

*D*,0} +

*C*

_{s}^{*}max{

*D*−

*Q*,0}

Finding the value of Q that will minimize the TIC utilizes the same procedure as the previous model^{2}. A plant engineer in the pencil manufacturing site found out that the demand, D, is equal to 1,300,450 units per year, with a standard deviation of σ = 155,210 pencils per year. With this information, we can calculate the value of EOQ as:

*Q* = *Q*^{*} = *µ* + *zσ*

= 1,300,450 + 0.7486 x 155,210

= 1,416,640 units.

This result tells us that the pencil manufacturing site needs to produce 0.7486 standard deviations above the average demand (1,300,450 pencils). The difference from this example to the previous one is that we have introduced demand variability, a closer approach to real-world scenarios than the case of deterministic demand.

^{2}*See appendix for technical note that explains how to find the value of _{Q} for this example*

## Final Remarks

The complexity and variety of inventory models is broad. This paper presents the very basics of operations management literature on inventory planning covering two models: one that works with deterministic demand and one that works with random demand. They are both useful to start getting a grasp on how inventory planning control can help a company be more profitable and customer-oriented. Both models have their strengths and weaknesses, but in general, they represent a variety of different mathematical solutions to the problem of inventory and how we can keep a company with just enough stock running (lean-oriented). Our objective in this paper is to get you started, motivated, and concerned about why planning inventory is essential to both minimizing waste and increasing customer satisfaction.

## References

Bowersox, D., D. Closs, and M. Cooper. 2005. *Supply Chain Logistics Management*. 2nd ed. New York: McGraw-Hill.

Hopp, W., and M. Spearman. 2001. *Factory Physics*. 2nd ed. New York: McGraw-Hill.

## Appendix: Technical Note for the Pencil Vendor Model

(Hopp and Spearman 2001)

**Finding Economic Order Quantity to Minimize Total Inventory Cost**

First we need to transform the TIC equation into a derivative so we can find the minimum. The new TIC formula will now look like this:

To solve this derivative, Leibnitz’ rule is required but is not explained in this technical note. After taking the derivative and setting the result equal to zero, we have:

which can also be expressed as:

TIC = C_{0}Q − C_{s}[1 − Q] = 0.

Notice that TIC should equal zero to find the minimum TIC. Solving for EOQ, we have:

### Random Demand

Note that according to equation (9), the economic order quantity for this model depends only on the cost of running out of stock or overstocking, as expected. As random demand (variability) comes into play, EOQ in equation (9) has to be defined for some probability distribution. If the demand, D, is equal to 1,300,450 pencils, normally distributed with a mean of µ and a standard deviation of σ = 155,210 pencils, and assumption of normality holds for the demand, then we can assume Q = (Q^{*} − D)/σ is normally distributed also, with a mean^{3} of zero and standard deviation of one. Therefore, we can use this result to express our EOQ as:

where z is the value in the standard normal table, and hence:

*Q ^{*}= µ + zσ*. (11)

So, in order to calculate the final value of EOQ, we need to first calculate the value of z. For this calculation, we will use equation (10):

By looking at a normal table, we can find that the value of Ф(0.67) = 0.7486. We need to do this because there is no possible way to express *ø(z)=∫*_{-}^{z}_{ ∞}*ø*(*y*)*dy* as a simple, closed-form expression. These tables are included in any statistical and probability book or incorporated in scientific calculators or spreadsheets.

Now we can insert this value into equation (11) to obtain our final EOQ^{*}:

* Q ^{*}= µ+ zσ =* 1,300,450

*+*0.7486 x 155,210

*1,416,640 pencils*

^{}=Notice that when demand is random, the economic order quantity depends on the probability distribution of the demand and the cost of overproducing or underproducing. Another important insight is that increasing the variability of the demand might increase or decrease the order quantity, depending on the values of Ф(z).

^{3} A measure of central tendency of a group of data.

## Lean Inventory Management

- Virginia Cooperative Extension

Source of the article posted above.

## About Walnut Lumber Wood

- About Walnut Wood | eHow.com

About Walnut Wood. Wood from walnut trees is considered to be hard wood, meaning it is particularly dense, tight-grained and resilient. Most of the 21 species of walnut can be cultivated and utilized for timber, but...

## Urban Walnut Lumber Trees

- Urban Walnut Trees: Their Value as Timber or Veneer, F-44-02

Heiligmann Extension Specialist, Forestry Reports of black walnut trees being sold for hundreds or even thousands of dollars often cause homeowners to

## Selling Walnut Lumber

- American Walnut Manufacturers Association

Black walnut requires and deserves attention if maximum returns are to be earned. For many woodland owners, the opportunity to sell timber comes only once or twice during a lifetime. For those fortunate enough to own a well-managed woodland, timber c