ArtsAutosBooksBusinessEducationEntertainmentFamilyFashionFoodGamesGenderHealthHolidaysHomeHubPagesPersonal FinancePetsPoliticsReligionSportsTechnologyTravel

20 Best Female Figure Skaters of All Time

Updated on June 21, 2019

Ever since the European Figure Skating Championships kicked off in the late 19th century, in 1891 precisely, figure skating as a sport has evolved in quantum scale. The evolution figure skating took has been so dramatic that today some even doubt whether "figure skating" as we know it today is really "figure skating", because "figure skating" was originally all about "compulsory figures" in which skaters were meant to do well in drawing geometric shapes on ice using the blade of their skates and would be judged on how well they did. Compulsory figures were nothing like today's figure skating let alone no skaters today are competing for compulsory figures, from which the "figure" of figure skating was actually derived. During its long but gradual evolution, the sport begat many stars whose name would be remembered forever. In this ever evolving sport, figure skaters were not just athletes who competed to win but, as part of the sport, creators and inventors whose spirit became the seed of figure skating as a living organism that evolved like no other sport. It was a sport that has been constantly transforming, feeding on visionary philosophies and athletic brilliance shared and nurtured in its rich history to become the unforgettable legacies for generations to come.

Madge Syers: First giant of Pre-class Figure Skating

Born in 1881, Syers, whose real name is Florence Madeline Syers, competed in the 1902 Worlds and won a silver medal. What makes this British figure skater so special is that no one at the time thought figure skating competition was for ladies. Syers' entry to all-men's events was by itself sensational, and she beat all odds to take silver. This prompted the ISU to introduce ladies competitions, and not surprisingly, Syers became the winner of the first two ladies' events in 1906 and 1907, and she also took a gold medal in the 1908 Olympics, which was the first Olympic figure skating gold in history.

Lily Kronberger

Born in 1890, Lily Kronberger was a four time World Champion from 1908 to 1911. She was also the first figure skater who won a World Championship gold for Hungary and the first skater who used music in free program for the first time in history.

Herma Szabo: Champion in Pre-classic Figure Skating

Born in 1902, Herma Szabo was a five time World Champion in ladies singles from 1922 to 1926 and won in the 1924 Olympics. This Vienna born figure skater, whose skating was exceptional among her contemporary has a peculiar credit to remember. Sazbo, having lived in the time when female skaters dressed much conservatively compared to today's female skaters, is credited for her wearing a skirt cut above the knee for the first time, although Sonja Henie is usually known for her being the first skater who wore short skirts in competition. Szabo won all major international competitions she entered from 1922 to 1926. With her five consecutive World titles in ladies' figure skating from 1922 to 1926, Szabo she was one of four women who won the World title five times - Sonja Henie, Carol Heiss, and Michelle Kwan. Szabo's competitive career was not limited to only ladies singles; she also competed in pairs and won the World title twice, in 1925 and 1927, which made her the only skater to hold titles for pairs and singles simultaneously.

Sonja Henie : Greatest of Pre-classic Figure Skating

Born in 1912, Sonja Henie was one of the most influential figure skaters of all time. This Norwegian star skater was a three time Olympic Champion in Ladies Figure Skating, a six-time European Champion and a ten- time World Champion in 1927 through 1936. No skater ever dominated the sport as Henie had done. Never. Henie's three Olympic gold medals is now considered as untouchable. In her 10 long year tenure, Henie ruled the sport like an immortal queen of ice, immensely popular and successful even in her off ice career. Henie was also one of the highest paid stars in Hollywood.

Barbara Ann Scott: First ice princess

Born in 1928, Barbara Ann Scott was a two-time World Champion, a four-time Canadian Champion and won a gold medal in the 1948 Olympics. As her public nick name "Canada's Sweetheart" indicates Scott was an iconic figure of ladies figure skating in her time. From 1944 to 1948, Scott won all international competitions she had entered. She was the only Canadian to have won a gold medal in Olympic ladies singles, and, like Sonja Henie, Scott was also a sought-out star in various off-ice shows.

Tenley Albright: Pioneer of Classic Figure Skating

Tenley Albright, born in 1935, was perhaps the most underrated female figure skater of all time. Albright was a two time World champion for 1953 and 1955 and a U.S. champion from 1952 to 1956. She won silver medal in the 1952 Olympics, and in 1956 she finally became the first American female skater to win an Olympic gold medal. Free skating as we know it today wasn't possible without Albright. Her mastery of free skating was simply incomparable at the time, especially incorporating her moves into music, which was beyond what her contemporary skaters were capable of. Even Carol Heiss, one of the greatest champions of all time, looked dwarfed by Albright's towering skills. To Heiss, Albright was someone she consistently challenged but always came short in terms of figure skater as a whole. Tenley Albright was a skater who pioneered free skating as a coordinated art performance of skating with music.

