Two Georges Lied Us Into War With Iraq
Calvin Trillin's Poem of the Week
ANOTHER EXASPERATING ACCOUNT OF THE BUNKER
So who ever thunk
That Tenet's "slam dunk"
Was really the chunk
Of intelligence junk
That got our boys sunk
In quagmire gunk?
But he, with no spunk,
Stayed mum, like a punk,
And helped sell this bunk
'Til all went kerplunk,
And then packed his trunk.
Like Powell, he's shrunk.
Calvin Trillin in The Nation May 21, 2007
George Tenet's Evasions by David Corn in The Nation 5-21-07
Helping Bush Grease the Way to War
In October 2002, as Congress was about to vote to grant George W. Bush the authority to invade Iraq, Democratic Senator, Carl Levin forced the CIA to declassify intelligence analyses indicating it was unlikely that Saddam Hussein would strike the United States with unconventional weapons or share such arms with anti-American terrorists. But CIA director George Tenet undermined the political punch of of this disclosure by stating publicly that CIA's view was not inconsistent with Bush's claim that Iraq posed an immediate and direct WMD threat. Moreover, Tenet's CIA at the same time revealed that there had been "senior level contacts" between Iraq and Al Qaeds. This suggested that Saddam was in league with the 9/11 murderers. Unmentioned was that CIA analysts had concluded there was no evidence of significant ties between Baghdad and Osama bin Laden. With this misleading disclosure, Tenet helped Bush grease the way to war.
As Tenet recounts this episode in his new book, "At the Center of the Storm," he concedes he was wrong to have bent to a request from National Security Adviser, Condolezza Rice to issue this public comment. But he neglects to mention release of the intelligence that appeared to link Saddam to Al Qaeda. Here's the Tenet formula in a nutshell: Accept some blame while blaming others and sidestepping inconvenient matters.
Tenet acknowledges that the CIA failed to act on pre-9/11 leads and botched the WMD issue. But he ducks a critical charge: He and his agency disregarded warning signs about the WMD intelligence that was being oversold by by the White House. For instance, Tenet downplays questions raised within the agency about the credibility of Curveball--the fabricator who claimed Iraq had mobile bioweapons labs--and ignores previously disclosed emails that document this internal debate.
It's hard to tell the unvarnished truth about oneself (and one's agency) ; its easier to do so about others. And Tenet does unload. He notes that the Administration never seriously considered options other than full-scale war on Iraq and it did not ponder the implications of "what would come next." Its prewar WMD rhetoric, he writes, "seemed considerably ahead of the intelligence we had been gathering.," and the Administration ignored prewar assessments of troubles that could arise following an invasion.Tenet also shows how calamitous postinvasion decisions were not rigorously discussed before being implemented.
This is a profound indictment, but Tenet never faults Bush. He aims mostly at Vice President Dick Cheney and the neocons. Cheney, Tenet notes, made claims about Iraq's WMD that were not even supported by the CIA's overstated intelligence. On one occasion, Tenet had to kill an over-the-top Cheney speech on the unproven Al Qaeda -Iraq connection. Before and after the invasion, the neocons relentlessly promoted Ahmad Chalabi, a controversial Iraqi exile and schemer, as the solution to whatever the problem of the moment was. Condolezza Rice was "remote," did little in response to pre-9/11 warnings and failed to broker Iraq policy in an effective manner. Defense Secretary Rumsfeld was out of touch with reality in Iraq.Tenet also slams David Kay, whom Tenet hired to lead the WMD search in postinvasion Iraq. Kay's crime? Not leaving his post quietly but instead telling the press and Congress that there were no WMDs to be found. In all this, Bush, inexplicably, is blameless.
Tenet's book is gripping (thanks to co-author Bill Harlow, a novelist and former CIA spokesman). But it's self-serving and partial. Tenet never holds himself fully accountable for his prime mistake: not paying sufficient attention to prewar questions about both the WMD intelligence and the postinvasion planning and not speaking out about his and the Administration's multiple failures until now (when he is making millions of dollars with his mea-quasi-culpa). All his explaining and blaming cannot cover up an undeniable fact: Tenet was not merely at the center of a disastrous storm; he helped create it.