How to Spot a Lie

Tactical Behavior Assesment

How to Spot a Liar and The Art of Deception Detection Techniques as taught by active CIA agents for those who trust but verify.

CIA workers are allowed to moonlight for hedge funds corporations in order to spot liars during earnings calls. How to tell if someone is lying is a valuable business skill. Agents teach corporate bigwigs the 'how to' of lie detection for very big money.

A good book to read about this in more detail is 'Broker, Trader, Lawyer, Spy, The Secret World of Corporate Espionage' (2010) by Eamon Javers. In it he discusses Pinkerton, the Nestle and Mars competition and TIA, Tactical Behavior Assessment - who advertise on their homepage " ... rooted in the national intelligence community ... "

Most human communication is non-conversational. The tone and inflection of the voice and the lexicon of gestures convey much more than simply what's being said.

Because the need to speak the truth instinctively, there is a cognitive dissonance that betrays the person's discomfort with telling a lie. Of course, this wouldn't work with a practiced liar who is very comfortable in telling lies.

A weighted database of 'mind markers' of a speaker's gestures exists about expressive cognitive dissonance. Thinking one thing on the inside and saying another on the outside is the reason why able to tell when someone is lying. This is big business as reflected in the article title, 'A comparison of the reproducibility of verbal and nonverbal facial gestures using three-dimensional motion analysis', where it was found that certain words make it easier to notice lip movements - otojournal

What to look for is a cluster of clues. One person is interviewing, the other is off to the side but not taking notes. Each numbered question has a series of dots next to it. After a threshold is reached of how many dots besides each question - the more likely that person is equivocating on that question. Evading direct questions and answering a different question that what was asked is a sure sign. Protesting with weasel words that qualify statements such as; honestly, actually, somewhat, and nearly plus many more shows they are lying. We have all seen and heard these non-answer answers during national political news conferences, such as the famous "Unknown unknowns" utterance by Donald Rumsfeld, the grand-daddy master of obfuscation.

Incongruent thought can bring discomfort not recognized in oneself is usually called denial. - when a person can't understand why they are feeling distressed. A chronic mix up can lead to bad health, poor judgment, pain and stress. The only way out of this dilemma is after self awareness then afterwards - need to reframe the perception and change attitudes called acceptance. The urge is so strong to tell the truth that there was a study conducted on "A study of the effect of cognitive dissonance on symptoms of rhinovirus-induced common colds" (1977), Totman

Cognitive dissonance doesn't happen under forced compliance because without freedom of choice then the person has no other choice and is absolved and OK with it.

After being caught in a lie the interviewer will try to elicit a confession with baiting and presumptive questions which are the interrogation tactics of the 1850s Pinkerton company according to Eamon Javers on BIA techniques. Subliminal coerciveness with mental mind games to destabilize a person's identity in a non physical way is one way to break a person down. Emotional manipulation by undercutting a person's beliefs in order to create instability is used to make a practiced liar uncomfortable, forcing a slip-up in the telling of their story.

According to Scott Shane of the New York Times, the interrogators at Guantánamo Bay used the book of Chinese Communist techniques from the Korean War. - nytimes The Gitmo techniques from the 1950s has been proven to elicit false confessions and is better known as brainwashing.

3 Card Monty

The Big Lie

How much do you lie?

See results without voting

The Big Lie part 2

No .. really the truth this time!

See results without voting

Ways to Catch a Liar

9 Ways to Spot a Lie:


  1. Establish a baseline of behavior first with mundane questions
  2. Ask a question from left field
  3. Look for inconsistency in their story
  4. Look for fake smile or 'out of tune' grimaces from what's being said
  5. Don't rule out your intuitive feelings about the answers given
  6. Watch for microexpressions - a flash of facial expression that lasts a fraction of a second
  7. Look for incongruity between what is being said and the accompanying gestures
  8. Look for any abnormal anxiety
  9. Noticed if answer is overly detailed of information not asked


Unfortunately there is no proving a negative and unable to have no proof if the truth is told, only when a lie is spoken.

Neuroscience of Detection Deception

Emblems

High Tech Lie Detectors

Neuroinformatics Interrogations

Homeland Security's program called Future Attribute Screening Technology (FAST) is intended to create "a real-time non-invasive sensors technologies to detect cues indicative of mal-intent (the intent or desire to cause harm) rapidly, reliably, and remotely." page 116 of 'Mind Wars: Brain Science and the Military in the 21st Century' by Jonathan D. Moreno (May 1, 2012)

Your brain works harder when telling a lie and therefore there is more activity in the prefrontal cortex that can be seen with a functional MRI, or fMRI for short.

