create your own

Should you tell your child the truth about who their parent is?

72
rate or flag this page

By ethel smith


Why create this hub?

CHANGING TIMES

With people these days often having many relationships throughout their lives and bearing children out of wedlock the true parentage of a child is often a mystery. Knowing at least two couples who have chosen to keep one of their children's parentage a secret I have given this subject some thought.

As with most things in this life it is down to individual choice and what will ultimately be best for the child. However no matter how much I think about this matter I cannot see that it is right and proper to keep such information withheld from a child.

Yes, there may be instances where:-

  • The actual parent's identity is unknown
  • The child is the result of a rape or an attack
  • The parent is a totally horrible person.

On the whole though I think, if possible, that it is important to be honest with children. Whatever you decide though it will not be easy.

Personal thoughts-Secrets and Lies

Nine times out of ten it seems that it will be the father's identity that is not known. A woman and her baby may move in with a new partner and the child may then never know any difference.

If this relationship is successful and marriage or a long term relationship ensues then other children may follow. Here to my mind lies some of the biggest problems. So often the father will find it hard not to treat his own blood relative in a different manner to his partner's child.

I can understand why, in such cases, the parents want to wait until such a time as the child is an appropriate age to understand the information that she or he is being told. However, deciding what the right time and age will be is a nightmare. If you are not careful the child may discover their true identity long before you can be up front with them.

In the past I have known someone who discovered her parentage by stumbling across her birth certificate when, as a nosey 11 year old, she was searching through cupboards. How devastating. It was something which screwed her up for years and she never really came to terms with.

I have also known someone who found out, that the person she knew and loved as Dad was not her father, when her mother, in a temper, blurted out the truth to her one sad day. Fancy keeping a secret 16 years only to reveal it in such a terrible way, and in anger. Another poor soul left with a scrambled mind.

Finally, I came across a person who said that, a member of her own family had told the child the truth about who his Dad was, when she had fallen out with the woman. How cruel and nasty. This woman was going to tell her little boy when he was a little older but instead he had to hear it in such a way. Suffice to say the relationship between this Mum and Son is strained to say the least.

Deciding on the right time and age will not be easy. However hopefully my instances will make you think carefully about whether it is right to withhold such information in the long run.

No doubt there will be some who withhold such information as it is easier for them and because it seems much too hard to be honest. However, if you love your child you must want to do what is best for them.

Think ahead to when the child is an adult. For example, the child may have a health issue that needs a full family health record. Then again the birth certificate will maybe hold part of the true story and so will ultimately be accessed.

Even if the child is an adult before he or she discovers the truth they may be able to cope with the information. However some do not cope well when eventually told. I have known a grown man who, when he found out in later years that he had been adopted, spent all of his time looking at people and wondering if they were his real parents. Adoption these days though is less fraught with such problems. The Law has changed and children, after a certain age, have a right to certain information.

In Conclusion.

This hub offers little in the way of answers, I am afraid. Hopefully it has given you something to think about, especially if you are directly concerned with such issues.

What my gut instinct says is think very carefully before you decide how to handle such a situation. Remember that other people will no doubt know the truth also. Remember also that people do fall out big style and then do hateful things to each other, so there is really no-one that you can rely on 100% to keep your secret.

Of course there will be some cases where the child was actually fathered by someone else and the father, and perhaps, the mother does not know this. This is a whole different ball game. However remember that especially in respect to health the true parentage could be important knowledge in the years to come.


More of Ethel's Hubs

More of this week's HubMobs

  • Should you tell your child the truth about who their parent is?

    CHANGING TIMES With people these days often having many relationships throughout their lives and bearing children out of wedlock the true parentage of a child is often a mystery. Knowing at least... - 3 months ago

  • Teaching Your Child to Budget

    I know the word "budget" is not one that most people want to hear, but technically the word budget means "a plan for using your money" according to Webster's dictionary. A plan... - 3 months ago

  • Should you buy your child a mobile or cell phone?

    Children these days want, and have, just about every gadget imaginable. DVD players, computers, televisions in their bedrooms and more, so why not their very own mobile phone? Why not indeed! ... - 3 months ago

  • HubMob Weekly topic : Personal finance and parenting

    http://hubpages.com/hub/Secure-Family-Saving-money-for-your-Childrens-future - 3 months ago

  • HubMob of Personal Finance Parenting Advice

    There's tons for adults and kids in this personal finance parenting advice HubMob. This hub is full of helpful tips on personal finance and parenting. Come on in and get some practical how-to's. - 3 months ago

  • Teaching Kids About Money ,Makes Sense

    Where do your kids think money comes from?.. that hole in the wall called an ATM ,or from something a little more realistic, teaching kids about money,makes sense. - 3 months ago

  • Mobile Phone For Your Child-Boon Or Bane?

