Dusting Off the Guillotines
74The news has been buzzing with anger over the $165 million in bonuses insurance corporation AIG plans to shell out to its executives, especially after the news broke that the majority of bonuses were going to AIG's Financial Products Unit, the same unit whose unregulated financial shenanigans brought the company - and the world economy - to its knees.
This behavior should come as a surprise to no one. After all, this is the same company that managed to spend more than $400,000 on an executive retreat less than a week after receiving $80 billion in taxpayer funded bailout money back in October.
The surprising thing is that we're letting them get away with it. Again.
Turns out that good ol' Shrub, who was wrong about so much, can add one more thing to his list: "Fool me once, shame on — shame on you. Fool me — you can't get fooled again."
AIG isn't the only focus of populist outrage. The courtroom erupted into loud laughter when Ira Sorkin, lawyer of Bernie Madoff, who swindled more than 4,000 individuals and organizations out of more than $60 billion dollars, argued that his client should go free on bail after pleading guilty to his crimes. The judge sided with the crowd - Bernie was led away in handcuffs to await his sentence in jail.
The Detroit automakers also fell afoul of the country's current mood when the Big Three CEO's each flew a separate private jet to Washington to beg for taxpayer money to save their failing companies from their own mismanagement.
These people make Marie Antoinette look sensitive and in touch with the mood of her times.
"Madame Deficit," as she was known by her angry contemporaries, probably never uttered the famous phrase "Let them eat cake." Modern historians believe the actual culprit was Louis XIV's much stupider and more sheltered wife Marie-Therese.
However, nobody can argue that prancing around in expensive hats pretending to be a shepherdess while real shepherdesses were starving wasn't a PR disaster of truly colossal proportions.
Poor Marie paid for her mistakes with her head. Will the corporate CEOs whose decisions led to the current financial crisis pay for theirs? Will they even admit them?
Where is the Accountability?
Chuck Grassley is shocked - shocked! - to learn that gambling is going on in here. Having voted for the deregulation that contributed to the current financial crisis, Senator Grassley has about as much credibility as Inspector Renault pocketing his earnings.
However, he did get one thing right in his initial call for AIG executives to commit suicide, and his subsequent retraction:
Where is the contrition? Where is the accountability? The CEOs of companies such as AIG, Citibank, and GM not only haven't acknowledged their mistakes, they're actively playing the American public for fools. When the AIG bonuses scandal broke, CEO Edward Liddy wrote a remarkably cynical letter to Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner explaining that paying the bonuses was necessary, among other reasons, because without doing so, AIG would not be able to attract and keep "the best" employees if they believed that their compensation would be "subject to continued and arbitrary adjustment by the U.S. Treasury."
Considering the bang-up job AIG did attracting "the best" employees when their bonus policies were not overseen by the government, I really think we can afford the risk, especially now that we, the taxpayers, now own 80% of the company, whose reckless and irresponsible policies (which themselves bordered on an illegal Ponzi scheme such as that headed by the fallen crook Bernie Madoff) nearly brought the entire world's economy to its knees.
So fuck you, Mr. Liddy.
Tempting as it might be to start dragging out the guillotines, we can't forget where that got the French, or where the hail of bullets that ended their similarly extravagant, out of touch monarchy landed the Russians.
Lying down and rolling over as the super-wealthy continue to build themselves a second (third? hundredth?) Gilded Age at the expense of American taxpayers is no more viable an outcome, however.
Smarter and more knowledgeable minds than mine will need to come up with a real solution, but I think an important starting point is education. The more we, the general public, know about the dirty dealings going on behind closed doors on Wall Street and in Washington, the better the chance we have of stopping them. I'll be honest: the current crisis has stretched my knowledge and understanding of economics to the limit and beyond, but every day I'm learning more, and the more I learn, the madder I get.
Though I was more informed than some over the last eight years, thanks to a deep-rooted hatred and mistrust of George Bush and everything that came out of his mouth - his perpetual, disingenuous economic optimism included - I still had no idea of the true depth of the problem until last year. If I and every taxpayer had been more knowledgeable and informed about financial issues in the first place, instead of accepting the pronouncements of CEOs, politicians, and the media at their word, the crisis might have been avoided.
Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. But I, for one, refuse to be fooled again.
Meanwhile, I've started knitting again. Just in case.
Check out these great hubs by a fellow knitter
- MSNBC Lists Most Troubled Banks in U.S.
- Dear President Obama: Please Stop Giving Money to the Banks!
- TARP and the Banks: Time for Real Accountability
- Thoughts on the Economic Depression the U.S. Is Officially Not Experiencing
- Thoughts on the New Bail-Out Package and the U.S. Economy
- The U.S. Decides to Bail Itself Out?
- Lehman Brothers, AIG, Wamu, Merrill Lynch: Get in Line, Folks, Here We Go
- How China Provoked the Fannie Mae Freddie Mac Bail-Out
|
|
Perfectly Legal: The Covert Campaign to Rig Our Tax System to Benefit the Super Rich--and Cheat Everybody Else
Price: $4.88
List Price: $15.00 |
|
|
Free Lunch: How the Wealthiest Americans Enrich Themselves at Government Expense (and StickYou with the Bill)
Price: $1.98
List Price: $16.00 |
|
|
Bad Money: Reckless Finance, Failed Politics, and the Global Crisis of American Capitalism
Price: $8.80
List Price: $16.00 |
|
The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism
Price: $16.58
List Price: $22.00 |
|
|
Plunder and Blunder: The Rise and Fall of the Bubble Economy
Price: $9.53
List Price: $15.95 |
|
The Return of Depression Economics and the Crisis of 2008
Price: $9.50
List Price: $24.95 |
|
The Conservative Nanny State: How the Wealthy Use the Government to Stay Rich and Get Richer
Price: $6.99
List Price: $7.90 |
Wall Street Folly
- Has Goldman sold its soul for profits?; SAC Capital uncomfortably in the spotlight; Ben Bernanke is Time Magazine’s Person of the Year; Citigroup gets a sure to be controversial $38B tax benefit, Abu Dhabi, claiming “fraudulent misrepresentations” wants out of its Citi investment, Citi cries bullshit; No change in rates expected from Fed; Rajaratnam indicted, proclaims innocence; France jumps on the bonus tax band wagon; Microsoft settles with EU
As Goldman Thrives, Some Say an Ethos has Faded An Unwelcome Spotlight Falls on SAC Capital Person of the Year 2009: Ben Bernanke Citigroup Says Abu Dhabi Seeks to End Share Purchase Citi: Abu Dhabi... - 2 hours ago
- After Kelly’s shunning, B of A may be forced to go with insider CEO; Goldman sued over bonuses; Wells Fargo is also deTARPing; Barclays’ Diamond tells UK employees not to worry ’bout 50% bonus tax; Rajaratnam tries again for bail reduction; Abu Dhabi may exert its leverage; AIG says they’ll repay loans, Senior management got screwed financially; Buffett sells more Moody’s; Microsoft accused of plagiarism
Bank of America Said to Be Likely to Pick Insider CEO Goldman faces lawsuit over anticipated bonuses Citigroup, Wells Fargo to repay bailouts Wells Fargo to Sell $10.4 Billion in Stock, Repay U.S.... - 26 hours ago
- Premature eTARPulation? Citigroup and the government make a deal but is Citi ready?; Greg Fleming lands: Merrill’s loss is Morgan Stanley’s gain; RIP Paul Samuelson; Abu Dhabi gives Dubai a $10B helping hand; B of A still having CEO recruiting problems?; Accenture gives Tiger the boot as the game of golf ponders his announced absence
Citigroup to Repay $20 Billion of Government Bailout Press Release: Citigroup, U.S. Government and Regulators Agree to TARP Repayment Dubai Gets $10B From Abu Dhabi; To Pay Nakheel Bond Merrill... - 2 days ago
- Henry Kravis has Warren Buffett envy; A year later Madoff “is the godfather, the don” behind bars; Goldman cash bonuses will make bottom line look nicer; UK hedge funds not part of supertax; Lawyers scramble to find supertax loopholes; Moody’s says U.S., UK not threatened with downgrades (yet); Ex-UBS banker is a fugitive; Merrill squawk box broker gets probation
Bernie Madoff, the $19B Con, Makes New Friends Behind Bars Buyout Pioneer Kravis Aims to Remake KKR Like Buffett Goldman Sachs Bars Cash Bonus for Top Officers Goldman Sachs Stock Bonus Plan to Defer... - 5 days ago
