Dropping Out Of College: Should I Allow My Adult Children Move Back Home?
83So has your adult son or daughter flunked out of college? Having been a college student myself that witnessed students partying while I studied hard and and maintained a high GPA, I must admit I had very little respect for those who ended up on academic probation. It is pretty hard to flunk out of a US college or university, so I hate to tell you this, but your son or daughter must have been working pretty hard to get to this place. There are certain circumstances where I might understand someone failing course, such as death in the family, or having to work several jobs to pay for tuition. On the other hand, I have very little respect for people whose parents pay for everything and they still fail their courses. Students who do not have jobs have all the time in the world to study and very few excuses for flunking out of college. I even knew students who never studied and were able to buckle down a week before midterms and finals, so it is possible to pass your courses in most circumstances. I do not recommend procrastination and cramming, but just being apathetic and not trying is a waste of money and time. Unless a college student was suffering from a major illness or experienced a traumatic event, most likely he or she was partying or just not studying in order to completely fail. Certain programs like biomed are understandable because there is a high attrition rate, but if your teen is failing psychology courses you might want to ask them if they ever cracked the books. Most colleges and universities put a student on academic probation before they are expelled, so most students have known about their grades well in advance and were given time to rectify the situation. As a parent you might want to reconsider paying for your son or daughter's education if you notice they are failing their courses. This is not harsh because often people will only appreciate things they have to pay for themselves.
Some college students argue that they did not know courses would require so much time set aside for study, but this is something everyone should keep in mind before applying to four year universities. If you are looking for an easier course load it makes more sense to first apply to a community college or a technical school to take one or two course, but having a full ride paid by your parents' to a major university and not respecting their money is slightly disrespectful. I had to pay for college myself, and in certain circumstance I think that students who are partying should have their parents stop footing the bill. Maybe if these college students had to pay for their own books and tuition they might take college more seriously and see it as an opportunity to learn rather than a chance to just hang out and socialize. On the other hand ,some college students are mature and simply realize that school is not for them, which in that case they will drop out and get a job. However, if you have the opportunity to finish your degree it is for the best because this is experience that you can put on your resume, and you can always get real world experience working at a job as you pursue a four year degree.
Setting Boundaries
Here are some guidelines to help your son or daughter realize that moving back home is only a temporary measure. These are only suggestions and not absolutes:
1. College may not be for your adult son or daughter at the moment, but they will need to get a job if this is the case.
2. Give your adult son or daughter a specific time frame for finding a job and moving out of the house.
3. Let your adult son or daughter know that once this deadline passes they will need to start looking for their own apartment. Help them go look for apartments and apply for jobs if needed. As long as parents encourage their kids they will be able to find a job and apartment in due time. In this economy it is harder to find a job right now, but the first job offered should usually be taken. I personally will work at any legal and respectable job available because during this economic crisis it is much important to have money than to hold out for one's ego.
4. Help your son or daughter go to an unemployment office or search online for a local area job.
5. Help your son or daughter enroll in community college to get back on track academically. Community colleges allow students to take courses without prerequisites, which is a needed solution for a student that failed out of a major university.
6. Discuss with your son or daughter why their grades were so low, and help them explore options for getting extra help. Do they need more tutoring or special services, such as extra time to complete tests and essays?
7. Help your son or daughter find a tutor if they need help with a subject once they have enrolled in a community college.
8. Decide whether you are comfortable with your adult son or daughter living at home if they are going to flaunt responsibilities such as college. They were over eighteen and no one forced them to go off to college, so discuss living arrangements outside the home that will teach them responsibility. People grow up pretty quick when they realize that on their own they have to get a job to pay rent/utilities.
9. Help your son or daughter enroll in a job core program, which will train him or her in a vocational career of their choice. Job core programs often offer housing, which will help to get your son or daughter out of the house and on their own.
10. Help your son or daughter enroll in a local training school or career college that offers shorter programs than community college and universities. Often private career colleges and trade schools are more expensive than going the community college route, but the courses at this institutions are tailored to the needs of those who prefer a hands on type of career, such as being a being an EMT, a medical assistant, a fire fighter, a carpenter, or an electrician. Those courses can also be taken at a community college, but trade schools often allow students to complete their training in less than a year.
Help your adult children take their time with finding their academic and career path, but do not allow them to sit at home and not work. I People often say they cannot find a job, but to be quite frank I do not believe this because often people are being picky about the type of job they want. Yes in this ecnomy it is not easy and will take longer, but being proactive and putting in applications on a daily basis is better than just sitting by and doing nothing. Any job is better than no job, and places such as McDonald's and Burger King are constantly in need of new workers. I know because when my sister first moved in with me she needed a job and decided to try McDonald's, but she quit after only three days because she did not like the working conditions. I was not happy about this because guess who got to pay the rent for two months straight, and it was silly for her to quit because they pleaded with her not to. My sister eventually found a new job, but only after I told her I could not afford to pay the rent all by myself. So in the meantime if your son or daughter is looking for a job tell them to find anything for the present and not to be too picky as they can always find a better job later. When I went to school there were students who felt they were above students that worked fast food or at the library, but what they did not understand was we needed these jobs to pay for our tuition. A job is a job and I take pride in my work no matter where I go and what I do, which is something that always makes me feel accomplished.