Carol Heiss: Greatest champion in Classic Figure Skating

Born in 1940, Heiss was a five-time World Champion from 1956 to 1960 and won a gold medal in the 1960 Olympics, following the footstep of her predecessor Tenley Albright. Heiss was noted for her talent as early as 11 when she won the U.S. Novice Ladies' Championship. Heiss's career was characterized by her complete dominance throughout her career. As a matter of fact, Heiss's dominance could have been longer without Tenley Albright who had always overshadowed Heiss in her early career. From 1953 to 1956, Heiss claimed no title, finishing behind Albright in all major international competitions including the 1956 Olympics. It was in the 1956 Worlds that Heiss finally beat Albright for the first time. Thereafter, Heiss became one of three women to have won five consecutive World Championships. From 1956 to 1960, during which time she was unrivaled, Heiss won all competitions she had entered. Heiss, known as the first female skater that landed a double axel, precisely in 1953, is remembered as one of the most competitive figure skaters of all time.

Peggy Fleming: Epitome of Classic Figure Skating

Born in 1948, Peggy Fleming was a household name for ladies figure skating in the 1960s, still is today and perhaps will remain so. Fleming was a gold medalist in the 1967 Olympics as well as a three time World Champion from 1966 to 1968. Fleming was only 9 year old when she first took to ice. In 1961, when she was 12, a tragic news struck her; her skating coach, Bill Kipp was killed by a plane crash in which the entire U.S. figure skating team had perished. This could have put a stop to the ongoing legacy of the U.S. figure skating, but Fleming, the then junior skater who was considered by many as the only hope for U.S. ladies figure skating, quickly stepped up to reshape the tradition of the U.S. ladies figure skating by winning five U.S. titles and three world titles in addition to her decisive victory in the 1968 Winter Olympics. Peggy Fleming not only presented a complete vision of Classic Figure Skating but also lay a classic model for Modern Figure Skating with her aestheticism. Especially, Fleming's skating brought to the sport a new awakening to what ladies figure skating ought to be with aesthetic emphasis of lines and extensions.

Janet Lynn : Founder of Modern Figure Skating

Janet Lynn is a figure of mythical intrigue in the history of figure skating. Born in 1953, Lynn was a two-time worlds medalist and a five-time U.S. Champion and won a bronze medal in the 1972 Olympics. Lynn's skating career started as early as 4, when she made her first public skating performance. At 13, Lynn landed triple salchow jumps which female skaters at the time rarely attempted. Lynn's jumping technique was astounding and far ahead of her time, especially her control mechanism that made her ethereal skating possible, but Lynn never won a single major international competition. Lynn's failure to clinch a major title due to her weak compulsory performances, however, made people doubt the validity of the competition format at the time that consisted of compulsories and free skating, 60% and 40%, respectively. Lynn's skating illuminated people that the ultimate end of ladies figure skating lies with aesthetic embodiment of free skating, not compulsories. Compulsories are an important discipline, providing skaters with fundamental skills, but they are vital means, not products themselves. As a result, the old school compulsories began to phase out and in 1990, they finally ceased to be a part of competition.

Dorothy Hamill : The one and only skater

Born in 1956, Dorothy Hamill won a gold medal in the 1976 Olympics and also won the 1976 Worlds. Like Janet Lynn, Hamill was also from Chicago, Illinois. Hamill started skating at 8. From 1974 to 1976 Hamill reigned as a U.S. Champion but she didn't dominate international competitions the way Peggy Fleming did. Despite her skills and performances that stood out among her competitors, in the 1974 Worlds Hamill finished second to Christine Errath from East Germany, and in the following year, Hamill again settled with silver. This mainly stems from judging incompetence at the time swayed by international politics; Hamill, if judged correctly, should have swept all competitions. It was in the 1976 Worlds that Hamill finally won the long-due gold medal. Hamill's skating was characterized by power and speed with technical brilliance while aesthetically attractive like Lynn's and Fleming's, which was so rare in her contemporary as well as even after

Pick your own choice!

Besides 20 listed here, who do you like to include in top 20?

See results

Linda Fratianne in 1977

Linda Fratianne: First triple jumper

Linda Fratianne, perhaps one of the most underrated skaters in history, was the first female skater who landed two different types of triple jumps, toe loop and salchow in 1976. Born in 1960, Linda Fratianne was a U.S. Champion in 1977 to 1980 and won gold in the 1977 Worlds and silver in the 1980 Winter Olympics. Fratianne, too, like her predecessors Fleming, Lynn or Hamill, could have dominated her time; however, Fratianne balked at compulsories, and was a victim of the so called "Cold War on ice" where she got marked down by judges from the Eastern Europe. In 1980, Fratianne appeared to have reserved an Olympic gold for U.S., but she ended up behind Annet Pötzsch. Many thought that Fratianne was "robbed" of the gold medal by Eastern-bloc judges.