    Cell phone users are growing every minute in every part of the globe and the user is getting younger. The cell phone and service provider advertisements are increasingly being targeted at the... - 3 months ago

  • Charities – Teaching Kids to Give

    We all know the importance of teaching our kids to manage money well. The question is, do we include giving in that education? Here are some practical ways to help children grow up with a giving... - 3 months ago

What do you think?

Should parents reveal the identity of the true parent?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Maybe
  • In some cases
  • Don't know
See results without voting

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

James A Watkins profile image

James A Watkins  says:
3 months ago

What a sad reflection on our culture that so many women don't know who fathered their child. We should really think about what that says about our society.

I had 2 of my 5 sisters in this situation. I come from a very fractured family. My parents have been married 10 times between them. My 7 brothers and sisters are all half-siblings—nothing wrong with that. It ends up 2 of them are not blood relatives at all, though this was hidden from them (in one case) and all of us (in the other). In both, the truth came out during an angry argument.

One of my sisters was adopted at birth my mom from a prostitute she had been acquainted with since grade school. When my sister was about 16 this woman surfaced and she and my mom quarreled. In her anger, she called my sister and told her she was her mother and there was no telling who was her father. My sister was devastated. Us older kids knew about this but were sworn to secrecy. My sister has never been the same.

My other sister reached her mid-twenties when, during an argument with her mother (my ex-step-mother) her mom told her that my dad was not her dad—as she had always thought: as all of us had always thought. My dad knew the truth but nobody else did, that she had an affair while they were married and my sister was the result of adultery. She was devastated and has never been the same since.

Jaspal profile image

Jaspal  says:
3 months ago

Very interesting subject ... I would think it is important that a child is informed of his parentage if it is different from what seems obvious to him at home. But, simultaneously, he should also be explained the circumstances and he should also be made comfortable in the knowledge that he is very much loved ...

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith  says:
3 months ago

James so you know all too well what I mean. Sometimes families keep secrets with all of the best intentions but secrets have a way of coming out. As you say the result can be devastating.

Jaspal, yes I think it is so important to try and handle these things well and not just thrust on a child.

RNMSN profile image

RNMSN  says:
3 months ago

GREAT HUBMOB ETHEL! DIFFICULT SUBJECT AS WELL...Y0U HAVE A GIFT OF INSIGHT AND AN EASY WAY OF DISCUSSING IT!

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith  says:
3 months ago

Thanks RNMSN. You are too kind.

Vizey profile image

Vizey  says:
3 months ago

Time is changing and people are changing. People should tell their kids that who their parent is. They will become more strong and accept the reality of the world right from the childhood.

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith  says:
3 months ago

I tend to agree Vizey but have found some young couples still keep such things a secret. To each his own I know but personally I think they are storing up trouble for later years.

maggs224 profile image

maggs224  says:
3 months ago

I was adopted and I have always known this fact, I did not know the details until I was a mother myself and I was talking with my mum about a fear I had and she laughed and then she told me about the circumstances. That was one of the few times we spoke of this I wish that she was still alive as I would love to speak to her more about this.

I think we should be told the facts about our parentage even when the circumstances of our conception are not very nice, I am a product of incest and my mum was only twelve when she gave birth to me but inspite of that I still think it is better to know these things. If you are interested I have written a hub about this

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith  says:
3 months ago

Thanks for the comments Maggs. These things are often hard to express I know. I hope this hub and everyone's incite may help someone reading who is undecided on the best course of action. I think it is best to be upfront. The lies can do more damage than the truth.

Yes I will read your hub and link it to this one, if that's OK?

Anthony Hillelson profile image

Anthony Hillelson  says:
3 months ago

Ethel, Thank you for bridging a difficult topic. You did it with such grace and nonjudgement. I was adopted at three years old, so I always knew. What I didn't know from 6 months to 3.5 years old was that my foster parents were not my real parents. This set me up for another huge loss of a mother whom I was very close. That day of tragedy has lived with me ever since. I am 57 years old, raised my own son, become successful in life and I can still recall that frightening day almost as clearly as if it had just happened.

It took a lot of work on myself and therapy, but I no longer live the emotional drama surrounding that terrifying day when some strange woman in black (literally) pulled me out of my mother's arms, as I was screaming and fighting with all my might, then drove off with me, never to see what I believed was my mother, ever again.

That day I lost a sense of security that only a child who believes himself to belong to a loving family recieves in childhood and that carries him throughout his life. It no longer defines my life, yet when anyone asks me, my answer to the debate is, "Please, tell the child the truth from the beginning even if the child is too young to fully understand." Graping the truth a little at a time is far healthier than the cruelness of it being forced upon you in any manner.

Tough subject that you presented quite well. Thanks for sharing.

Anthony

(I've just become a member today and look forward to finishing my first hub and making friends along the way)

ethel smith profile image

ethel smith  says:
3 months ago

Thanks for the personal input Anthony and welcome to HubPages. Words are too futile for me to pass on your comment but I hope others reading it may take heed. Honesty really is the best policy it would seem. It makes me wonder yet again if sometimes the truth is witheld as it is easier for the adults.

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working