A look at the mini-series "LONESOME DOVE"

Duvall (Left) and Jones (Right)

Two great stars with great on-screen chemestry

LONESOME DOVE


The 1989 television miniseries Lonesome Dove is a very faithful and detailed adaptation of Larry McMurtry’s 1985 novel. The televised version retains the spirit of the book, as well as the themes of male bonding, personal honor, growing up, growing old and dealing with loss. Starring Robert Duvall, Tommy Lee Jones, Diane Lane and Chris Cooper, and co-written by McMurtry himself, the TV movie is an epic retelling of the story done with great fidelity to the source material.

There's something so iconic about the western genre and also so uniquely American. Robert Duvall once said, "The English have Shakespeare; we have the Western." This is a wonderful mini-series based on one of the great modern western novels.

Duvall and Jones perfectly embody the literary versions of the characters Gus McCrea and Woodrow Call. They play two men searching for redefinition in their lives and only finding a lasting value in their lifelong friendship, although that is the last thing they would ever admit. The film keeps this close bond of the characters central to the story. Gus (Robert Duvall) and Call (Tommy Lee Jones) go on the 3,000 mile cattle drive because Gus is hoping to reconnect with a lost love from his youth and Call is hoping for one last frontier to conquer. Despite their illustrious past as renowned Texas Rangers, they don’t have much to show for their lives except each other. As Gus says to Call, “Did it ever occur to you that everything we done was a mistake?” The only thing they really have is their friendship. Toward the end of the story, an old love of Gus’ berates Call for coming between she and Gus, saying that she couldn’t fight Call for Gus’ attention day and night. Duvall and Jones excellently capture the attitude of unspoken affection between two rugged, old-fashioned men, which is the heart of both the literary and televised versions of the story.


From the beginning, we see Call (Jones) chiding Gus (Duvall) for being lazy and for eating and drinking too much. “If you ever get tire of loafing you could get a job waiting tables” Call says. Although the comment is meant as a jibe, Gus doesn’t take the remark to heart. He never does when Call scolds him. Gus just makes a joke about it, recalling his days on a riverboat and simply goes on with what he is doing. The way Duvall plays the scene, with a mirthful smile during the exchange to show that he enjoys their little spats; it demonstrates the comfort he finds in his ritual of needling his old friend.


Call is a very stoic, imperturbable, emotionally controlled man who doesn’t speak unless he’s got something important to say or an order to give. The only why you ever know he is upset is when he’s even more silent than usual. Tommy Lee Jones emulates the literary version of Call by being seemingly dispassionate and only showing hints of emotion at appropriate moments. Jones plays Call with a deadpan look and an often monotone voice. Like the literary Call, the TV version is always intense and authoritative but almost never loses control, except under rare circumstances, such as when he sees his son Newt being beaten by a man named Dixon. Even then, he refuses to admit that emotion was involved in his actions and brushes it off as being the result of his distaste for rude behavior. That scene in the film tells us all we need to know. This scene is well played by Jones who quickly switches from blind, uncontrolled rage back to Call’s usual cold-as-ice demeanor, as if a switch had been pushed.


Duvall’s portrayal of Gus McCrea is wonderfully charming and likable. Duval said that this was his personal favorite role and be makes Gus so personable, with a sense of humor and a hedonistic attitude toward life. We know he prefers gambling, drinking and sex over work and duty. These aspects of Gus are perfectly brought to life by Duvall, who gives Gus a magnetic appeal. After seeing Duvall’s performance, you can understand why Gus is so well liked by everyone in the film. Gus constantly refers to the all-male ranch hands of the Hat Creek Cattle Company as “girls”, which might earn anyone else a punch in the face but no one ever gets mad at Gus. He’s just too likable. It takes an actor with Duvall’s charisma and talent to inject the sort of incredible charm into a character that the viewer feels it right through the screen.

SPOILER:

During the scene where Gus dies, Duvall and Jones do an impressive job of bringing emotion to a scene between two men who would never express emotion to each other. Gus is trying to laugh in the face of impending death while Call is trying to remain as stoic as usual. Duvall and Jones manage to capture the hidden turmoil going on under the character’s outer façade. Gus’ final words in the film are “Woodrow, quite a party.” There is some extra dialogue in the book after that line which isn’t in the TV film, but by making this line Gus’ last, it sums up that his adventures with Woodrow Call were the main substance of his life and what he will be remembered for.


