create your own

Railroads Trying for Comeback

69
rate or flag this page

By William F. Torpey


Amtrak train Northbound on the old New Haven Line
Amtrak train Northbound on the old New Haven Line
In Saugatuck, Connecticut
In Saugatuck, Connecticut

The heyday of our nation's passenger trains is a distant memory for those of us old enough to remember when railroad travelers were treated like royalty.

In the early '60s while shuttling to New York University from Connecticut I took a course in customer relations that turned out to be one of my most memorable, largely because the professor told the class, in a casual and entertaining style, about the glory days of the railroads.

Those were the days when porters greeted passengers with a smile as they raced to help you find your sleeping accommodations, conductors made sure your trip was without untoward incidents, stewards made sure you had a place in the dining car and a good meal -- and other attendants helped with information about other onboard services.

World War II and the financial decline of the railroads after the war led to service that was spotty at best for train travelers. Railroad management, trying to keep costs under control, spent years berating trade unions for featherbedding.

Railroad management won the battle, but lost the war. The unions lost the battle, and the war; both management and the unions were losers.

But passengers lost, too! Personnel cutbacks left trains so understaffed that some rolled along without as much as a conductor. It got so bad for a while that underworld types became aware of easy pickin's on the trains; they would hop on a train at one station, rob some passengers and hop off at the next stop.

But things may be turning around. Amtrak, at least, is trying!

I've been taking the sleeper to Fort Lauderdale (from Connecticut) for several years. While I love trains, and have a high tolerance for pain when it comes to travel, service and accommodations on Amtrak in the past sometimes left something to be desired.

But, lo and behold, the improvement this year has been remarkable.

When I arrived at Pennsylvania Station, literally moments before departure time, a redcap tossed my suitcase and golf bag on a dolly and escorted me in good humor to my sleeping compartment; the "chief of onboard services" showed up to explain the workings of the new sleeping cars -- sink, toilet, upper and lower bunks, tray (with chessboard) and lights, as well as a dining schedule and hours of operation of the lounge car.

Another service employee came by with a complimentary bottle of Chardonnay, a nice wine glass and tie-bag containing virtually every toiletry item one might need on an overnight trip (I received the same gifts on the return trip.) Everyone was courteous, even friendly.

The stewards also were courteous and did a great job. While the menu offers a selection of only a half dozen items, the hamburger and fish I had were well prepared and of good quality.

I don't have any relatives on Amtrak's payroll, but I offer this endorsement:

For my money, Amtrak is making a welcome effort to improve service, despite budget cutbacks. To me, passenger rail travel, as a means of transportation, comes second only to the trolley car (which I grew up with in Yonkers, N.Y.)

If you're planning a trip, consider going by rail! Unless you're a certified "Type A" personality, you'll like it!

I wrote this column as a "My View" for The Hour newspaper of Norwalk, Conn., on April 5, 1997. Since then the railroads, and Amtrak in particular, have struggled with tight budgets. As a result, efforts at a comeback have been spotty. I now write my views on a wide variety of topics on HubPages. You can, too. It's easy, and free! Get paid for writing about what you love, or whatever interests you!. HubPages makes the technical part easy. Make friends and get help on its active forum. Take a quick tour to see how easy it is to get started today Click Here -- To view my HubPages Profile Click Here


Should America invest more in passenger rail service?

  • Yes
  • No
See results without voting

  • Railroads favored Wilmington over TewksburyWilmington Town Crier1 second ago

    TEWKSBURY - When the Boston & Lowell Railroad opened in 1835, Tewksbury found itself “off-line.” The railroad almost completely bypassed the town. It ran through Wilmington and Billerica, with the tracks only crossing a tiny corner of Tewksbury, land that was later annexed by Lowell.

  • Early Glance: Railroads companiesINO News3 days ago

    (AP:NEW YORK) Shares of some top railroads companies are mixed at 10 a.m.: Burlington Northern fell $.05 or .1 percent, to $98.68. CSX fell $.17 or .3 percent, to $48.95.

  • Early Glance: Railroads companiesINO News4 days ago

    (AP:NEW YORK) Shares of some top railroads companies are mixed at 10 a.m.: Burlington Northern rose $.10 or .1 percent, to $98.55. CSX fell $.15 or .3 percent, to $49.01.

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

bogey047  says:
2 years ago

I really enjoyed that article. I would like to take a vacation riding the rails soon. I just don't know where they go to and how many train changes you have to make to get to your destination?

compu-smart profile image

compu-smart  says:
2 years ago

Good points William,,

It is such a shame that things have not improved with all kinds of services available to the public, which one would expect as time goes by especially as were far from a 3rd world countys!!

