Overrated Fantasy Football Players
68
ADP
ADP: Stands for Average Draft Pick according to ESPN's fantasy draft results.
Most Over Valued Players
These are players who are drafted in the top 5 rounds who on average been drafted higher than they are worth. Some players price tags are too high like purchasing a Walmart t-shirt for one hundred dollars. While others values have not been adjusted and put on sale or discount because of past performances.
|
|
McFarlane Toys NFL Sports Picks Series 17 (2008 Wave 1) Action Figure Tony Romo 2 (Dallas Cowboys) Dirty Uniform
Price: $9.45
List Price: $19.99 |
|
Dallas Cowboys Tony Romo Junior Wall Decal
Price: $39.99
List Price: $39.99 |
|
Tony Romo (Dallas Cowboys) 2010 Wall Calendar
Price: $14.99
List Price: $14.99 |
|
DALLAS COWBOYS NFL CAR TRUCK FLOOR MATS by NORTHWESTERN VINYL GO ROMO TO PACMAN JONES TEXAS STADIUM STAR
Price: $30.99
|
Over Priced Quarterbacks
Peyton Manning ADP 16.8
Yes, he is one of the best quarterbacks in the league. He
finished 6th overall last year among quarterbacks. But without Dungy
Harrison his numbers will take a hit. He will still be a top 10 Quarterback but
this is not enough to justify a second round pick.
Actual Value: third round pick
Alternatives: Aaron Rodgers ADP 35
Phillip Rivers ADP 39.5
Kurt Warner ADP 33.2
Good Quarterback, but I would rather draft take the
alternatives who finished higher than him last year. Warner’s age makes him an injury concern(He recently had his
hip repaired).
Actual Value: fourth round pick
Alternatives: Aaron Rodgers ADP 35
Phillip Rivers ADP 39.5
Tony Romo ADP 43.4
He was a top 10 quarterbacks statistically last year, but finished 12th among fantasy quarterbacks. Also, this year he will be with out star receiver Terrell Owens. I don’t feel Romo who was outside of the top ten quarterbacks last year is worth more than players who were inside the top 10. If he could not crack the top ten last year with Terrell Owens, who is to say he will this season without him.
Actual Value: sixth round pick
Alternatives: Jay Cutler (Number 4) ADP 77.3
Donavon McNabb (Number 7) APD 58.2.
|
Madden NFL 10
Price: $39.00
List Price: $59.99 |
|
Madden NFL 10
Price: $31.49
List Price: $49.99 |
|
Madden NFL 10
Price: $38.00
List Price: $59.99 |
|
Madden NFL 10
Price: $35.98
List Price: $39.99 |
Over Priced Running Backs
Chris Johnson ADP 8.9
He finished last season 11 among running backs. For a guy he once
broke 20 carries once last season and was not much of a receiving threat, a first round pick
is too high for this speedy sophomore.
Actual Value: Second round pick
Alternatives: Steve Slaton ADP 17.4 second round.
Frank Gore ADP 13.7
The 49ers are not any better than they were last
year. Gore rushed over 100 yards only three times last season and seemed to
wear down throughout the season.
Actual Value: Fourth round pick
Alternatives: Brandon Jacobs ADP 14.9
Clinton Portis ADP 20.6 Steve Slaton ADP
17.4
Marion Barber ADP 22.3
Barber was once a fantasy beast finishing with 10 plus touchdowns the last two seasons (2006-2007). But after a 2008 collapse I have my doubts. With Felix Jones and Choice fighting for carries Barber’s production will decrease. This is a guy who has never rushed over 1,000 yards in a season! He has slipped into a third round pick. So, if you plan on drafting running backs with your first two picks go ahead and draft Barber as a questionable flex if you must have him. But for those for you that will be drafting differently stay clear of Barber.
Actual Value: Fifth round pick
Alternatives: Brandon Jacobs ADP 14.9
Clinton Portis ADP 20.6 Steve Slaton ADP 17.4
Ronnie Brown ADP 31.2
Brown has only 6 games over 10 fantasy points
last season. With reports of Ricky Williams looking good in camp, I do not see
Brown being the featured back.
Williams has run well in the preseason averaging 6.5 on 13 carries.
Actual Value: 5th Round pick
Alternatives: Kevin Smith ADP 33.2
Pierre Thomas ADP34.8
Ryan Grant ADP 38.0
Darren McFadden ADP 42.9
McFadden is an unproven fantasy option. He will be sharing
carries with Michael Bush and Justin Fargas. Even if he was the lone running
back, Oakland does not offer many scoring opportunities.
Actual Value: 13 Round Pick
Alternatives: Derrick Ward ADP 52.1
Jonathan Stewart ADP 58.8
Larry Johnson ADP 59.7
Marshawn Lynch ADP 48.6
He is missing the first 3 games due to
suspension. Fred Jackson is filling in the role of starting running back
while Lynch serves his suspension. I think Jackson has the talent to take over the starting running back job. Why, not take a top tier tight end like Antonio Gates at ADP 50.0 instead.
Actual Value: Ninth Round
Alternatives: Derrick Ward ADP 52.1
Jonathan Stewart ADP 58.8
Larry Johnson ADP 59.7
Over Priced Wide Recievers
Roy E. Williams ADP 44.2
He
was not the number one guy in Detroit nor was he the number one guy in Dallas
last year. I can’t justify drafting a guy who has just one 1,000 plus yard
season and played only one full 16 game season of football. He is WAY over hyped.
Actual Value: Round 13
Alternatives: Brandon Marshall ADP 43.8
T.J. Houshmandzadeh
ADP 44.7
My Fantasy Football Blog
- Fantasy Football WisDome
Everything football
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
Good insight!
Thank you two for your comments!
Ouch, I can't agree with Gore being undervalued. I couldnt take portis before Gore. Maybe last year, but that offense will give him 6,000 carries this year. Interesting article though.
Gawd, you're almost as crazy about American Football as I am about Movies! :)
Great hub!
Thanks!
Really useful info, great post
Chris Johnson is probably a top 3 fantasy player overall. He's worth any pick.
Fantasy Football Players in the News
- Fantasy Football: Fantasy as unpredictable as the real sportMPNnow.com18 hours ago
Fantasy football: a crapshoot? I’ve had this debate with friends for about as long as I’ve taken fantasy football seriously. Last week didn’t help my side of the debate.
- Fantasy football: As unpredictable as the real sportThe Journal-Standard32 hours ago
Fantasy football: a crapshoot?
- Fantasy football: Plenty of choices for Week 17Detroit Free Press2 days ago
There's good news and bad news for fantasy football leagues that play championship games in the final week of the regular season.

















dohn121 says:
4 months ago
I think that Darren McFadden has the best nickname of them all: Run DMC is awesome, but let's see how he does with the Silver and Bleak in his sophomore year.
Another outstanding job my friend. I wish you well in your fantasy league!