- More pay caps coming from the U.S. pay czar; Yipes! Between tax on banks and bankers, Brits face total bonus tax of over 100%; Citi desperately wants out of TARP; B of A has officially DeTARPed; Sounds like the SEC isn’t done persecuting Cioffi, Tannin; B of A’s Montag took a newrly $5M piece of their recent stock offer; The ax is falling on 5% of Putnam’s staff
Firms Face New Curbs on Pay Top bankers’ bonus rate to top 100% ‘What banker wants to be in the UK?’ City tells Darling: your super-tax is pushing us out of Britain Darling Forces U.K. Banks to... - 6 days ago
Do Summers and Geithner Need to Go?
- The real scandal at AIG
Everybody is rushing to condemn AIG's bonuses, but this simple scandal is obscuring the real disgrace at the insurance giant: Why are AIG's counterparties getting paid back in full, to the tune of tens of billions of taxpayer dollars? - The Potentially Larger AIG Problem
The political hue and cry over the millions in bonuses for AIG execs has hit fever pitch but there are major questions about what AIG has done with far larger portions of the federal bailout money it's received.
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
KerryG, if we just don't keep bailing these people out, there will be no need for guillotines.
And accountability? These people are employees. Who owns their businesses? Who has the majority of shares? Whoever it is, if they had been personally liable for the loss, would have done a better job of overseeing things. It's the limited liability of corporations that destroys accountability.
Righteous anger. Yet misplaced. Neither AIG nor other corporations can control taxpayers money. Government do. And once money are handed out by government no strings attached, corparations can spend them as they see fit...
Kerry- Although bonuses/holidaying with tax payer money is shameful. But at the same time this is the largest insurance company in the world and is based in 130 countries. I guess the government justification that this company is too big and would have disastrous ripple effects across the globe does make some sense when they say it is "too big and can't be allowed to fail". Good thought provoking hub.
Nice job, Kerry. The AIG situation was handled very poorly by all concerned with the result that the public's faith in our economic and political system has been undermined, not the least because there were serious conflicts of interest among the key players (Paulsen and Blankfein, Goldman CEO. This fiasco comes on top of three decades of growing income disparity fueled by CEO greed and voodoo, supply side tax breaks for the richest Americans. Just now on the Lehrer News Hour I watched a segment about a new book about a bombing that occurred in front of JP Morgan;s bank during the depression, killing 38 people. Despite efforts by the FBI and NYPD the crime was never solved. This was the greatest acti of domestic terrorism until the Oklahoma City federal building was bombed in 1995.
Kerry, this is fantastic. I'd like a giant banner for the front of my house with your title on it...along with an "Eat the Rich" one for the garage. If we don't use this time to wrest control of our country from those who would consign us to permanent serfdom - well, perhaps we deserve what we get.
I can't tell you how completely I agree with everything you've said here. I too have a little list - but I'll bring my embroidery, if that's okay. :-)
A guillotine would be the easy way out, they should be thrown into poverty and and wrapped in an old blanket for warmth carry a sign that reads " Homeless Please help" that would be true punishment. And maybe even that would be too good for them but let us not end their misery quickly by lopping off their heads, maybe a cell with Bernie for the rest of their lives would be good. the inmates would love the pretty ones. They could get it stuck to them the way they stuck it to the american public.
