Apple MacBook Air

61
rate this page

By Mark Knowles


Steve Jobs once again managed to wow the world with the latest laptop release from Apple. The MacBook Air. Thinner, lighter and following Sony’s lead, one of the first mainstream computers to offer a solid state hard drive.

Billed as the world’s thinnest notebook, you cannot deny that this is an attractive piece of equipment. It is certainly thin, no question, but I wonder at the use of this as the major selling point. My personal experience of buying the thinnest whatever, generally involved replacing it with something a little more substantial after a short period of time. Technical specs are impressive, but nothing to write home about.



Apple are also billing this as a “green laptop "and this is a quote from their website:

MacBook Air embodies Apple’s continuing environmental progress. It consumes the least amount of power of any Mac and is also designed with the following features to reduce environmental impact:

  • Highly recyclable aluminum enclosure
  • Mercury-free LCD display with arsenic-free glass
  • PVC-free internal cables
  • Largely recyclable, low-volume packaging

Don’t get me wrong, I love Apple products, I have used them for years, but Green? Please ! Largely recyclable - what is that supposed to mean?

Green it’s not. Maybe a gentle shade of Cyan, thanks to a few token gestures with the intention of using that as a selling point, but there is no way this is a green laptop. Pull the other one Mr. Jobs. Why on earth these manufacturers insist on feeding their consumers this crap is upsetting. Here is why this ain’t a green laptop.

  • Apple manufacture in China. Now, I know every one gives China bad press for creating a lot of pollution. But who is doing the manufacturing and more importantly, the consuming ? That’s right – US !
  • It is non-upgradeable – There is no way in hell you will be able to upgrade this when the software overtakes the specs. NO WAY.
  • It has a non-replaceable battery. When the battery fails, as it is sure to do - You will have to buy a new machine.

This thing has a maximum lifespan of two years. Maximum. Three thousand dollars for a computer you will be throwing in the garbage in two years time. How dumb do they think we are?

Just think about how many of these Apple will sell, and then think about the huge pile of garbage that will need to be buried in a landfill in the Amazon basin in two or three years time.

No, no, no – It is pretty, it is thin, it is innovatively designed, but one thing it most definitely is not is green. For me green means built to last, using sustainable resources and environmentally friendly manufacturing processes. . If you want a green laptop, buy the MacBook Pro and keep it for ten years. That’s green.


Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub Small RSS Icon

Saw Pe profile image

Saw Pe  says:
6 months ago

I saw the TV commerical advertisement recently about Apple MacBook Air.  Indeed, it does attract me.  Despite 3 years life span as I read what you said, Apple is banking on its strong household brand name.  Look at what they do with iPod. iPod is well known to have a short lifespan, too.  Yet, consumers kept buying them. You can see large number of dazed shoppers and lookers at Apple's crowded flagship store in midtown Manhattan on East 59 Street something very close to southeast corner of the Central Park.

Anyway, my immediate concern and question is: Is it, that is, Apple MacBook Air, prone to heat breakdown very common to most PC laptops?

I appreciate your time.

Saw Pe

Mark Knowles profile image

Mark Knowles  says:
6 months ago

I shouldn't worry about that _ I doubt it will last long enough for that to be an issue.

Stacie Naczelnik profile image

Stacie Naczelnik  says:
6 months ago

Good info on its lack of green. It ain't easy being green. My husband showed me the commercial for this laptop online before I saw it on tv...I thought: bet Mark is going to write an article!

Mark Knowles profile image

Mark Knowles  says:
6 months ago

You thought right, LOL

It looks great, I have to admit, but a two year life span and they are selling it as a green computer?

SanFernando profile image

SanFernando  says:
6 months ago

I like your review of the product. The critique is spot on. Who do these guys think their kidding?
Dumb Alley lies right smack between Madison Avenue and Wall Street. Every morning the execs., on their way to their ivory tower offices cut across this Alley with their Starbucks in one hand. I think they are inhaling too much secondary crack vapors seeping up from the ground around them. Where is Batman when America needs him? Or is this a job for "Super Clean up Gal" Hilary?

Mark Knowles profile image

Mark Knowles  says:
6 months ago

Thanks. I am getting fed up with being treated like this. It means they think you are stupid. Check out the video I added and take a look at the story of stuff. It's scary.

apx profile image

apx  says:
6 months ago

I agree with your review, I think they're trying to make a fool out of us. The thing is, Apple seems to be trying to make gadgets with short life span, so that they reap the profit profit when we buy another of their product to replace the old one. what a cheap trick.

Mark Knowles profile image

Mark Knowles  says:
6 months ago

I agree 100% - It's insulting. But the depressing thing is, this will probably be their biggest seller.

compu-smart profile image

compu-smart  says:
6 months ago

Great article and Interesting comments debate..I have only ever had good reviews for macs so i shall watch this space;)

Lissie profile image

Lissie  says:
6 months ago

A disagree a bit - the battery is non-replaceable by the user but can be in a service centre (for extra cost too!) I don't know if Apple still does the incompatible MacOS upgrade thing - you have to upgrade the OS and then the software needs upgrading and then you need faster hardware! In PC world so long as you don't upgrade the OS I find the software has kept on the same spec for about 4 years especially if you don't go with Microsoft software

Mark Knowles profile image

Mark Knowles  says:
6 months ago

Well, I guess I was a little over zealous, but the fact is, my wife has an iPod and it needs a new battery, but the price is such that it's just about worth buying a new one instead. And the Air battery will require returning ity to a service center which measn you will have to buy an Apple battery. And yes, the software does overtake the hardware - nowhere near as bad as with a PC though.

Whitney05 profile image

Whitney05  says:
6 months ago

I saw this on tv the other day! It looks awesome, but I would worry about breaking it. I have big dogs that like to jump in your lap when you're on the computer. Many times I get toes on my keyboard. One good jump and it would be gone. I'll stick with Dell.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional



  • Apple golden in 2008 Industrial Design Excellence Awards

    In its special report on the IDEA 2008 winners, BusinessWeek reports that the iPhone, MacBook Air, and the Apple Wireless Keyboard won Gold awards and iMac won a Silver award in the prestigious annual competition sponsored by the Industrial Designers Society of America (IDSA). - 30 hours ago

  • Now playing on iTunes U: “Ask a Biologist”

    Hosted by Dr. Biology (CJ Kazilek) and brought to us by Arizona State University, “Ask a Biologist” features interviews of prominent scientists who discuss tiger beetles, marine biology, the history of fire, microbes, bird song, arachnology, and a wide range of other life science topics. Whether you listen to the shows, read the transcripts, or both, “Ask a Biologist” makes for an enjoyable and thought provoking experience. - 2 days ago

  • Five stars to iPhone 2.0 software

    From the new App Store to easier mail management to support for Microsoft Exchange and MobileMe, PC Advisor steps you through the major and minor additions and improvements offered by iPhone 2.0 software. Awarding it five stars for its value for the money, PC Advisor concludes that iPhone 2.0 offers “a welcome step-up for what was already arguably the best mobile platform on the market.” - 2 days ago

working