Domestic Violence and Fundamentalist Christianity
81
I was the victim of domestic violence in my home, growing up. I was a battered child.
I was also the daughter of two extreme fundamentalist Christians.
My mother was also the victim of domestic violence, though she thought that was acceptable. Dad hit her in the face so hard one time, that he broke her dentures. Blood from her mouth flew across the room. She had the temerity to accuse him of something. She didn't often get hit: she most often simply submitted to whatever he wanted. But the threat was always there. Her victimization of domestic abuse most often took the form of emotional and psychological domestic abuse. She also could gauge his mood, and use the children as a shield, to vent his unrelenting anger at the world and the people in it.
I've written a lot about that elsewhere, in the "Stories From My Life" series. I don't particularly want to go into the details of being a battered child in this hub. We want to explore the relationship between my parents' religion and their attitude towards "discipline", which, in a different religious culture, would be called "child battering". We want to explore the relationship between Fundamentalist Protestant Christianity and domestic abuse.
Both my parents had a particular and peculiar narrow vision of what was right and what was wrong. It was confusing. For instance, they saw nothing wrong with beating a newborn baby until it ceased to cry and disturb my father's rest during the night. They evidently had no clue the baby needed to be fed at regular intervals through the night. That was "Discipline". They had no problem with letting my sister Faye almost die from bee stings, a consequence of her disobediently crossing the road. That was "Discipline". They had no problem with Dad issuing routine beatings to all his children, on "general principles". That was "Discipline".
OK, enough, you get the idea. Yet, they professed to be Christians. They talked a good line, about the love of Jesus and the love of God for sacrificing His only begotten Son to save our sinful souls. We saw very little (actually none that I can remember) love in action in our home.
The religion they practiced tended to focus on the darker aspects of Christianity. They focused on the sufferings of Christ on the cross, His torments. They focused on the torments of hell for unrepentant sinners. They focused on how BAD people were, how we were all born in sin and would die in sin, did we not repent, and suffer the torments of hell in the lake of fire forever!
There was no carrot in front of the donkey's nose: it was the devil with a pitchfork prodding the donkey from behind, all the way.
They also blamed EVE, for letting sin into the world. We were all children of Eve. They also had a peculiar relish in eschewing the sins of Sodom and Gomorrah, and the Whore of Babylon, and the adulterous woman that Jesus saved from stoning. It was impressed on us as girl children that any immodesty on our part, the least bit of natural human curiosity about the opposite sex, was shamefully our fault and could lead to dire consequences here on earth in addition to damning us to hell forevermore. My mother was excessively modest, appearing to be frightened of and uncomfortable inside her own body. I think she wished not to have a body at all, and wished no one else did, either.
This religion was rigid about the Ten Commandments. Enforcing these behaviors in their children with excessive "Discipline" was the RIGHT thing to do. I truly felt my parents' God was Discipline, that's why I keep capitalizing this word.
It wasn't until I became an adult that I realized how much we had suffered from the battering behavior of our father and the acquiescent, compliant, enabling behavior of our mother. I learned that what we suffered, both physically and mentally, as children, was called "battering" and it was generally socially unacceptable. People by now had realized what damage it caused to the self-esteem and development of its victims and were against it.
All while we were growing up, this behavior appeared to be acceptable, or condoned or maybe even recommended by the church elders. "Spare the rod and spoil the child." Yes, that's in the Bible. We accepted this behavior on the part of our parents without question as children. We suffered in as much silence as we could muster. We toughed it out, as best we could. We had no other milieu to compare it to, until we went to school. Then, indeed, we did notice a difference. And we weren't able to specifically identify it or understand why our plight made people so uncomfortable until we reached adulthood.
We also accepted Dad as the head of the family. His word was law. The hierarchy went like this: the children were subject to Mom, Mom was subject to Dad, and Dad was (supposedly) subject to God. In practical fact, Mom referred all matters of "disciplining" the children to Dad, who was always ready and eager to beat us with a cane or kick us in the butt or slap us up side the head, anyway. In practical fact, Dad was a law unto himself in that household. His word was law. Whatever he said, went. And Mom was fine with that, because she thought she was doing her duty as a Christian wife to obey her husband in all things. What an evasion of responsibility on her part that was! She could never see it.