Denise Biellmann in 1981

Denise Biellmann: Sensation in the 1980s

Born in 1962, Denise Biellmann was a sensation in the fledgling Modern Figure Skating conceived in Janet's Lynn's vision. This three time Swiss National Champion won the 1981 Worlds and European Championships. Denise Biellmann was an exceptional prodigy early on. At 11, she won the Swiss junior figure skating championships, and at 14, she finished second in free skating in the 1977 European Championships. At 15, Biellmann again competed in the 1978 European Championships and became the first female skater to land triple lutz. Biellmann won free skating after receiving a 6.0 on technical merits and finished fourth overall. Like those legendary skaters before her, Denise Biellmann too was weak in compulsories. In the 1980 Olympics, Biellmann won the free skating but finished fourth overall. Although Biellmann today is remembered mostly by her innovative move called Biellman spin, Biellmann wasn't just a skater of outstanding flexibility; she was the best free skater in her time with incredible technical agility.

Elaine Zayak in 1982

Elaine Zayak: Master jumper the ISU feared

Born in 1965, Elaine Zayak won the 1982 Worlds, and that's the only major international title she had. In the 1982 Worlds Zayak landed six triple jumps, four of which were triple toe loops. Zayak was the first female skater who landed triples consistently, which prompted the ISU to enact what would later be known as Zayak Rule in which skaters are not allowed to repeat same triples. Consequently, since 1982, Zayak, whose jumping ability seemed far superior to her peers, didn't win any title. Her poor compulsories and Zayak Rule the ISU had introduced to check the potential coup by jumping beans got the better unfortunately. Zayak's jumping technique was brilliant undoubtedly, but she wasn't warmly welcome to a society of figure skating. Especially, Peggy Fleming, whose aesthetic skating became a classic model of ladies figure skating, wasn't ready to give her nod to Zayak. Fleming raised her concerns with Zayak's skating very openly and frequently, and the ISU agreed with her that jumping beans should not be the main stream of ladies figure skating. However justifiable Zayak rule may seem in terms of ladies figure skating's vision, it is also incontrovertibly right to say that Zayak was unjustly penalized only because she was too ahead of her own time.

Katarina Witt: Iron skater in the 1980s.

Born in 1965, Witt was a four time Worlds Champion, a six time European Champion from 1983 to 1988 and won two Olympic golds in 1984 and 1988. This East Germany born legend beat the then reigning World Champion Rosalynn Sumners though the winning margin was very small. Although Witt was one of the most successful skaters of all time in competition, she was constantly challenged by her potent rivals, Debi Thomas, Elizabeth Manley, Rosalyn Sumners, etc. But in the end it was Witt that came out victorious. As a skater Witt was quite deficient compared to her competitors. Witt wasn't equipped with Thomas's extensions and lines, wasn't capable of being elegant like Sumners, and wasn't polished like Manley. Witt's upper body moves were comparatively inferior to most of her competitors and suffered lack of flexibility, but she was always capable of landing jumps in competition with a mouthful of drama. Witt's competitiveness lies with her stamina and power and especially her audacious drive of performance in competition. With her iron power, Witt bulldozed her competitors off the field all the time. Witt will be remembered as one of the most competitive skaters of all time as her two time Olympic win will be likely to remain unchallenged so soon.

Midori Ito in 1989

Midori Ito: Power jumper in the 1980s.

Born in 1969, Midori Ito was the 1989 World champion and won the 1992 Olympic silver. This nine time Japanese National champion was also the first skater who landed a triple-triple jump combination and a triple axel in competition. Ito also became the first woman to land seven triple jumps in a free skating competition in 1988. Ito, who had started skating at the age of 4, reportedly landed her first triple jump at 8. In her senior debut in 1983, Ito finished second to Katarina Witt, who would win in a few months later her first Olympic gold. Ito earned five 6.0s in the 1989 Worlds where she became the first Asian skater who had ever taken a World title. Like many great skaters prior to Ito, Ito was also weak in compulsories. But Ito had no rival for jump. As far as jump is concerned for ladies figure skating (as well as men figure skating) no skater has ever left a greater impact to the sport like Ito. Simply, the world had never before witnessed more powerful and more dominant a jumper than Ito. Ito's jumping ability even surpassed male skaters. Scott Hamilton once said "It will be 50 years before we see anything like Midori Ito again."

Oksana Baiul in 1993

Oksana Baiul: Best in the 1990s.

Born in 1977, Oksana Baiul was the 1993 World champion as well as the 1994 Olympic champion. Baiul, who had finished second to Surya Bonaly in the 1993 European Championships, won the 1993 Worlds at the age of just 15. In 1994 Olympics, Baiul won a gold medal, this time having out-skated Nancy Kerrigan and Chen Lu. Having accomplished so much at so young an age of 16, this Ukrainian genius decided to retire to many's surprise, mainly due to her financial difficulty. Surprisingly though, her being the first Ukrainian skater to win an Olympic gold as well as the first Ukrainian Olympic champion for Ukraine didn't help her much financially. Despite Baiul's reign was short, Baiul's skating was a testament for what had been missing in ladies figure skating in her days. In her days skaters were busy throwing triples without due qualities and figure skating judging wasn't particularly encouraging skaters to learn properly all the skills to make them well-rounded.