Barbara Sahakian said, "A lot of neuroscientists in the field are very cautious and say we can't talk about reading individuals' minds, and right now that is very true, but we're moving ahead so rapidly, it's not going to be that long before we will be able to tell whether someone's making up a story, or whether someone intended to do a crime with a certain degree of certainty." www.guardian.co.uk

These intentions are read about 360 ms before the subject is consciously aware of their own thoughts. Conventional electroencephalograms (EEGs) need to have electrodes inserted onto the scalp but remote sensing for use of mind-machine systems seems akin to the 1956 movie 'Forbidden Planet' where the entire Krell race extinguished itself overnight from the mind controlled machine they invented due to the inner demons of the subconscious mind.

In the future, Pleading the Fifth and refusing to be a witness against oneself will become another quaint idea along with habeas corpus and freedom of speech. Pre-criminal behaviour programs have already been started such as the "indeterminate imprisonment for suspected terrorists" that is part of the National Defense Authorization Act, (NDDA).

The thought police are worse than ever envisioned by George Orwell's 1984;

"There was of course no way of knowing whether you were being watched at any given moment. How often, or on what system, the Thought Police plugged in on any individual wire was guesswork. It was even conceivable that they watched everybody all the time. But at any rate they could plug in your wire whenever they wanted to. You had to live—did live, from habit that became instinct—in the assumption that every sound you made was overheard, and, except in darkness, every movement scrutinized."

All About Lying and the Liars who Lie

True Lies

The check is in the mail. Those pants don't make you look fat. It's company policy. That line of dresses runs small and so you need to go one size up. I'm from the government and I'm here to help you. How good at you at spotting a liar? Are you a good liar?

Everybody lies to some degree every day. One UCSB scholar calculated that people lie twice a day. That seems a rather low figure. I guess if you're alone in an Ivory Tower doing esoteric arithmetic then you don't have much opportunity to lie as much as a Washington politician. A lawyer gets paid to lie, not seek justice. Not outright lies but colored truths to get his client off - even if he knows the client is guilty. I'm sure that if your job involves lying for a living then perhaps an average of 600 lies a day would be normal.

Paid professional liars who earn a buck by it are not the same type of liars as are people who lie in their personal relationships. Lying to young children about Santa Claus is not considered evil or wrong. If your girlfriend asks you if she needs breast implants, it's best to always say no - even if they look like two raisins on an ironing board. Being brutally honest and honestly brutal are two different things.

Lying is definitely OK if it would save a person's life. If a genocidal crowd was at your door demanding if you're harboring any unwanted outcasts then it would be morally right to hide a defenseless would be victim. Or to save your own life, it could be possible to say, "No! I killed them yesterday and had them for breakfast this morning. I love to join you in your killing rampage but I'm a bit full right now."

There are different degrees of lying. Bearing false witness in court is a criminal act. Putting up a snow job with your boss during a performance review is par for the course. Enron fudged facts that hurt thousands of people. Voodoo economics is a failed national policy. Disinformation is a winning stratagem of war and diplomacy. Most of these events are beyond a person's control.

What about the person who you are sharing your life with? The closest one to you? Your significant other? Surely if there is anybody you would like to be completely honest with you is your significant other.Or would you? We all lie to ourselves to prop up our own ego.

That orgasm was real - hey I'm a really good lover! The dryer shrunk my jeans. I wasn't a jerk last night when I said yes, she needed a boob job. I can quit cigarettes anytime I want to - I just don't want to right now. I'm going to quit drinking and this time - I mean it! If I can fake sincerity, then she will realize what a nice honest guy I am.I'm fine. I'm not angry. It's OK with me. I don't care.

In the 1993 movie by Quentin Tarantino, 'True Romance', Vincent Coccotti, (Christopher Walken) is using enhanced interrogation techniques on Mr. Worley, (Dennis Hopper) in the infamously brutal Sicilian scene. Part of the script is as follows.

Vincent Coccotti: You know… Sicilians are great liars, the best - in the world, I'm Sicilian, my father was the world's heavy weight champion of Sicilian liars. From growing up with him, I’ve learned the pantomime of liars. There are 17 different things a guy does when he lies - to give himself away. A woman got 20, but guys got 17. But if you know them - like you know your own face, they beat lie detectors all to hell. Now, what we’ve got here is a little game of show and tell - you don't wanna show me nothing but you tell me everything.

The Sicilian scene - A cult favorite

Masters of Deception

Who is the biggest liar?

See results without voting

Kelley Moore: NLP Eye Movement

How often do you lie every day?

Including little white lies, fibs, equivocations, evasiveness, and fairy tales - how often on average do you lie a day?