I put myself through college, worked part-time, and studied very hard to graduate with honors in four years, so I do not mean to sound harsh towards those who flunk out of college, but the reality is adult children need to learn to take responsibility for themselves. Allowing your adult son or daughter to move home and live there rent free is not helping them, so it is better to encourage and set a good example. I knew parents who allowed their adult children to move back home rent free, and ten years later some of them are still there and never attempt to find a job. The choice as a parent is yours, but tough love is needed to help your son or daughter navigate the waters after dropping out of college.
Tips On Success In College
| No Photo |
How to Succeed in College, Herbert C. Gabhart, Acceptab
Current Bid: $1.00
|
|
|
College Rules!: How to Study, Survive and Succeed in Co
Current Bid: $10.50
|
|
|
College Rules!: How to Study, Survive and Succeed in Co
Current Bid: $1.00
|
|
|
College Rules!: How to Study, Survive, and Succeed in C
Current Bid: $11.96
|
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
RyanRE,
I agree, parents should be encouraging of their adult children, but we should not enable them to take advantage of people either. I wrote this hub in a very blunt tough love fashion to make my point. Thanks for reading and commenting.
Well I totally agree with you both..sometimes there can circumstances though that need your understanding and help...but to let them stay rent free and not work..no no no...They are adults and need to be able to cope with the adult world...somehow I wonder though if the ones that act like this were actually pampered AND NOT TAUGHT these important comcepts while growing up?/ It is the parents responsiblilty from the beginning to teach and prepare them for their adulthood.... afterall we are the elders....thanks for an informative hub Sweetie Pie...;G-Ma :o) Hugs
G-Ma- Johnson,
Thanks for your comments and insights. When I wrote this hub it may come across as harsh, but I was using the tough love tactic that some parents use with their teenagers. You are right, if a child is pampered a little too much when they were younger, it may be difficult for them to adjust to on the responsibility of being an adult. Some college students I knew had their parents paying their entire way through undergrad, but it became a shock when their parents cut off funds for graduate school. I have heard some of parents complain about how their adult children were taking advantage of them, so this is why I wrote this hub with these suggestions in mind. Of course it is up to the individual parent, but when someone is asking what to do about their child who has flunked out of college and moved back home, it sounds as if the parent is bewildered. Also, even though this may just be a hypothetical request, it sounds as if someone asking this question is not happy with their adult child moving back home after dropping out of college.
My feeling is adult children should at least get a job and explore their academic or vocational options if they are going to move back home. I know some people that complain about their thirty something year old children living at home, but it is up to the parents to kick their children out if they are not making a contribution. Once again this is up to the individual parent, but my feeling is adult children should be working hard so they can do some nice things for their parents in their old age, and not so their parents drain their retirement funds supporting their adult children. Also, some adult never went to college and never got a job, but their parents just allowed them to continue living at home without a job. Unless they are the odd ball guru like the guy on Wedding Crashers, then I would guess this lifestyle is not very appealing. However, that is just me because I appreciate having my independence and being able to pay for my own things.
Excellent hub! I fully agree with you. When you let an adult child move back home, you are usually enabling them. My brothers are two examples. One is 39 and the other is 40. Several years ago, she let each one move back home for a year to get back on their feet. Did it help their situation? No. One either lives in a homeless shelter or in his truck. He has schizophrenia so at least he has an excuse. The other brother has been living in his van since mom put down the law. In five years, he has not worked at a job for more than six months, and most of the time, he has been out of work. It isn't because he can't find a job though. He just doesn't want to work at anything unless it feels rewarding to him. So, did my mom help them out by letting them come back home. NO. You are definitely right.
seamist,
I agree that we are not helping adults by allowing them to move back home. Yes in other cultures there are three generations living at home, but that is a much different situation because everyone is working and contributing. In fact, three generations usually live together in some cultures so the children and grandchildren can take care of their elders in their old age. I hate to say it, but I do not think the average adult child living at home is going to want to take care of their parents in their old age. Some will, but many others will also take advantage if you do not lay down the law. My grandpa had seven children and while most went on to be functioning adults, my aunt always tried to take advantage of people. Apparently my grandpa let her at the age of forty and her teenage daughter move in for awhile, but he had to ask them to leave because they started taking money and trashing his house. She next moved on to each of her brothers and sisters, until no one wanted to put up with her antics anymore.