Michelle Kwan: Champion of the 1990s

Michelle Kwan, born in 1980, is arguably the most decorated U.S. figure skater up to date. Kwan was a five-time World Champion and a nine-time U.S. Champion. Kwan's tenure stretched over a decade, during which time Kwan remained not only as America's most popular figure skater but as one of America's most popular female athletes. Kwan won eight consecutive U.S. titles and also twelve consecutive U.S. Championship medals. She also received 57 perfect marks under 6.0 system. Despite her monumental achievement and long career, Kwan failed to win an Olympic gold. In both 1998 and 2002, she, as a favorite to win, ended up with silver. Ever since Kwan, no U.S. female skater has been able to follow her steps.

Tara Lipinski: One of greatest prodigies

Born in 1982, Tara Lipinski was the 1997 World champion and the 1998 Olympic champion. Lipinski was the youngest person(14 years, 9 months and 10 days) who ever won a World title and the youngest person (15 years, 8 months, and 10 days) who won Olympic gold in ladies singles until 2014 when Julia Lipnitskaya became the youngest Olympic gold medalist in ladies figure skating, six days younger than Lipinski. In the 1997 U.S. Nationals, Lipinski also became the youngest person to win the title at 14. Despite her extraordinary talent as a skater, Lipinski didn't necessarily overcome Kwan during her rivalry with Michelle Kwan. Lipinsky's jumping ability might be on a par with Kwan, but not quite so in quality. Lipinsky's advantage lies with her edge control and expressiveness. Lipinsky's victory over Michelle Kwan in the 1988 Olympics might not be cut and dried for some, but still clearly shows that she was a worthy opponent of Kwan the Great.


Irina Slutskaya: Strongest in the 1990s

Born in 1979, Irina Slutskaya is arguably the most successful ladies' singles skater in Russian history. Slutskaya was a two-time World champion and a seven-time European champion and a four time Russian champion. Slutskaya was also one of Kwan's fierce rival, and her rivalry with Michelle Kwan continued over a decade, during which time Slutskaya challenged the best skaters of her time, Michelle Kwan, Tara Lipniski, Chen Lu, etc. In the 1992 Olympics, Slutskaya could have won an Olympic gold, had she won free skating, but judges declared Hughes' victory in free skating with a 5–4 decision. This made Russia file a complaint against the result unsuccessfully. In 2001, Slutskaya won all competitions she had entered except the Worlds. In this particular season Slutskaya met Kwan five times and defeated Kwan five times. But it was in 2002 that Slutskaya finally captured her first World title.

Yuna Kim: Greatest in triple era

Born in 1990, Yuna Kim is the latest legend of ladies singles and arguably one of the greatest of all time. Kim won the 2010 Olympic champion, a two time World champion and a six time South Korean champion. Kim is also largely regarded as the legitimate champion of the 2014 Sochi Olympics where the judging panel was alleged to inflate scores in favor of Adelina Sotnikova. After Sochi, Kim retired. Kim was the first female skater to win four major competitions: Olympics, Worlds, Four Continents, and Grand Prix Final. Kim made her senior debut through the 2006 Skate Canada and won bronze. It was, however, in 2009 that she finally won her first World title. In the following year, Kim won the Olympic gold to become the first figure skater to win any Olympic medal for South Korea. Remarkably, during her entire career, Kim never finished in competition off the podium, which was unprecedented in the history of figure skating and still is until now. Kim owned the podium.


Comments

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment
    • profile image

      cagatlin 

      5 months ago

      Surya Bonaly !!!!! Why is she not anywhere in the top 20 or on any list ?

    • profile image

      Yunawhatimean 

      14 months ago

      There's a reason why Mao is not on the list, and was never considered a rival to Yuna. Mao's jumps were never corrected with her flutz and frequent URs. Also, she never had the speed and wide coverage of ice. If you saw them Live, you'd have known what I mean.

      This goes for Yulia Liptniskaya. Her jumps were so little and juniorish. She was a spinner, not what I'd describe an overall figure skater. If the Olympics were not in Sochi, there was no way in hell she would have won anywhere near Gold. Her coach Eteri never taught her students the correct forms of jumps, thus the usual flutzing.

      Btw, figure skating was not part of Summer Olympics before 1994. Winter and Summer Olympics were held the same year. And it was in 1994 Winter Games to be held every 4 years, while Summer Games continued the regular year cycle in 1992. 1992 was the last year the both Games had in the same year with Summer Barcelona and Winter Albertville, France.

    • Glecerio Tatoy profile image

      Cerio 

      15 months ago

      Such a great list of figure skaters. All of them were awesome and competitive.

      Thanks for sharing, Jesse Helms!

    • Nargiza profile image

      Ergashov Hurmatillo 

      16 months ago

      This is the best article that i have read this month. from my childhood i have been in love wit the figure skating because figure skating is one of the most exhilarating sports ever. At the professional level, men and women will do dangerous revolution jumps requiring massive amounts of skill and power. They will spin rapidly at high speeds, trying to achieve the highest score possible. Figure skaters have to be strong yet graceful.

