You Wanted the Best, You Got the Drama: Kiss and the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Media Merry Go Round

Kiss Enters the Rock N Roll Hall of Fame with Kontroversy

After four decades, Kiss is still in the news again. And all of the news is bad. Long time Kiss fans know Ace and Peter and Paul and Gene are not fond of one another. The feud has been blown wide open into the mainstream press thanks to all the absurd drama surrounding the foursome's Rock and Roll Hall of Fame induction.

The short story is the on/off relationship (probably forever off) between founding members Gene Simmons, Peter Criss, Paul Stanley, and Ace Frehley is off once again. A significant amount of bad blood exists between the members and the band will not play together at the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, breaking tradition at the event. The reasons for the fiasco include:

The Hall of Fame only wishes to induct the original lineup of Kiss and not subsequent members such as the late Eric Carr and Bruce Kulick and current Kiss members Tommy Thayer and Eric Singer. Gene and Paul feel this is unfair since other bands in the Hall of Fame had members outside of the original lineup inducted.

Peter Criss despises the notion that someone else wears the makeup of the Catman persona and also is upset over money he feels he should have received over the original reunion tour. He still harbors ill feelings about the way in which he was fired from the band when he last went on tour with Kiss.

Gene Simmons and Paul Stanley long ago grew weary of what they perceived as unprofessional conduct from Criss and Frehley.

There may even be a money motive.

Radio host Eddie Trunk speculates that Kiss is currently enormously successful as a touring act with Thayer and Singer in the makeup. Presenting Criss and Frehley without the current lineup could create the impression the new Kiss is little more than a cover band. Business could take a hit if that became the dominant impression.

All of this may be playing out like a surprising soap opera to those who are not long time Kiss fans, but those who have followed the band for any length of time would be disappointed if NO drama occurred.

The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Kiss: Late to the Party

Let the truth ring clear: no one at the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame ever wanted Kiss to be inducted. Strange considering the band struck such iconic imagery in the 1970s and sold out venues all over the world while selling millions of albums. The band may have had its heyday in the 1970s, the group was incredibly successfully all throughout the 1980s with only a few lulls here and there. While the original lineup was long gone by 1982, Gene and Paul not only survived, but they thrived (for the most part) in the 1980s. Smashes, Thrashes, and Hits was a multi-platinum seller. 7 years after everyone said Kiss would not last, Hot In The Shade went on to sell a million copies in 1989.


The early 1990s saw Revenge go gold and the tour was fairly well received. Then there was the amazing reunion tour of the late 1990s when the original line up returned once again to sell out arena after arena and more than a few stadiums, too.

Why would the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame be so down on Kiss?

Kiss was always looked at as a crassly commercial gimmick act by those in the music industry that take themselves too seriously.

Say what you will about the group, Kiss never did take itself too seriously. The goal of the band was to put on a fun show and make a lot of money doing it. Gene Simmons never hid this fact in his refreshing honesty. Other bands and musicians wanted as much money as they could get, they just pretended otherwise. Such honesty did not endear them to music critics and certain historians. At some point though, you just have to look at the $$$$ the band made along with Kiss' longevity and realize they are Hall of Fame caliber act.

By the way, A LOT of Kiss' music really is good. The critics were way to harsh on the band since all incarnations of Kiss were able to release NUMEROUS fun hard rock songs. Granted, fun hard rock songs are not what rock critics and reporters find all that appealing.... especially when it sells huge.

The truth is, Kiss was hated even when the band was the hottest act on earth. In a lot of ways, this is what they wanted.

Kiss: Louder Than Loud and On Top of the World

Gene Simmons once said to Henry Rollins ''There are no rock stars left.'' What he means here is there is no one in rock (do they even call it rock anymore? Or is everyone on a quest to be a pop star?) who wants to be larger than life. Musicians seems to run away from the excesses of fame barring one or two here and there. Not so was the case in the 1970s when Kiss was the quintessential band that really defined the era.

Outrageous, over the top, and the antithesis to the both bubblegum bands and those super groups that saw themselves as artistes. Simmons once mentioned he would look at John Denver and cringe that people saw the folkish singer as the face of rock and roll. Simmons said something to the effect he wanted people to see him on stage and think he crawled out from under a rock.

Kiss had a rocky road to the top and were mostly a successful touring band until Alive was released and went platinum. Kiss came out from the underground and became the hottest act in the land overnight after four years of hard work.

Yes, there were bands that sold more concert tickets during the 1970s. Other bands had major album success. Kiss stills remains the most remembered and iconic bands of the Me Decade because Kiss and the 1970s were perfect for one another.

The 1970s were definitely an era of excess. Excess is not always a bad thing. When $50 million (A massive sum in the late 1970s) was spent on the budget for Superman: The Motion Picture, the excess created a unique new motion picture event everyone had to see. Today, movies almost HAVE to have huge budgets and they lose a lot of what makes them special. In the world of rock and roll, things are way worse.

In the aftermath of Vietnam and Watergate, many wanted answers. Others just wanted to have fun and forget so a lot of the 1970s became an era known for just having a lot of mindless fun. Kiss definitely helped those looking for it.

