Why Haven't the Colts Contacted Garrard

Why Haven't the Colts Contacted Garrard?


To say that the Indianapolis Colts quarterback situation is in disarray would be an understatement. Kerry Collins has been absolutely brutal, and Curtis Painter doesn't show much promise as a replacement. They went out this week and resigned Dan Orlovsky, and are bringing in Brodie Croyle to try out for the team. But why haven't they contacted David Garrard?
There seems to be some kind of plague against Garrard, who threw 23 touchdown passes and 15 interceptions last year and made a Pro Bowl yet doesn't seem to have any teams willing to give him a shot. If you look at the Colts offensive line, they are young, haven't played many games together, and have a rookie left tackle. With this type of line you need a quarterback that can extend the play and Collins is too old to do that. Painter and Orlovsky don't have enough experience to do this, and they're both pocket passers. David Garrard isn't a speedster, but he is able to move around in the pocket and create plays with his legs and buy time for his receivers to get open.

Let's face it, Dallas Clark is the epitome of a pass catching tight end. He's not going to stay in and block too many defensive ends and outside linebackers successfully. They need a quarterback with a quick release that can extend plays and get the ball out of his hands.

At this point with the quarterbacks available, David Garrard would be their best option to win some games. None of the QB's on the roster are going to get the job done for them. May be they should give McAfee a shot at QB. The fans seem to be a favorite of this.

As for a Peyton Manning return this season, don't count on it. Colts owner Jim Irsay delivered some mixed messages on the topic Monday morning, but it continues to look like even a December return borders on pipe-dream status. NFL Network's Albert Breer reported last week that Manning is dealing with a nine- to 12-month rehabilitation process, which would have him ready for training camp in 2012. It doesn't look like they will be competing for a Super Bowl at home this season.

Submit Your Answer

Who Should Be the Colts Starting Quarterback

See results without voting

More by this Author


Comments 4 comments

Paul Edmondson profile image

Paul Edmondson 5 years ago from Burlingame, CA

With a few teams really needing to upgrade at QB, I'd expect people are beating down Cinci's door to get a shot at Carson Palmer.


Bigpayno profile image

Bigpayno 5 years ago from Indianapolis, Indiana Author

I know they are, but Mike Brown isn't going to budge. It doesn't make sense from a business standpoint. I understand he doesn't want players to feel like they can get out of town that way, but he is not coming back to play for your team. You used a first round pick on a QB, so why not trade Palmer to get some draft picks instead of just letting him retire. Be a smart business man and swallow your pride.


Cogerson profile image

Cogerson 5 years ago from Virginia

Being a huge Colts fan....I am willing to give Curtis Painter a chance...the season is almost lost....no Manning...now no Brackett....no Bullitt...a brutal schedule ..the ship is going down....and it does not matter who is helping with the buckets....too much water in the ship to save the ship. Plus as Irsay twittered...not enough cap room for Garrard.....which how good can he be if he is still sitting out there a month after getting cut. Nice hub....Go Colts.


Bigpayno profile image

Bigpayno 5 years ago from Indianapolis, Indiana Author

There was talk of releasing Collins, which could have cleared up some room. I understand the frustration of bringing in another quarterback and trying to teach them the system. You are right, with the schedule they have the season is all but lost at this point with what they are working with. It really hurts living in Indy to see this happening, especially during a year where we host the Super Bowl. Thanks for the great comments!

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working