      Think about the Triple Axel. For this tough, revolution jump, you take off from your left foot while going forwards and spin three and a half times in the air. Finally, you have to land gracefully on your right foot. To be able to spin three and a half times in the air requires enormous power. Then, you have to have the skill to stop spinning and land gracefully on your right foot.

      Before 1994, figure skating competitions had been included in the Summer Olympics. Now, it is an official competition category in the Winter Olympics. This should make the sport considered "serious competition. " Every four years, millions of people convene together to watch professional figure skaters compete for the Olympic gold medal. And even more people watch this sport on television.

      It is obvious that people who judge figure skating don't actually know much about this sport. Figure skating requires a combination of power, skill, and grace.

      My favorite skater is Julia Lipnitskaia. She is a Russian skater. Yulia Lipnitskaia became an Olympic champion at the age of 15, setting a new record in women’s single skating. In Sochi, she placed first in both the free skate and short program segments, helping Team Russia win the gold medal. Though Lipnitskaya finished only fifth in individual competition, she emerged as one of the symbols of the Russian national team’s success in 2014.

      Although she has been retired in 2017, at the age of 19, she remains the best figure-skater in the world for me.

    • Nargiza profile image

      Ergashov Hurmatillo 

      16 months ago

      This is the best article that i have read this month. from my childhood i have been in love wit the figure skating because figure skating is one of the most exhilarating sports ever. At the professional level, men and women will do dangerous revolution jumps requiring massive amounts of skill and power. They will spin rapidly at high speeds, trying to achieve the highest score possible. Figure skaters have to be strong yet graceful.

      Think about the Triple Axel. For this tough, revolution jump, you take off from your left foot while going forwards and spin three and a half times in the air. Finally, you have to land gracefully on your right foot. To be able to spin three and a half times in the air requires enormous power. Then, you have to have the skill to stop spinning and land gracefully on your right foot.

      Before 1994, figure skating competitions had been included in the Summer Olympics. Now, it is an official competition category in the Winter Olympics. This should make the sport considered "serious competition. " Every four years, millions of people convene together to watch professional figure skaters compete for the Olympic gold medal. And even more people watch this sport on television.

      It is obvious that people who judge figure skating don't actually know much about this sport. Figure skating requires a combination of power, skill, and grace.

      My favorite skater is Julia Lipnitskaia. She is a Russian skater. Yulia Lipnitskaia became an Olympic champion at the age of 15, setting a new record in women’s single skating. In Sochi, she placed first in both the free skate and short program segments, helping Team Russia win the gold medal. Though Lipnitskaya finished only fifth in individual competition, she emerged as one of the symbols of the Russian national team’s success in 2014.

      Although she has been retired in 2017, at the age of 19, she remains the best figure-skater in the world for me.

    • profile image

      Anon. 

      18 months ago

      Oksana Baiul is from Ukraine, not "Ukrainia".

    • profile image

      Fuc Mao and Shitnikova 

      19 months ago

      Your heads full of garbage. Mao never came close to Kim. Mao admitted it herself in an interview when she said she always thought of Kim as a rival until she retired and thought so otherwise. Mao's triples are no where near as perfect as Kim. Kim's artistic expression also triumphed over Mao. Mao should be on this list. Never in hell should she be number 1. Also, Shitnikova never deserved that gold in Sochi. Russia Russia Russia. Ol fukn cheatin Russia.

    • profile image

      SengIm Dann 

      22 months ago

      I am surprised that three times world championships like Mao Asada as known as legend of figure skater is not on the list as a best female figure skater of all time. I’m so disappointed with America Media such as horrible thing ever.. I want people around the world to remember Mao Asada ever unlike other skaters so boring to watch.. Mao Asada is the best figure skater of all time

    • profile image

      Lookthruillusions 

      24 months ago

      Correction Chen Lu skated to Butterfly Lover not Madame Butterfly at the Olympics 1998 a performance I love.

      I apologize for the double posts but I have not used this system before and in editing my comments and transferring them from word I accidentally duplicated them in the confusion.

    • profile image

      Lookthruillusions 

      24 months ago

      Despite her difficulties because of back and much more knee injuries and illnesses in her comeback and her chronic underscoring , Mao added to her legacy of legendary performances with her Madame Butterfly at the Japan Open 2015 and Worlds 2016, a performance that one of the people I showed it to who happens to be a senior citizen from the US claimed was the most beautiful performance they had ever seen, and her Cup of China SP 2015. Her skating skills, dancing and expression remained magnificent even injured in her last season like her Bach Cello Suite exhibition that was like a time tunnel and precious jewel of high classical art and ballet and even in her last performance when she was injured she still landed the triple flip and loop and a clean triple lutz with excellent flow, posture and minimal pre-rotation and had the best skating skills and step sequences.