Eventually she came to visit us in California and was trying to stay with us rent free, but our house was too small and my parents could not afford to support her and her teenager daughter. Her scheming went so far that she even asked my dad's friend if she could stay with them. My aunt was perfectly capable of getting a job, but she often quit because she did not want to work. She even had a college scholarship and went up until her junior year, but she dropped out towards the end because she became tired of studying. So I agree, if you enable people to take advantage they will take a mile as the old saying goes. I love my aunt, but she is a very manipulative person and when we saw her again years later she tried to guilt trip my mom about not raising my cousin as her own daughter. Sometimes people just have to draw the line, and in her case we had to as a family. All of us were always there to help her, but she never appreciated the help, and often was manipulative unless she got her way 100% of the time.
I generally agree with your opinion about how a sizeable proportion of students do not take college seriously. You're absolutely correct in saying it is hard to drop out - colleges do not want flunkers since it detracts from their ratings and esteem.
In the UK the government has pushed too many students towards university at the expense of the technical colleges/trades. Not everybody should be at college as you say!
A great hub and some really useful talking points here.
Pjdscott,
I am glad you also see some students just do not want to go to college. My sister on the one hand is very brillant academically, but she does not do well when given an assignment to complete in school. She would rather read and book and write a story on her own. She has a good job right now and may go to college in the future, but it is not her choice to go right now. I think that parents' should help their kids find their path, but not force them to go to college if that is not their choice. Hopefully this will alleviate part of the desire to want to drop out.
When I moved out, I moved out permanently! I think it's stupid for people to reside as late 20-something video gaming basement dwellers...I have friends who have done that too. I just think it's a visible, distinct portrayal of the maturity of people in our time. It's a lacking feature, but perhaps things will change...though not likely with the economic crisis as persuasion to cop more off of daddy's wallet.
I agree, it is not mature or wise to expect your parents to take care of you for the rest of your life. Parents need to plan for their retirement to, and some people have put this off because they are constantly getting their kids out of a jam. It is one thing to support and help you children, but I never understood kids who did not ever do things for their parents. Even when I did live at home for a bit I paid for the groceries and many other things.
My parents made me pay my college bills. It wasn't til I moved out and got married that they started to bail my wife and I out on a few small things here and there. Bailing out of children no doubt is the major influence to our politicians right now....the idea that they need to make every decision for us as if we're too immature to do so ourselves...
Vote Libertarian 2008 to eradicate this problem :P
There, my political plug for the day!
That is good you are responsible and I think there is a big difference between helping kids once and awhile as opposed to paying for all of their things. Thanks for sharing your insights on this issue.
Thank you for answering my request.
I was glad to answer your request Tom. Sorry did not see your comment earlier.
You sound like a person with a lot of experience and maturity. I agree with every word you say. I find a lot of comfort in what you say. I have a son who is in his junior year of college and is flunking out. He had a scholarship and I was paying for his other expenses. I just found out that his flunking this semester again and therefore I have decided to cut him off financially. I have told him that I will be paying for his apartment until May and than his on his own. It hurts tremendously but I know I must do this to make him grow up and take responsibility for his choices. He doesn't want to quit college but he doesn't try to get a job either. Believe me he wasn't raise this way, I am profoundly disappointed in the choices his made. I pray and hope that he will be smart enough to make better choices from this point forward. As I see it his future is in his hands. I am taking this action because I love him dearly and I only want what is best for him. At present we have no communication and yes it hurts but I don't want him to end up like your aunt. By the way my son is 20. Thank you
Marissa,
You sound like a good mom that is helping your son tremendously. I am sorry he is not taking his finances more seriously, but keep in mind this is his own choice and not reflective upon you whatsoever. I have a feeling he will come around once he sees he has to pay for things on his own. One day he will thank you.
my college-senior daughter is dating one of these drop outs... he's been on his own for 2 years working minimally but makes his rent & pays his bills (for the most part) but no ambitions to do anything more... we just keep telling to pursue her career interests ... i think his insecurities will come through and he'll move on (tough lesson on our daughter) despite her attempts to motivate him.
Hi Caroline,
The great thing is he can go back to school at any time in his life, but does she really want to wait around for him to get his act together. Not to be judgemental, but I have come to the point I just do not want to date men who are still trying to get their lives together because most are not ready for a serious relationship. This guy might be, but if they were to get more serious and eventually get married it would be a struggle. She might even end up having to be the more stable one in the relationship, and that could make her resent him later on. Of course she will have to figure these things out for herself, but overall in today's world I have just learned many young men are more focused on being single and enjoying their lives than taking relationships seriously. Not all men are this way, but it is becoming more prevalent. He could be one of those few that gets a good career without a college education, but those are usually the extraordinary talented few that can pull that off.
















RyanRE says:
13 months ago
I think you said it all in that last paragraph "adult children need to learn to take responsibility for themselves." When they leave the nest they need to be able to fly. Parents should still be encouraging and helpful, but they shouldn't be enablers.