Self Control When Disciplining a Child

While there are many methods of disciplining children available for parents to choose from (including my own, called Stacked-Relational Consequences), there is a central secret that can either make your discipline effective or negate any positive effects.

Every parent lives with constant stress and strain in their life. From work stress to financial and relationship stressors, our reservoir of stress is always quite full and uncomfortable. With added issues of sleep deprivation and mood, our parenting can often suffer from inconsistency at the least, and degrade into discipline mistakes and even abusiveness in some cases. If you are honest with yourself, you will recognize times when you have been overwhelmed by your children’s misbehavior or tantrums to the point where you wanted to pull your (or their) hair out.

Each parent will have particularly irritating and frustrating behaviors their children engage in that bother them the most. Perhaps it is whining, or the kids fighting with each other, constant messiness, or those oh so nasty tantrums. Knowing which behaviors of your child that are most annoying to you is important, because this leads you towards the secret key of making your discipline efforts effective.

Essentially, the big secret of child discipline is maintaining emotional self control during the process. It is important to understand that because you and your child know each other so very well, you cannot hide your emotional reactivity towards each other. It is this emotional reactivity, which tends to escalate as a conflict and resulting correction moves forward, that sabotages your good efforts at discipline. This is the ‘space’ that the ‘battle of wills’ can begin and get so out of control that any discipline given will be doomed to failure. Any desired positive effect of correction will get lost in strong emotions coming from both sides of the encounter.

Here is another way to view the problem: If my emotions get so upset in reaction to my child’s behavior that I am conveying that I want to punish the child instead of discipline them with a consequence, the child will match my angry or upset emotion with their own, escalating the situation. When the child perceives that I am punishing them (punishment is different than consequence and discipline; punishment is vindictive and personal), I lose the corrective power of the action. All the child will remember is the punishment, not the correction or the reason for the correction.

Now, you might be thinking that this is all semantics, or ‘splitting hairs’, but it is not. Here is another illustration to help: If you get stopped for speeding by the police officer, you may be angry that you got caught, or feel you were not really speeding and it is unfair, or just angry at yourself for speeding. But the officer is going to give you a standardized ticket and fine, not one he has made up just because he is angry with you for speeding. In fact, he probably is not angry (per se) at you for speeding. What if the officer, when you rolled won the window, yelled and screamed at you and gave you a three thousand dollar ticket? Or ordered you to bend over your car hood so he could spank you? Sound like a law suit to you?

Any discipline approach that you use must start with your own emotional self control. And by this, it is meant genuinely ‘holding on to yourself’ and being calm. You cannot fake this (really, you can’t). So how do you ‘hold on to yourself’? By slowing down the process and giving yourself time to first calm your negative thoughts about the situation and then soothing your negative emotions. A good way to give yourself time to do this is by learning, teaching your child to positively respond to ‘Stacked-Relational Consequences’. Over time, this gives both of you practice at keeping reactivity to minimum in discipline situations. It also, believe it or not, begins to enhance and strengthen the the relationship between you and your child.

To calm negative thoughts and sooth negative emotions, follow these steps: Slow down the process. Become aware of the negative thoughts you are having. Challenge the negative thoughts for distortions (this process alone can begin to ease negative emotions). Use an emotional self soothing technique such as deep breathing or centering. Review your response choices and choose an action plan.

It is also a good idea to keep visual reminders around you to remember to consistently use the steps to keep reactivity at a minimum. Simple posters of the steps for ‘Stacked Relational Consequences’ and ‘Calm Negative Thoughts-Soothe Negative Emotions’ can go a long way in keeping you on track and make this effective process of discipline a habit.

More by this Author


Comments 4 comments

Willbeblessed profile image

Willbeblessed 3 years ago

Good practical application; I believe that with any goals in life you need to have a plan, no plan generally leaves us just responding to life without a course of action. As you have outlined discipline is something that you plan to do, emotional responses almost give the indication that you didn't even expect to be doing it, let alone plan. Interestingly as you highlighted self control and the difference between punishment and discipline, I thought about how the word discipline comes from disciple, to get someone to follow you, or a set of principals or values, which would be quite difficult, if you are not demonstrating them first in your own life as a parent. (Personally) I've found that hypocrisy is a serial killer; he murders your effectiveness both now, and in the future. Lastly, I think that all parents and/or those in positions of authority, especially those who teach the golden rule, should follow the golden rule: "Do unto others, as you would have done unto you" Good Hub!


Steph0596 profile image

Steph0596 3 years ago from Ontario

Wonderful article! I love the example of the police officer pulling you over. This is a tough topic to cover. Parents have differing methods of disciplining and may even, out of frustration, revert back to how they were once disciplined(or punished). As a mom of 5, I know how hard it can be to keep your cool and pick your battles wisely. I've never heard of ‘Stacked Relational Consequences’ but I am sure to investigate it more. Thank you for this article! Voted up


bettybarnesb profile image

bettybarnesb 3 years ago from Bartlett, TN

Very good article. I was a single parent and my children were disciplined. When it is mixed with a good relationship with children they understand and accept it better. "Balance" is hughe when it comes to operating an household. My children had chores and they also had activities they enjoyed. But discipline was big in my house. Now that they are grown, they respect and are grateful to the discipline they had while growing up.


Keeley Shea profile image

Keeley Shea 3 years ago from Norwich, CT

BRILLIANT! I am a reactor. (some say over-reactor). Was taught to react quickly by parents who react quickly. Hard habit to break but I like your advice to challenging those negative thoughts for distortion and reviewing your responses and choosing a plan of action. I will give it a try!

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working