They are both top 10 all time in my opinion, but I would give the nod to Brady. Peyton Manning has always had a better supporting cast. Prior to Randy Moss going to the Patriots, Brady really never had a household name receiver or running back like Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Edgerrin James, Joseph Addai, etc. Brady has accomplished just as much as Manning, with less talent.
You can help the HubPages community highlight top quality content by ranking this answer up or down.