      While Mao has given my favorite performances of all the skaters on this list like her Rach II LP at Sochi LP, Nocturne at Worlds 2014, her Sochi LP, Worlds 2010 LP and Madame Butterfly at Worlds 2016 among others, I admit that my desert island performances would also include those from Chen Lu like Worlds 1996 LP a competition which I firmly believe she should have won (again underscored because of the elephant in the room much like Mao), and her Madame Butterfly at the Olympics in 1998, Midori Ito's Worlds 1989 and 1990 LP and Denise Biellmann's 1980 LP. In my view, Mao is a skater who appeals to me because of her personal ideal of a great performance that isn't merely constructed to play for points in what I consider to be a highly dubious, limited and often corrupt system. In this sense, she very much comes across as a revolutionary artist and athlete who may not always attain her goal, but when she does she overwhelms me with transcendent beauty and powerful athletic elements and artistic elemements in a way no other on this list does.

    • profile image

      Lookthruillusions 

      24 months ago

      Though Mao had difficulty in her comeback because of back and much more knee injuries and illnesses, She still added to the legacy of her classic but highly underscored performances of Madame Butterfly at the Japan Open and Worlds 2016, a performance that one of the people I showed it to said was the most beautiful performance they have ever seen and Mao's Cup of China SP. Mao's skating skills, expression and dancing skills continued to improve to the end and even in her last performance she still landed a triple flip and loop and clean triple lutz even while she was injured. Personally, I think Mao has given the greatest performances of anyone on this list, though objectively speaking outside of my own preference I would say that Midori Ito, Lu Chen and Denise Biellman have also given some of the greatest performances of the skaters on the list. I think the best way for Mao to be appreciated is to take her best performances save them and give them to someone 100 years from now outside of the forces and system that seemed almost specially designed to undermine her scores and amazing array of talented qualities in her skating.

    • profile image

      Lookthruillusions 

      24 months ago

      Mao Asada should definitely be on the list. Yet, she was at a huge disadvantage because of the elephant in the room that is so often ignored in these kinds of lists but is discussed endlessly on videos so it is very prevalent especially among those who watch a lot. That is the extreme bias in scoring so that one skater is lowballed (like Mao Asada) compared to others like Yuna Kim, Evgenia Medvedeva, Gracie Gold, Ashley Wagner, Carolina Kostner who received big advantages in scoring compared to Mao. Comments on videos indicate this is the case and it would take a long time and probably a lot of argument to explain why but to ignore its influence is to my mind to be blind to the reality of figure skating. However, I can understand Yuna Kim being on this list because of the impact her performances have made on many people, though I prefer Mao much more and here are the reasons why.

      In terms of the variety and quality of elements put into her programs and the depth of emotional resonance and artistry, I feel that Mao has given some of the greatest performances ever. She has landed the triple axel and triple flip and loop more than any other woman skater, again tech calls have often been rigged or highly questionable and heavy pre-rotation of over 180 is ignored, so I am going by what the eye sees in real time not what the biased microscopes of tech crews focus on or minute touches of the ice that can't be seen in real time and that often contradict the high GOE given by judges before often overly harsh or bogus calls are made. Furthermore, Mao also had a great triple flip / double loop / double loop. She also maintained very erect posture and symmetrical air position through her jumps including a very erect landing position which is unusual. Furthermore, she had great flair of her arms on exit to her jumps and in her artistic expression and a great flow in and out of her jumps as her Sochi LP demonstrates so well. She also has the ability to combine effortless speed which is shown by her huge rink coverage on heat maps like in her Sochi LP in which she placed all her jumps in the far corners of the rink in rapid succession all while doing intricate transitions and one legged and swaying movements in her skating. Heat maps belie her relatively low PCS scores because they show that with minimal pumping of the legs and arms she often had the greatest rink coverage among her competitors. Furthermore, Mao combined this power with prima ballerina qualities such as spectacular spirals (like the cross grab Biellmann, fan spiral and arabesque while carving sharp arcs and even semi-circles in the ice with her excellent blade work. She also had outstanding Biellmanns including gorgeous variations on the one handed Biellmann, a magnificent classical Biellmann, a picturesque I spin, the lowest sit spin with the unqiue quaity of touching the blade with her hands, and marvelous musicality and symmetry of revolution in her illusion spin when incorported into fabulous step sequences with professional dance isntructors praising her for producing rare moments of effortless dancing. Finally,

      Mao did have difficult times when reworking her jumps from 2010-2012 while her mother was ill with cancer and she battled a bad knee injury and multiple cases of the flu when she returned to competition in 2015. This injury could have very well been caused because she was seen icing her knee after skating in very soft and slushy ice conditions in an overheated arena at the Cup of China 2015 LP. This is one example of the negligence of the ISU and nobody in that competition should have had to risk their health and career to skate in such horrible conditions.

      In terms of championships, Mao should be in the list because even with very harsh scoring in major championships she still has won more World and Grand Prix Final championships than any other woman from Asia. And to my mind, she should have won one more of each, including 2007 Worlds and 2007 Grand Prix Final. In any case, she gave the best long program performances in both competitions. Furthermore, Mao's Sochi LP to me was the greatest Olympic freeskate I have seen.