And then there was the dark imagery that really set Kiss apart from the glam pop look of 1970s music.

Somewhat overlooked when it comes to the popularity of Kiss is the role classic horror movies played in their appeal. Simmons' persona of a Bat Demon has horror roots and Frehley's Space Ace persona draws from science-fiction. The Ultimate Star and The Catman are no so much horror influenced but the black and white makeup certainly had a dark, gothic overtone to it. While the Shock Theater TV package horror movie fad of previous generations were over, a lot of 17 kids and 27 year old young adults who made up a large number of Kiss' audience in 1975 remembered those old horror films they loved on late night TV at the age of 7, at least subconsciously.

Kiss' was prominently featured playing songs from Destroyer on the 1976 Paul Lynde Halloween Special, so the horror film imagery and connection is not exactly one that is far fetched. Clearly, someone at ABC saw the connection.

Many factors tied into the success of the band, but it was overexposure and market saturation that caused the decline in 1978/1979. The low years of the band from 1980 to 1983 certainly were also the result of the original lineup leaving and Criss and Frehley being replaced.

A lot of the turmoil between the original members has been well documented.

Books, Sniping in Print, and Cocaine Blues

The first time I came across sniping in print was in the old Rock and Roll Comics three part Kiss bio. There was a Gene Simmons interview and he was quick to mention that Ace and Peter were terminally lazy during the early days when the band was just playing clubs for pocket change. The interview was also where I first learned Criss and Frehley were fired from the band. Drug and alcohol issues definitely played a role in the schism between Criss and Frehley and Simmons and Stanley with Criss admitting he was hopeless addicted to cocaine. During his interview with Eddie Trunk, Criss noted in the 1970s, an enormous amount of people were using cocaine and he never even realized there was a problem with doing the drug until things were far too late.

In time, the members of the band started to go public with their complaints about each other.

Gene Simmons cut loose on Ace and Peter in his book Kiss and Makeup, an entertaining memoir albeit one lacking in depth.

Paul Stanley's Face the Music: A Life Exposed is the newest Kiss autobiography to be released and it follows 2012's outstanding memoir from Peter Criss, From Makeup to Breakup. Even Ace Frehley offered up a less than memorable one some time back as well.

And then there was last year's Nothing to Lose, a memoir focusing on the very early years of Kiss from 1972 to about 1975. Scores of other books have been written about Kiss, many of them being worth the investment.

If there was one common thread among all of them, you quickly realize Gene and Paul do not exactly care very much for Peter and Ace. Peter definitely does not like Gene or Paul very much. And Ace, well, Ace is Ace.

There will surely be more books, more drama, and more feuding. To paraphrase Mark Twain, at least people are talking.

And come on, you know all four members relish all the free publicity. The would not be Kiss if they didn't.

Post-Script

The drama was all worth it. Ace's solo CD and subsequent tour exceeded all expectations. The CD ranked quite high in the Billboard charts. Gene and Paul went on tour with KISS and shattered box office records. The "new version" of KISS with Tommy Thayer and Erik Singer draws in audiences and has been doing so for many years.


More by this Author


6 comments

FatFreddysCat profile image

FatFreddysCat 2 years ago from The Garden State

I can understand Gene & Paul's stance on the Hall Of Fame and their reluctance to play with Criss and Frehley again. History has shown that Ace & Peter screwed themselves out of their positions in KISS not once, but twice. Meanwhile, Gene and Paul have become a tight musical unit with Thayer and Singer and they believe that lineup deserves just as much recognition. Gene and Paul have kept the band (and the brand) alive; Frehley and Criss have become bitter old men.


FatFreddysCat profile image

FatFreddysCat 2 years ago from The Garden State

Whoops....dang, double post. Feel free to delete this one!


TCaro profile image

TCaro 2 years ago Author

True, Gene and Paul were able to keep Kiss thriving well after many of their contemporary bands from the 1970s faded away. I would not call Ace bitter though. Incoherent would be a better word.


FatFreddysCat profile image

FatFreddysCat 2 years ago from The Garden State

I have met Ace Frehley and yeah, I'd say "incoherent" pretty much covers it...haha!


annasmom profile image

annasmom 9 months ago

FAtFreddysCat, It's too bad you keep reiterating your impression of Frehley from one encounter. The man is open about his struggle with addiction and remains a pretty gracious presence in the face of this type of adversity. I have a feeling Origins Vol. 1 is going to set the record straight regardi1ng his talent and marketability. Interestingly, Paul Stanley is one of the guests on this lp. I think the rift between the four originals is mostly financial, but their friendship survives. TCaro, this article is a good one. It is a puzzle as to why the Hall of Fame would buck recognizing these guys. I heard a rumor that Stanley and Simmons now have plans for a complete cover band in 'Vegas. Thayer, Singer and who knows ... Have you heard anything about that?


TCaro profile image

TCaro 2 months ago Author

Supposedly, when Paul and Gene retire, they plan on hiring their own replacements to play The Starchild and The Demon. KISS would, essentially, be hiring its own authorized cover band.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working