my full question is found at :
Scientists have proven that organic life can be generated if you have the correct ingredients (primordial soup as you say it) and time and chance.
The point isn't that something knows how to replicate itself or not. Simply that things that replicate themselves in some basic way are more probable to survive than those which don't.
I don't wish to argue against God, or the existence of God. Simply, if you are a creationist you must look at the balance of evidence and see that there is a wealth of evidence against you, and none on your side. If you are a rational thinker, then you must realize that you should consider evolution to be correct on balance of probability.
Thus I suppose an answer is that creationist are incapable of reasoned thought. But this is a little satisfying is it not?