    • profile image

      Lookthruillusions 

      24 months ago

      Mao Asada should definitely be on the list. Yet, she was at a huge disadvantage because of the elephant in the room that is so often ignored in these kinds of lists but is discussed endlessly on videos so it is very prevalent especially among those who watch a lot. That is the extreme bias in scoring so that one skater is lowballed (like Mao Asada) compared to others like Yuna Kim, Evgenia Medvedeva, Gracie Gold, Ashley Wagner, Carolina Kostner who received big advantages in scoring compared to Mao. Comments on videos indicate this is the case and it would take a long time and probably a lot of argument to explain why but to ignore its influence is to my mind to be blind to the reality of figure skating. However, I can understand Yuna Kim being on this list because of the impact her performances have made on people, though I prefer Mao much more and here are the reasons why.

      In terms of the variety and quality of elements put into her programs and the depth of emotional resonance and artistry, I feel that Mao has given some of the greatest performances ever. She has landed the triple axel and triple flip and loop more than any other skater, again tech calls have often been rigged and heavy pre-rotation of over 180 is ignored, so I am going by what the eye sees in real time not what the biased microscopes of tech crews focus on or minute touches of the ice that can't be seen in real time and that often contradict the high GOE given by judges before often overly harsh or bogus calls are made. Furthermore, Mao also had a great triple flip / double loop / double loop. She also maintained very erect posture and symmetrical air position through her jumps including a very erect landing position which is unusual. Furthermore, she had great flair of her arms on exit to her jumps and in her artistic expression and a great flow in and out of her jumps as her Sochi LP demonstrates so well. She also has the ability to combine effortless speed which is shown by her huge rink coverage on heat maps like in her Sochi LP in which she placed all her jumps in the far corners of the rink in rapid succession all while doing intricate transitions and one legged and swaying movements in her skating. Heat maps belie her relatively low PCS scores because they show that with minimal pumping of the legs and arms she often had the greatest rink coverage among her competitors. Furthermore, Mao combined this power with prima ballerina qualities such as spectacular spirals (like the cross grab Biellmann, fan spiral and arabesque while carving sharp arcs and even semi-circles in the ice with her excellent blade work. She also had outstanding Biellmanns including gorgeous variations on the one handed Biellmann, a magnificent classical Biellmann, a picturesque I spin, the lowest sit spin with the unqiue quaity of touching the blade with her hands, and marvelous musicality and symmetry of revolution in her illusion spin when incorported into fabulous step sequences with professional dance isntructors praising her for producing rare moments of effortless dancing. Finally,

      Mao did have difficult times when reworking her jumps from 2010-2012 while her mother was ill with cancer and she battled a bad knee injury and multiple cases of the flu when she returned to competition in 2015. This injury could have very well been caused because she was seen icing her knee after skating in very soft and slushy ice conditions in an overheated arena at the Cup of China 2015 LP. This is one example of the negligence of the ISU and nobody in that competition should have had to risk their health and career to skate in such horrible conditions.

      In terms of championships, Mao should be in the list because even with very harsh scoring in major championships she still has won more World and Grand Prix Final championships than any other woman from Asia. And to my mind, she should have won one more of each, including 2007 Worlds and 2007 Grand Prix Final. In any case, she gave the best long program performances in both competitions. Furthermore, Mao's Sochi LP to me was the greatest Olympic freeskate I have seen.

    • profile image

      вукакоу 

      2 years ago

      Evgenia Medvedeva is greatest!!!!!

    • profile image

      Miumiu 

      2 years ago

      I have no idea why the 3 time world champion Mao Asada is not listed here. Until recently beaten by Evgenia Medvedeva, Mao had the highest score for the SP.

    • profile image

      AnnBeth 

      3 years ago

      Michelle Kwan is certainly not an overrated skater as much as Rachel Flatt is since she has a huge legitimate talent so under appreciated by her critics who waste their time bashing and hating her simply because she got more attention than anyone else. She deserved a place at the top ten along with the other, while Katarina Witt, certainly talented, doesn't have the same standard of excellence as Michelle Kwan. While Kwan doesn't have the flexibility like Sasha, for example, it doesn't mean that she is 'boring' or 'lacking talent' since her artistry is quite different from Sasha. While Sasha has more of a visual artistry, she isn't 'better' than Michelle per see. Michelle Kwan didn't let Emily Hughes take her place because she was unwilling to compete when in fact that the injuries prevented Michelle Kwan from competing- she has demonstrated that during her tryouts. As the result, Emily Hughes who has a dismal placement as the result, while Sasha certainly couldn't fare any better than Michelle, Michelle proved that she belonged on the ice and when she retired, her legacy will never fade.

    • profile image

      Yunawhatimean 

      3 years ago

      rz7 - your irrational, idiotic comments only make you and the rest Japanese look so bad, dood. Quit acting like an ultimate bakasan.

    • profile image

      Yuko 

      4 years ago

      rz7, you obviously know nothing about figure skating. Yuna had huge jumps all done with correct edges and smooth landings. Her jumps actually do travel from one end of a rink to another. And she is an artist on ice, you should see some of her videos. And the amazing thing is that while many of her main conpetitors came from countries that actually supported the sport, figure skating was unknown in Korea before Yuna. That means she had to do everything on her own. She always had to train in cramped public rinks but still made it to the top. Sure, some skaters may be able to land more jumps, but it's the correct technique and distance and height it gets that really matters. Quality over quantity dude. And do you honestly think if you were to put michelle against yuna, michelle would win? Dont make me laugh...