Mom was abused, herself, in many ways. Dad was always, always, talking her down, calling her "stupid", "incompetent"; he criticized her in every way possible; he emotionally battered her in front of the children. He established dominance, or maintained dominance, in his household in this way: by being so punishing, so abusive, so unpleasant, that no one wished to go against him and bring down untold suffering upon their hapless heads.
So when I came across this excerpt, from "The Repentant Fundamentalist" by James C. Alexander, it seemed so familiar to me:
- The most obvious is physical abuse. It is difficult to make a conclusive statistical connection between fundamentalism and domestic violence. There are numerous anecdotal cases of fundamentalist husbands hitting their spouses. Also, virtually all fundamentalist churches recommend spanking as a normal, frequent method of child discipline, and all "fundamentalist experts" advise using an object to spank and to spank until profuse crying ensues.
- Another type of abuse is psychological. Here the wife is under constant pressure to submit to her husband. She is under constant scrutiny and the always a candidate for criticism.
- The woman is constantly reminded that she must submit to her husband because the Bible says she must.
So there we have it. The fundamentalist church condones hitting the wife, to "correct" her, and that's part of the husband's marital duty. The fundamentalist church advises to beat the kids with an object until they cry, "profusely", which leaves a lot of room for the indulgence of domestic violence on the part of a husband who has those proclivities.
I'm not saying that ALL Christian Fundamentalists are wife-beaters and child-batterers. I just wish to point out that women in a Fundamentalist Christian household who are subject to domestic violence may very well have a special challenge to alter their life situation. They can't find any help within their church or their congregation. Their own mind-set works against them, to be able to assess what is acceptable and what is not. There are many far-reaching implications to the belief that the man is the head of the household and his actions and words are indisputable, infallibly correct, and beyond challenging.
|
Healing the Trauma of Domestic Violence: A Workbook for Women (New Harbinger Self-Help Workbook)
Price: $13.49
List Price: $21.95 |
|
Why Does He Do That?: Inside the Minds of Angry and Controlling Men
Price: $9.57
List Price: $16.00 |
|
Black and Blue (True Stories Collection TV Movie)
Price: $4.98
List Price: $9.98 |
|
|
Surviving Domestic Violence: Voices of Women Who Broke Free
Price: $15.00
List Price: $17.95 |
|
|
Stories of a Recovering Fundamentalist: Understanding and Responding to Christian Absolutism
Price: $12.34
List Price: $14.95 |
If you want to read more about DOMESTIC VIOLENCE, click HERE:
- Domestic Violence and Fundamentalist Christianity
I was the victim of domestic violence in my home, growing up. I was a battered child. I was also the daughter of two extreme fundamentalist Christians. My mother was also the victim of domestic violence,... - 4 weeks ago
- HubMob Weekly Topic: Domestic Violence
Yes, I can say I have been a former victim of this. I was very young and naive and really insecure. But I survived it. I never subjected my children to it, they were born after I left him. But to this day, I still suffer the PTSD. If my current spouse makes a sudden move, say, in an explosive conversation, I cringe back without even thinking. Reflex instinct. But the good thing is that this former husband of so long ago has made an amends for his bad treatment of me. We are now friends and share a son together. (now grown). This rarely happens, but he apologized years ago and tried to make it up the best he could, this was after he joined AA. But he's still very controlling and manipulative and unable to stay in a lasting, normal relationship without slipping into his former tendencies. I can truly say that if I needed anything, and if he had the means to help me, he would. But he cannot be in a normal relationship, he's too damaged. Realized years later, he's bipolar and anti-social personality. - 4 weeks ago
- Domestic Violence - Are You A Victim?
Domestic violence, spousal abuse, child abuse, elder abuse - we have all heard the words, and seen the stories on the news - the ultimate results of unchecked domestic violence. We abhor the senseless... - 4 weeks ago
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
What a powerful hub! This must have been so hard to share, but it really touched me, and I so admire you for it. My heart goes out to you...and all children/women who suffer from abuse (emotional and physical); As I always say, 'out of pain... beauty." And your writing is a clear case of that. Sending all the healing and love in the world to you....x
Thank you so much, febriedethan, for your comment. I'm OK now and though it took many, many years of being away from that situation, we children managed to make some fair adjustments to the world. As far as forgiveness goes, my Dad, who is now deceased, has it from me at least, just because an abusive man is not a happy man, and I believe my life on the whole has been much more joyful than his.