Here in the UK most of our transport systems have all been priavatised which has not helped things at all!!

Bogey.. Just jump on and enjoy the ride!;)

William F. Torpey profile image

William F. Torpey  says:
2 years ago

Thanks for the comment, Bogey047. It all depends on where you're located. I lived in Connecticut at the time, so I had to take the train to Pennsylvania Station in New York City to pick up the sleeper to Florida. For long distance, the sleepers are great!

I'd love to see Amtrak get better funding from the government, compu-smart, but they apparently don't have much of a lobby compared to the auto and airline industries. I sure hope they don't even think about privatizing the railroads here in the U.S.

pjdscott profile image

pjdscott  says:
2 years ago

It's great to hear about these positive changes. Some years ago we travelled all over the east coast/Chicago/Montreal/Buffalo on an Amtrak rover ticket and had a wonderful time. I would agree that the service and comfort was not always great, but the staff were!

Super hub and thumbs up to you William.

William F. Torpey profile image

William F. Torpey  says:
2 years ago

 It's been a while, pjdscott, since I've ridden the rails, and I miss it. Your trip sounds like it was fun. Thanks for the thumbs up!

Bob  says:
2 years ago

Wish they would come back. If you have the time , the best way to see this Wonderful Country is with your nose pushed up against the window.

William F. Torpey profile image

William F. Torpey  says:
2 years ago

Thanks for the comment, Bob. The only thing better than the trains were the old trolleys. If gas prices don't stop going up, maybe they'll come back!

Spuffler  says:
3 weeks ago

In 2001, my wife and I took an Amtrack vacation. Keep in mind that I loved the rail trip, although later I might sound critical. We boarded in Boston, Massachusetts in the mid afternoon, taking our assigned sleeper with the pleasant company of the coachman when his time permitted. The sleeper was odd, in that it had a lot of brushed aluminum edging and acres of lima bean green molded fiberglass seemingly everywhere in the interior of the cabin. The fold down sink struck me as out of place, too. The trip to Chicago was mostly uneventful, but the sleeper just smacked of sterility and industrial ethic. From Chicago, where we switched trains, to LA, the cars were a bit older, but there were minimal sharp edges and lots of carpet, heavy cloth, darker colors and a bit more creature comfort in the cabin style. Throughout, interpersonal service from Amtrak employees was at least better than airlines. The real failure was the trackage. I recall areas west of Des Moines heading southwest towards Phoenix, where people walking from car to car (on the upper levels of the more elaborate sleepers) were completely thrown to the floor by the rapid shifting of the rails beneath us (and flange noise woke me many times). While I understand there will be gentle rocking motions from the better trackage, I'd have to demand substantial improvements in trackage before I'd talk openly about american rail transport. The leading downside of rail travel is clearly the travel time as compared to flight; lets not also lose customers by the need to tell passengers they should consider not walking about because 'we are on a rough stretch of track'.

Recent talk from the president wants us to think that passenger rail may yet grow, but lets not lose sight of the 'recession', lets keep in mind lessons from a much needed tunnel in Boston that fails frequently yet made many contractors rich (in a time with stretches of relative prosperity). I seriously doubt any investment in high speed rail is going to produce large volumes of high speed commuter traffic in more than a single segment. So much money, so many chances for incompatibilities, so many chances to line a pocket, so many entrenched commuting habits. And then there is the idea of why would I travel - work? My career isn't going to need me to head towards big cities, and the majority of employment in the cities is all services based and does not pay well enough to draw me into the cities that may gain high speed rail services.

William F. Torpey profile image

William F. Torpey  says:
3 weeks ago

I don't disagree with your comments, Spuffler. Nevertheless, rail travel remains good, but it could be far better. It requires heavy investment, true, and that will come eventually. More routes, better accommodations and better service will accompany the growth of railroads when it no longer is possible to keep up with the pollution of oil and gasoline burning automobiles (See the hub I wrote about Darien: http://hubpages.com/hub/Darien-Could-Be-Paradise

tonymac04 profile image

tonymac04  says:
2 weeks ago

Great Hub and yes, I love rail travel also. Have linked this Hub to mine on the Pretoria-based Friends of the Rail.

Love and peace

Tony

William F. Torpey profile image

William F. Torpey  says:
2 weeks ago

Thanks, Tony, for the nice comment and the link. Happy holidays.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working