Worlds Best Peanut Butter Pie Recipe

This recipe really is the Worlds Best Peanut Butter Pie.
This recipe really is the Worlds Best Peanut Butter Pie.
You want to be sure to use Hershey's Chocolate Syrup to top your pie with.
You want to be sure to use Hershey's Chocolate Syrup to top your pie with.
You want to be sure to use Cool Whip for your pie as it is the best brand possible.
You want to be sure to use Cool Whip for your pie as it is the best brand possible.
Once you have your pies in the graham cracker pie shells you will be wanting to cut the pies. But you'll want to wait.
Once you have your pies in the graham cracker pie shells you will be wanting to cut the pies. But you'll want to wait.
You want the Instant brand of Vanilla Pudding Mix and you want to make sure your milk is really cold.
You want the Instant brand of Vanilla Pudding Mix and you want to make sure your milk is really cold.
You want a large metal mixing bowl and you want to freeze it at least 4 hours in the freezer before you use it.
You want a large metal mixing bowl and you want to freeze it at least 4 hours in the freezer before you use it.

Worlds Best Peanut Butter Pie Recipe

If you love Peanut Butter like I do then you will love this recipe for the Worlds Best Peanut Butter Pie. Because everyone that tries it says that it truly is the Worlds Best Peanut Butter Pie. Don't skimp or go low fat when you make this recipe. The taste of this pie to me is so wonderful and delicious.The below recipe makes two pies and after you eat the first one you may find yourself looking for a unique hiding place so you and the second pie can be alone together.

1. 2 Graham Cracker Pie Shells.

2. 2 Large Packs Jello Instant Vanilla Pudding.

3. 4 Cups Cold Whole Milk.

4. 2 8 Ounce Containers Of Cool Whip Topping.

5. 3 Cups Jiffy Smooth Peanut Butter. , And yes be sure to use Jiffy.

6. 1 Container Hershey'sĀ  Chocolate Syrup.

7. Fine Chopped Peanuts.

Jiffy is the brand of peanut butterĀ  that I have always used for this pie and I would strongly suggest using Jiffy Smooth Peanut Butter because the taste is just there. It gives the pie a peanut butter taste that your not going to find with any other brand of peanut butter.

You want to follow the below steps when you are making your Worlds Best Peanut Butter Pie Recipe.

1. Mix together your Jello Instant Pudding Mix and the 4 cups of cold milk in a large pre chilled metal mixing bowl until thick and creamy with a hand mixer.

2. Now you want to add your Jiffy Peanut Butter and mix until well blended with the hand mixer.

3. Now add the two cartons of Cool Whip Topping to your mixing bowl and whip until smooth.

4. Now that you have everything mixed well pour into the two pie shells and smooth the tops of each pie and place into the freezer for one hour. You can cover with the plastic covers that were over your graham cracker pie shells.

5. Once the hour is up and the pies are well set remove from the freezer and drizzle the top of each with Hershey's Chocolate Syrup. Return to the freezer and let thaw at least one hour before you serve.

And you have now made the Worlds Best Peanut Butter Pie and yes you want to guard the freezer so no one else can get at your pies.


Jif really does make the Worlds Best Peanut Butter Pie. The taste of Jif just does it for the pie and once you taste it I think you will agree.
Jif really does make the Worlds Best Peanut Butter Pie. The taste of Jif just does it for the pie and once you taste it I think you will agree.

More by this Author


Post your comments , tips , or suggestions about the Worlds Best Peanut Butter Pie Recipe. Also feel free to ask your questions. 14 comments

pt8106 3 years ago

I have made this pie several times. I did try it with Jif but actually like it with Smart Balance creamy better. Also I added bananas and used banana cream pudding instead of vanilla because we love peanut butter and bananas together. It is a great recipe.


David 4 years ago

i been making pie lie this for years, it is good this way, but better if you use chocolate pudding, leave out 1/2 a cup of milk and add 1 80z package of cream chease then it is even better. and i put reeses peanut butter cups instead of the syrup. well just my 2 cents :)


crazyhorsesghost profile image

crazyhorsesghost 5 years ago from East Coast , United States Author

Fine Chopped Peanuts are used as a Garnish if you wish.


Thompson 5 years ago

I see that the recipe calls for fine chopped peanuts, however, I don't see in the recipe where the peanuts are added? Help!


Sinea Pies profile image

Sinea Pies 5 years ago from Northeastern United States

This looks absolutely delightful. I've got to calculate my weight watchers points so that I can try this one.

Thanks. Voted up.


fillyourheart profile image

fillyourheart 5 years ago from USA

This looks so delicious! I will try it, thanks.


pt8106 5 years ago

I've made this a couple of times and it is really good. The first time I used JIF and the second time I used Smart Balance and I really like it better with Smart Balance instead of JIF. I also used Banana Cream Pudding instead of Vanilla the second time and added some bananas to it. Nothing better than a great Peanut Butter Pie that has bananas and chocolate in it.


crazyhorsesghost profile image

crazyhorsesghost 6 years ago from East Coast , United States Author

Yes it is for sure the best peanut butter pie I have ever tasted. It is so good. So delicious. Can you say wow. What a flavor explosion.


Peter Pan 6 years ago

http://hubpages.com/food/Worlds-Best-Peanut-Butter...

This is one of if not the best recipe for Peanut Butter Pie that I have ever tasted. It is so delicious.


yum 6 years ago

I made this pie. It is so good and easy to make. Now I know why the recipe is for two pies. You will eat both of them!


crazyhorsesghost profile image

crazyhorsesghost 6 years ago from East Coast , United States Author

It really is one of the best peanut butter pies that I have ever tasted. It is so good.


Karen Ellis profile image

Karen Ellis 6 years ago from Central Oregon

I love pie, any kind of pie, except maybe mincemeat. This looks really simple, it may be a new Christmas tradition.


crazyhorsesghost profile image

crazyhorsesghost 6 years ago from East Coast , United States Author

It is the best peanut butter pie that you will ever eat in your life. It really is that good.


HarperSmith profile image

HarperSmith 6 years ago

Sounds yummy! I think I'll go ahead and try this now. Why wait for Thanksgiving? Thanks

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    This Hub Page and the text on it was created by Thomas Byers aka Crazyhorsesghost and is not to be copied or used on any other web site.
    This Hub Page and the text on it was created by Thomas Byers aka Crazyhorsesghost and is not to be copied or used on any other web site.
    Click to Rate This Article
    working