Thank you, myownworld. It amazes and awes me, how much outbound sympathy you have for others, and what a truly good heart you have and retain, when many of your own experiences have been so cruel. You've written about them with such a gift of moving candor, yourself.
There are two points of view. I expect to find that some Fundamentalist Christians strongly disagree with everything I've said in this hub. All points of view are welcome, and I will not disapprove any comments made.
This is a powerful hub indeed! I have so many feelings about what I read, but I'm not quite sure how to express them. From my study of the scriptures, I've always been impressed about how loving and kind Jesus was to people of all genders and backgrounds (especially women and children) Even during a time where some religous leaders thought (and displayed) little or nothing of women and children, Jesus always displayed a totaly different attitude through his words and actions. When I hear of stories like this (and sadly there are so many), it makes me wonder how that aspect of "having the true mind of Christ" can go unnoticed. You are truly brave to share this with us. It will no doubt help others who may be experiencing this now, what you and your family experienced in the past.
I think you express it well. That always struck me, the very different attitude, the kind and loving attitude Jesus had in the Bible to ALL people, women, children, hurt people, poor people, sick people; how he healed them. And the very harsh and anti-female, anti-child outlook the fundamentalist church embraced.
I appreciate you writing this hub and expressing and showing us that this goes on. It could have been turmoil to you to go into the past and write this and re-live it or you could have been scared off because you possibly could be considered accusatory of the fundamentalist church goers. However, you stood your ground and wrote it knowing that it needed to be out there. I applaud you for that and I am seeing great strength in you and your hubs--Thank you for sharing that with the readers. :)
Paradise - Thanks for sharing.
This is very disturbing. To think people use the scriptures and take excerpts and use them out of context to justify their abuse. This makes me sick to the stomach.
Thanks for your bravery in sharing this powerful witness. Women and children abuse is a real problem in South Africa, and I agree it often has religious overtones. I have always had a special problem with those who cloak their controlling and sexist behaviours in religious talk - and it is not only the Christian fundamentalists who do this, those of other religions do also. If you saw the movie "Shine" you would have seen how a Jewish father could almost destroy a gifted child. It is everywhere and needs to be confronted everywhere it occurs. It takes people with the courage that you have shown here to expose this horrible perversion, becuase that is what it is.
Thanks for your courage and sensitivity in putting your story out there for others to know.
Love and peace
Tony
Paradise this was such a smart piece for the Domestic Violence HubMob! It's mind boggling how much pain and suffering is caused by a misguided sense of religion and morality. Some people use religion to justify their bad behavior. Hard to believe, but as you've painted so well, it's true.
wow, that is painful to read. I admire and applaud you for writing it so boldly. I have worked with children closely and can always spot the ones from this kind of environment although cleverly veiled.
'spare the rod, spoil the child' does NOT refer to beating or spanking a child as is so often interpreted. as the Bible was written in the eastern culture, much of it is filled with oriental customs. the shepherd used a staff to help direct the sheep, to lead them. it was never used to beat or hit a sheep as the sheep would run away. the verse is talking about boundaries for the child, not spanking. the parents are to discipline and give the child guidance so that the child can learn. I can't even imagine what kind of thoughts this sent to you as a child. thank you for sharing.
Thank you all so much for your wonderful comments, and your insight into this problem.
I knew I might offend some sincere and devout people who themselves would never in a million years harm their wives or children, and are fine and upright citizens and truly living in Christ. NOT ALL Fundamentalist Protestant Christians act upon the leeway given by this set of beliefs.
Tony Mac also made the great point that it isn't only Fundamentalist Christians who have the extremely male-dominated, insistent on womanly submission, and mortifying to children type of beliefs on the proper way to run a household. Muslims, some African religions, many, many different religions have this flaw, but that isn't too say all the practioners of any given religion abuse that leeway and use the religion to mask domestic violence.
With that being said there is a darker side to many of the Fundamentalist religions. I think many parents such as yours were probably physically abused as children and told that it was their punishment for being children of Eve, so they grew up thinking they had to do this to their own children. I remember watching a documentary about a woman that beat her son to death with a curtain rod because he would not stop crying, and the judge let her off because he said it was a mistake on her part. It turns out growing up her dad severely beat her, and they had a history of child abuse in their family going back all the way to the Civil War.