See results without voting

Microexpressions

FBI Agent Explains How To Spot Liars

Anger, Contempt, Disjust, Fear, Sadness, Surprise, Polite Enjoyment, Real Enjoyment, Shame, joy, sadness, fear, anger, disgust, contempt, and surprise

More by this Author


14 comments

ptosis profile image

ptosis 6 years ago from Arizona Author

In the recent indictment against the old fashioned Russian spies that harken back to days of yore:

Counterintelligence efforts over many years involving the SVR agents under assumed names are illegals with a false background called a legend. These unregistered spies were trained in the brush-pass or flash meeting who they themselves practice counter-surveillance measures (obviously - not very well!) to avoid detection as working agents and often worked in pairs. They are being charged because active foreign government agents are required to register with the US Attorney General .

Steganography is the process of secreting data in an image. Encrypted data in images that are located on publicly -available websites without the data being visible. Radiograms are coded bursts of data that generally sound like Morse


oishi profile image

oishi 6 years ago

Great hub. In spite of the technical terms it makes an interesting reading. Voted up.


John B Badd profile image

John B Badd 6 years ago from Saint Louis, MO

This is a great, well researched hub. I read an article on yahoo a few weeks ago entitled "How To Tell When Your Man Is Lying" or some crap like that, and it went on to list 10 surefire ways to tell if you are being lied too. One was looking up and to the left was creating a lie while down and to the right was recalling something from the right side of the brain. The rest were just as simple. Now I am ok with saying these may be signs, but this article stated if this happens then you are being lied to. I thought 'what a load of crap these folks are feeding us'. I can not imagine how many fights have been started by that article which has not place in print.

Your article on the other hand points out real techniques used by professionals around the world. It is based in science not urban legend. If it was as simple as the above article made it seem there would be no lies because we would have figured this out years ago. Thank you for doing your research and being intelligent about this subject, you probably will not receive the recognition you deserve.


gulnazahmad profile image

gulnazahmad 6 years ago from Pakistan

I have heard that CIA can detect lies from an instrument but people say that it is not that reliable because human mechanism is so complicated and each human being behave differently in different situation.


ptosis profile image

ptosis 6 years ago from Arizona Author

oishi: Thanks for the vote up!

John B Badd:The thing about the eyes is (Your left and right - not theirs - ) Is left lying, right remembering, for 80% of the people who are right handed. (And that was my article hub.liarliar who was feeding you that crap!)

In Javors book, one or two signs means nothing, it has to be a cluster of signs & it has to happen within 5 seconds after the first start giving an answer.

gulnazahmad: The classic lie detector as seen on TV is just there to make a person nervous. The more nervous a person is - the more likely the practiced liar will slip up. It's like a game of poker.


privateye2500 profile image

privateye2500 6 years ago from Canada, USA, London

#7 sortof has it. 7.Look for incongruity between what is being said and the accompanying gestures."

BODY LANGUAGE and the art/study of that is the #1 ability needed to determine if a person is a liar; or at least a liar in the particular quest.

MOST very good liars know about this and so they will watch it very closely. Then - blink ratios come into it as well as many other items not mentioned in here.

Just a few more ways to tell. I have articles written about this topic as well.

Melanie


ptosis profile image

ptosis 6 years ago from Arizona Author

privateye2500: Thanks for the added clues - I didn't even mention blinking at all.


Silver Poet profile image

Silver Poet 6 years ago from the computer of a midwestern American writer

A very good, well written hub. What a useful topic! So many of us can use this info to outwit the con artists in our society.


Beata Stasak profile image

Beata Stasak 6 years ago from Western Australia

Very useful hub, 'Ptosis', it makes us stop and think how do we behave and how the people around us behave:)

I don't know if what I do is lying, but I am a dreamer and tend to see the world around me in a specific way...like to telling stories and include many specific details, which people experiencing the event with me haven't noticed at all...so they jump up at the end of my story saying: " I have noticed that?"

I just gave up on it and comfort myself with realization that most of the time I perceive the world around me differently to many people:)

Thank you for stopping by on my hub and becoming my fan...appreciated a lot..love from Beata


ptosis profile image

ptosis 6 years ago from Arizona Author

Thanksz Silver Poet & Beata Stasak!


LeanMan profile image

LeanMan 6 years ago from At the Gemba

Most people's instincts tell them when someone is telling them a lie, the thing is to trust your instincts..

As to politicians, just see if their lips are moving!


ptosis profile image

ptosis 6 years ago from Arizona Author

Thanksx LeanMan - As in the case of Bush 43 - Dick Cheney's hand was up inside the dummy - making his head & mouth move.


Express10 profile image

Express10 3 years ago from East Coast

This is a useful and interesting hub. So many people overlook their gut instinct or the fact that the person is doing strange things like scratching their face, blinking, or can't make eye contact.


grand old lady profile image

grand old lady 2 years ago from Philippines

Very interesting and thorough. The videos were also very good. Voted up:)

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working