One more thought if I may....Great article Kerryg
Issues, Aya, and Misha, I wrote this hub in a fit of annoyance over Liddy's smugly infuriating letter, so the CEOs and other executives were the aspect I focused on, but I do agree with all of you that it's a systemic problem involving the current and all recent presidents, Congress, the media, and the owners/shareholders of the corporatations as well as the executives themselves. However, that's several more hubs worth of material!
Alot of anger going on today. But I'm with you. Here's another hub that might get you riled up
I got a little more to say, sorry but I do. 12 people no longer on the payroll for AIG getting a million dollar bonus. put that into the unemployment accounts and help those who really need it. Extend unemployment for those who deserve it. WOW 12 million dollars to help those who really need it. the X employees, I'm sure can get by on what they have already stashed away while working for AIG, perhaps they might have to give up the yacht and a car or two....poor babies
I got a little more to say, sorry but I do. 12 people no longer on the payroll for AIG getting a million dollar bonus. put that into the unemployment accounts and help those who really need it. Extend unemployment for those who deserve it. WOW 12 million dollars to help those who really need it. the X employees, I'm sure can get by on what they have already stashed away while working for AIG, perhaps they might have to give up the yacht and a car or two....poor babies
Hang Chris Dodd while we are at It to , he put In that clause for their bonuses ! And I want to cash In for my share of that 80 % ,I want no help from our Government !
tony0724, be fair to Dodd - his original clause would have denied the bonuses, but Geithner and Summers felt that was "too aggressive" and got him to rewrite it. Blame them, not Dodd.
TheSandman, I've heard that too. I wouldn't have thought it was possible to be angrier about this, but paying "retention" bonuses to employees who have already left the company does it!
goldentoad, thanks for the rec!
And thanks to CW, Ralph, and MindField for your comments!
I should also add, Tony, that conservatives are hardly blameless in this matter either: http://blogs.tnr.com/tnr/blogs/the_plank/archive/2
I understand the anger, but this has been going on for at least six months, probably longer. When the bank I worked for failed, all the top executives left with big money because technically, since they didn't take TARP funds (the bank forced to buy them did), none of the rules limiting executive compensation applied. So they were richly rewarded for killing the bank, and thousands of ordinary employees lost their jobs.
Well I hated that job and I learned a lot working there, all of it negative but definitely worth knowing. But what troubles me about this AIG stuff is the public is being manipulated. We're being jerked around over this. This outrageous compensation crap has been going on for a long, long time. If we'd have seen more righteous anger earlier, maybe the financial system wouldn't melting down now.
I do agree we are being played for fools though. More and more I think this can't end well. It's very bad. We should start an HP knitting circle for when it all goes down. We'll need the support!
PS--Misha says sugar, salt, and matches. Make sure you have plenty. I'm also stocking dry beans and rice. :0)
I better learn to shoot though.
Best add iodine and medical basics.
I wonder what Mme Defarge was knitting as she sat by the guillotine. Probably socks. Personally I'll be knitting blankets. It might be a long, hard winter.
And now four months later, what have we seen about all of this? It's been swept under the carpet, as it were. I am still awaiting the prosecutions and the ridding of the White House staff of former AIG employees and the mindset which brought much of this disaster about.
Cheers!
Chef Jeff.
Photo Credit





















issues veritas says:
9 months ago
kerryg
I agree with a lot of your hub but I Bush didn't do it all alone, he had 537 politicians helping him along. My blame is on the entire system, especially Congress. Anything that Bush did that wasn't right they could have made it better, but when you have Bush doing one thing wrong and the Congress doing a different thing wrong, then you have two things wrong.
The two party system is the problem, they just can't do anything good together.
You are right that there is no accountability and I can't remember if or whenever there was accountability. Also, having a 2 year campaign for President really stopped Congress in its tracks, not that we noticed the difference. The Senators and Congressmen that were running for the election either the Presidency or re-election in Congress didn't do much other than campaign. The ones that weren't running took to raising money for their party. In the end, nothing was accomplished for good of the country.
So in my opinion, not only did our economic system fail but so did our political system.