    • profile image

      Bill 

      4 years ago

      Yuna's jumps are the most standard and correct technically ever which is the reason coaches refer to her jumps as a textbook. It is not a kind of priority to do difficult jumps with wrong edges, underrotation, prerotation, step out and take much more points than deserved. That is the reason dude.

    • profile image

      rz7 

      4 years ago

      Lameness, this farce of a "list" has zero credibility.

      A skater who does the NINTH hardest program in Sochi, with URs everywhere, who was gifted inflation points her entire career...

      How can a skater be "the best, as yet, in triple era" - with only 4 types of triples, and one less than everyone else?! What a joke! Every single champion going back to 1998 had 7 Standard triples, and Kim's 6 triple rigging dragged skating back into the prehistoric ages.

      Most of Yuna's "wins" are by hyperinflation rigging, very few are legitimate, such the rare occasion when everyone else falls down.

      If we go by medal count and western fanbase, Michelle Kwan is #1, if we go by pure athletic and artistic ability, it's anyone but Kim.

    working

    This website uses cookies

    As a user in the EEA, your approval is needed on a few things. To provide a better website experience, hubpages.com uses cookies (and other similar technologies) and may collect, process, and share personal data. Please choose which areas of our service you consent to our doing so.

    For more information on managing or withdrawing consents and how we handle data, visit our Privacy Policy at: https://hubpages.com/privacy-policy#gdpr

    Show Details
    Necessary
    HubPages Device IDThis is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.
    LoginThis is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.
    Google RecaptchaThis is used to prevent bots and spam. (Privacy Policy)
    AkismetThis is used to detect comment spam. (Privacy Policy)
    HubPages Google AnalyticsThis is used to provide data on traffic to our website, all personally identifyable data is anonymized. (Privacy Policy)
    HubPages Traffic PixelThis is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.
    Amazon Web ServicesThis is a cloud services platform that we used to host our service. (Privacy Policy)
    CloudflareThis is a cloud CDN service that we use to efficiently deliver files required for our service to operate such as javascript, cascading style sheets, images, and videos. (Privacy Policy)
    Google Hosted LibrariesJavascript software libraries such as jQuery are loaded at endpoints on the googleapis.com or gstatic.com domains, for performance and efficiency reasons. (Privacy Policy)
    Features
    Google Custom SearchThis is feature allows you to search the site. (Privacy Policy)
    Google MapsSome articles have Google Maps embedded in them. (Privacy Policy)
    Google ChartsThis is used to display charts and graphs on articles and the author center. (Privacy Policy)
    Google AdSense Host APIThis service allows you to sign up for or associate a Google AdSense account with HubPages, so that you can earn money from ads on your articles. No data is shared unless you engage with this feature. (Privacy Policy)
    Google YouTubeSome articles have YouTube videos embedded in them. (Privacy Policy)
    VimeoSome articles have Vimeo videos embedded in them. (Privacy Policy)
    PaypalThis is used for a registered author who enrolls in the HubPages Earnings program and requests to be paid via PayPal. No data is shared with Paypal unless you engage with this feature. (Privacy Policy)
    Facebook LoginYou can use this to streamline signing up for, or signing in to your Hubpages account. No data is shared with Facebook unless you engage with this feature. (Privacy Policy)
    MavenThis supports the Maven widget and search functionality. (Privacy Policy)
    Marketing
    Google AdSenseThis is an ad network. (Privacy Policy)
    Google DoubleClickGoogle provides ad serving technology and runs an ad network. (Privacy Policy)
    Index ExchangeThis is an ad network. (Privacy Policy)
    SovrnThis is an ad network. (Privacy Policy)
    Facebook AdsThis is an ad network. (Privacy Policy)
    Amazon Unified Ad MarketplaceThis is an ad network. (Privacy Policy)
    AppNexusThis is an ad network. (Privacy Policy)
    OpenxThis is an ad network. (Privacy Policy)
    Rubicon ProjectThis is an ad network. (Privacy Policy)
    TripleLiftThis is an ad network. (Privacy Policy)
    Say MediaWe partner with Say Media to deliver ad campaigns on our sites. (Privacy Policy)
    Remarketing PixelsWe may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.
    Conversion Tracking PixelsWe may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.
    Statistics
    Author Google AnalyticsThis is used to provide traffic data and reports to the authors of articles on the HubPages Service. (Privacy Policy)
    ComscoreComScore is a media measurement and analytics company providing marketing data and analytics to enterprises, media and advertising agencies, and publishers. Non-consent will result in ComScore only processing obfuscated personal data. (Privacy Policy)
    Amazon Tracking PixelSome articles display amazon products as part of the Amazon Affiliate program, this pixel provides traffic statistics for those products (Privacy Policy)
    ClickscoThis is a data management platform studying reader behavior (Privacy Policy)