The final scene in the film finds Call alone, having kept his promise to deliver the late Gus’ body to his requested resting place. Call wanders around their old town where they’d run the cattle company for ten years, feeling directionless and lost. Without his life-long friend, Call doesn’t have the motivation or the strength to conquer another frontier. The final scene talks about how an old acquaintance killed himself because he lost the girl he loved. This parallel’s Call’s feeling of being dead inside without Gus. The last line in the film regards a reporter who’s trying to get a few words from the reticent Call. He describes Cal as a man of vision. Call mutters sadly “A hell of a vision”, indicating that his present does match the vision he had of the future because he’s lost too much. He has lost a lot of things and a lot of people in the past and was able to deal with those, but the loss of Gus finally breaks his spirit and leaves him a lost soul.



If you’ve never seen the mini-series’, it’s definitely worth watching.


More by this Author


Comments 13 comments

Don 4 years ago

You said it all brother. ***** 5 stars.


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 4 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY Author

You give it a perfect score, then.


Flora Breen Robison 4 years ago

Thanks for the review. I've still not seen this miniseries. I wasn't watching miniseries at the time it was out, and there are not enough actors for whom I'm fans to get past the fact that it is a western not made during the more family friendly days of classic Hollywood. You know me.....


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 4 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY Author

Hi Flora; I didn't see it when it first came out either but I caught it later. I really liked the cast in this. Duvall, Jones, Chris Cooper, Danny Glover and Diana Lane are all good performers and I enjoy their work.

Interestingly, McMurty based his book on a screenplay he wrote for a film that never finished production. It was supposed to star John Wayne and Jimmy Stewart in the Jones/Duvall roles. Sadly, it never got made.

Thanks for stopping by,

Robert


prairieprincess profile image

prairieprincess 4 years ago from Canada

Rob, I lived in Calgary while they were filming the T.V. show, and my friend at the time was an extra on the film, so I feel a personal connection to that show. I have not seen the movie, though, and it does sound like a good one. I'm not a huge westerns fan but I am a fan of those actors. Thanks for the review!


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 4 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY Author

Hi; Yes, it had a great cast, and Duvall was at his best (And that's saying a lot!) It's eight hours and if you're not a weatern fan, you may not really enjoy it, but I liked it a lot.

Thanks for stopping by,

Rob


epigramman profile image

epigramman 4 years ago

Hi Rob - so sorry I haven't been around much - but love has come calling and I have been fairly busy at my music - cinema group at FB - your hubs are still - and always will be world class all of the way - will post this great tribute to my group with a direct link back here - and I have a copy of this great tv series/movie on VHS - lol lol


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 4 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY Author

Hi Colin; Always good to hear from you. Good to hear from a fellow fan of "Lonesome Dove". Thanks for another link to your page,

Rob


Cogerson profile image

Cogerson 4 years ago from Virginia

Great hub and review on a classic mini-series. After years of hearing about Lonesome Dove....I finally got the chance to watch the movie a few months ago. I agree with your review about the performances of Tommy Lee Jones and Robert Duvall.....two awesome performances by two of the best actors working today. The final scenes of Duvall's passing and Jones keeping his word and scenes that have stayed with me since watching the movie. Great selection and an enjoyable read...voted up and awesome.


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 4 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY Author

Hi Bruce; Glad you enjoyed the series. Duvall and Jones were both fantastic in this. I loved the book too but this is one of the few times I liked the film version better because the performances were spot-on perfect.

Thanks for stoppinbg by, Bruce,

Rob


LaThing profile image

LaThing 4 years ago from From a World Within, USA

Wow, this brings back memories! I didn't watch every episodes but remember it being on and how it was so popular. Great review, enjoyed it..... Thanks for sharing!


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 4 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY Author

Hi; Glad I could bring back some nostalgiac memories.

Thanks for the comment,

Rob


Mel Carriere profile image

Mel Carriere 2 years ago from San Diego California

I really loved the book Lonesome Dove, it is one of my all time favorites and I think a classic of American Literature. The series did it credit, although I think Tommy Lee Jone's portrayal of Woodrow Call could have been a bit more stoic and dispassionate. Duvall was superb as Augustus McCrae and I think I even visualized someone like Robert Duvall as I read the book, prior to watching the movie. Great hub!

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working