Becker BK2 vs. Schrade SCHF9
Becker Bk2 or Schrade SCHF9 - Better Buy?
Recently I have seen a lot of traffic to my websites with folks looking for a comparison between the Becker BK2 vs. Schrade SCHF9. I personally own both blades and used them extensively. Both have their positives and negatives have similar stats on paper.including the type of steel they are made of relatively similar in size and are marketed towards the same outdoor enthusiast that is looking for a good knife at a competitive price.
Check out my site for all my top picks at Best Survival Knife Choices for the survivalist
Becker BK2 vs. Schrade SCH9 Stats
Lets take a look at a stat comparison
Blade Steel: 1095 High Carbon
Overall Length : 10.25"
Blade Length : 5.25 "
Blade Thickness : .25"
Handle material: Grivoy
Blade Steel: 1095 High Carbon
Overall Length : 12"
Blade Length: 6.64
Blade Thickness: .25"
Weight: 15.9 oz
Handle material: Kraton scales
The overall feel of the Becker BK2 vs. Schrade SCHF9 are quite different. The SCHF9 has a handle that is made with a few different grips options in the design. There is an option to choke up on the knife and use a finger choil that is machined into the blade, a "regular grip with jimping on the spine of the knife where the thumb rests, and an option to choke down on the blade for chopping.
The handle took a bit of time to get used to for me but after I played with the different grip options it was pretty comfortable. The kraton scales are a good material however not as nice to the hands as the Grivory of the BK2.
The Becker BK2 overall feel is a bit more balanced than the SCHF9 and unlike the SCHF9, as soon as you grab the handle of the BK2 your hand knows exactly where to go. The handle is flat out comfortable. Even though there are no designed positions on the handle to choke up, choke down etc, you can still comfortably achieve all of these grips.
The Blades of the BK2 and SCHF9 look similar on paper but are actually very different both in shape and performance. Both have a flat grind, a drop point , .25” thickness and are made of 1095 high carbon steel. However the BK2 has a fatter blade from the spine of the knife to the cutting edge of the steel. The BK2 also retains the .25” tang thickness further towards the tip of the blade, making the knife a more durable prier. It is an overall meatier blade.
The SCHF9 has a longer seemingly more detail oriented blade. The cutting edge has a slight curve inward at the belly of the blade and then curves outward towards the top of the blade like a long shallow “S” shape. I originally thought this would make the knife a more detailed carver but I have not been able to validate that or really see any positives or negatives from that blade shape.
In the chopping test both knives are fairly equal however the Becker BK2 does chop slightly more wood per stroke. The fatter blade seems to make a difference as the overall weight of the BK2 is condensed along a slightly shorter more robust blade. Both do a good job but the Becker, in this test seems to have a slight advantage.
The Baton test is equal across both knives. I thought that the SCHF9 would be easier because of the longer blade but both faired about the same. Both are extremely efficient for the relatively small size of the knives.
The Becker BK2 takes has the advantage over the smaller work. The SCHF9 is harder to control when whittling the finer details. I was able to make a feather stick with the Becker but had a really hard time with the SCHF9 even while choking up on the blade, using the finger choil.
Full Reviews and Chop Tests
The overall impression on both blades is positive, although I like the Becker BK2 over the SCHF9, both have their place in your kit. Since the Schrade SCHF9 is $30 cheaper than the Becker it is definitely a great knife for those that cannot spend the $65 that the Becker BK2 costs. The Becker is no doubt the better knife but if you have to spend less, the SCHF9 is the way to go. Both knives have similar specs and will no doubt last a lifetime but if you are in the market for one knife, spend the extra dollars and go with the Becker you will not be disappointed.