Are you asking about people in general or in certain situations or on an individual basis? Your question is not clear enough for me to give you a definitive answer. So I will give a broad answer. How do you know what is logical or illogical? When the word "we" is used, it is, presumably, coming from a perspective of inclusion; there is also an assumption or presumption that the"we" is standing on common ground. So if "we" choose to deal with those outside of "we" logically, aren't we assuming that "they" expect that?
If "we" decide to deal with "them" illogically, aren't "we" stepping outside of "our" mindset to be logical? Or have "we" penned rules and regulations for when "we" are decisively illogical?
Have "we" established what is logical or illogical? Have those outside of "we" agreed with those standards? A lot to think about.