They came from dysfunctional households. They weren't physically abused. They grew up in the Great Depression, and I think that deep insecurity of where their next mean was coming from ,when they were children, was a big part of their problems. It doesn't justify things, but it explains some things.
I am sorry if I made some assumptions. I just have heard on other documentaries when kids are abused that there is an increased likelihood of them becoming abusers themselves. I am sorry if my comment offended.
Your comment didn't offend me at all. I hope I wasn't mistaken in my tone to you, I just answered honestly. I know it is often true that the abused become abusers, but it is not always true. And the converse is true also: abusers were not always abused persons. Sometimes it feels like the whole family thing is a lottery.
This is very educative article which shows how people should never interprete any religion, neither will of any god, neither should create hell, neither need fo suffering or devil which would justify their own misdeeds...OK, all that happened because they were deeply insecure, unhappy and frightened from life itself. As a product of that illness you suffered as well. The hell they were frightened of they passed on you.
It is sad story. Not all, but many Christians (as well as members of many other religions) are very frightened and are not aware that they actually create the hell here for themselves and the others.
I wish you all the best on your way to happy and fulfilled life...which you obviously have chosen according to your beautiful avatar and penname.
Thank you very much, Tatjana. Forgiveness and understanding are the key to a much happier life than either of my parents had. And I think it's so unfortunate that sometimes religious words are misused.
I always appreciate your candidness. It is good you are able to write about these issues with such sincerity and objectivity.
It is very hard to live in those moments. It would have been tough for you as well. But that is what life is all about! take care and GBU :-)
Thank you both, Seetie Pie and Vizey. I learned fairly early on that the only way to deal with things is look the truth in the face and try to make an impartial assessment of things; try to figure out how to make things better for myself and others. It isn't always easy to look the truth in the face, especially when dealing with the past. (Especially MY past.) The more we look at the truth, the freer we are from it. That turns out to be a necessary side benefit.
hello Paradise. This is a very emotional article that you are so brave to share with us. I really do hope you're okay now. Forgiveness is one key to happiness. I wish you all happiness.
I'm happy to know that you printed out my top 10 tips to a healthier life. I'm thnakful and happy that I am able to share very essential information to people like you.
Be well now and take care
Wow! What a view of the real. Reading your hub was something. I am sorry for those that have had to experience others that paint this picture of "religion" as a justification to abuse. I do hope that all your soul's scars are healed and that you can help so many others find peace in their lives. Survivor!!!
Thank you, Treasures. The scars have healed, pretty much. What doesn't kill us makes us stronger. There are many words of warning to quell the violence inherent in our human hearts, and to find peace, sharing, and love for each other, which is there in our hearts, commingled with self-seeking and violence. Those words sometimes fall on empty ears, but not always.
Hi there
Thanks for your post. My sister sounds a lot like your mother and I fear for her four children. We have all tried on numerous occasions to help her get away from her abusive husband and there are times when we thought she would finally see the light but then she ultimately goes back to him because he gives her the guilt trip, threatens to kill himself, it is her wifely, christian duty, etc. I'm sure you've heard all the excuses yourself. I used to feel sorry for her but now I am just disgusted with her for subjecting her kids to this. I know they will all be scared for life and as it is her oldest child is already totally screwed up. I wish I could do something to help but every time I do I get ostracized from her family. At the moment she is not speaking to me, my mom or my other sister because we are "unbelievers" and are trying to break up her "happy" family. I fear that one day something really awful will happen. All I can do is try to tell her kids that I am here for them. Thank you again for your story. I wish I could send it to my sister and make her see what she is doing to her children.
Sharon, maybe you could just print it out and send it to her anonomously. If the children are in danger, don't hesitate--call Child Welfare Services. Let them look into it. Myself and two of my siblings came very close to dying in our household, and it was purely luck we didn't. This attitude towards children is DANGEROUS for the children. Sometimes parents don't know when they're going too far with the discipline, until it's too late.
Everybody knows, and people do nothing, for some complicated reasons of their own, and it nearly cost myself and my two sisters our lives.
As far as your sister goes, she has been brainwashed and needs professional help to get deprogrammed, once she's out of the situation.























febriedethan says:
4 weeks ago
Oh my..I have no idea what you've been through Paradise7, I hope you're in a good condition now and are able to forgive your father. Just hope the best for you, thank you for sharing this, I know it's hard. I appreciate it so much. God Bless You :)