ArtsAutosBooksBusinessEducationEntertainmentFamilyFashionFoodGamesGenderHealthHolidaysHomeHubPagesPersonal FinancePetsPoliticsReligionSportsTechnologyTravel
  • »
  • Pets and Animals»
  • Dogs & Dog Breeds

Cross Over Trainers: Compulsion to Reward-Based Training

Updated on February 16, 2013

Reap the rewards of reward-based training!

Training positively will change the bond with your dogs for the better! All rights reserved
Training positively will change the bond with your dogs for the better! All rights reserved | Source

Making the Change is Really Easy!

A vast array of training methods appear to constellate the world of dog training, but more and more dog trainers and owners are embracing reward-based training methods. Positive reinforcement trainers find that a training approach based on rewards helps dogs build trust in the owner rather than living in fear of being punished for making the wrong choices, explains dog trainer Pat Miller, owner of Peaceable Paws in Fairplay, Maryland. The shift from compulsion training to a reward-based training is not a difficult process; many dog owners indeed are reaping the many rewards derived from using such method.

A Guide to Better Training

How to Switch From Compulsion To Reward Based

One of my training colleagues just recently posted a comment on his Facebook page about a client being sent to him after three other trainers suggested electronic collars and other outdated training methods such as alpha rolls and neck scruffs. These are methods of many decades ago! We know better now! Luckily, my colleague was able to help this client out and told the dog owner to toss out the prong collar and learn better, scientifically approved training methods! If you are looking for a trainer, beware of trainers immediately suggesting electronic collars and other old dominant-based training methods!

  • New Principles

The first step into shifting to a reward-based training method would require compliance with different principles when it comes to operant conditioning. The use of positive punishment would need to be replaced with positive reinforcement. Instead of creating an undesirable consequence to the dog for undesirable behavior, you will need to provide instead a desirable consequence for desired behavior. For example, instead of giving a leash correction when your dog pulls on the leash, you would reward your dog for walking next to you on a loose leash instead.

  • New Tools

Because reward-based trainers rarely, if ever, use corrections, the use of training tools crafted for the purpose of causing discomfort or pain are not commonly used. The use of aversion-based tools such as choke chain collars, prong collars and electronic collars ultimately defeat the purpose of reward-based training which is to reward the good and ignore the bad. While it is true that any training collar in the wrong hands can be misused, there are many better training tools suitable for kinder training methods.

  • New Techniques

Reward-based training encompasses different training techniques. For instance, instead of physically manipulated your dog into a sit by applying pressure on his bottom, you can try lure-reward training. To teach the sit using this technique, you would place a treat in front of your dog's nose moving it backwards over his head. As the dog follows the treat, he should assume the desired position, according to the Association of Professional Dog Trainers. Another reward-based method is marker training, where a sound or word is used to signal the moment a dog engages in a correct behavior. The signal is immediately followed by a reward so to reinforce the desired behavior.

  • New Guidelines

Often, compulsion trainers are intimidated by reward-based training because they are afraid they will be stuck giving treats for the rest of the dog's life. While it is true a dog can be trained without food, food is for many dogs the most salient reward possible, explains Valarie V. Tynes a Diplomate of the American College of Veterinary Behaviorists and owner Premier Veterinary Behavior Consulting in Sweetwater, Texas. Reward-based training does not require treats all the time; rather, once a behavior is learned, a good trainer will switch to an intermittent schedule of reinforcement which entails only giving the treats periodically.

  • New Results

Training based on cooperation and kindness rather than forced submission and fear, yields a deep connection between dog and owner that increases trust and builds a better bond. A positive training experience lowers the chances for behavioral problems, whereas, punishment or confrontational techniques may worsen existing problems, leading to a more fearful or aggressive dog, explains Gary Landsberg, a veterinary behaviorist at the North Toronto Animal Clinic, Thornhill, Ont., Canada.Expect to see a happier dog that ultimately works for you for pleasure rather than fear.

All rights reserved. Note: copied content subject to DMCA reporting.

How do you train your dogs?

See results


    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    • alexadry profile image

      Adrienne Janet Farricelli 6 years ago from USA

      I am of the belief that most cases of aggression are fear based, and had to personally fix some dogs that have received ill treatments with shock collars and other outdated methods. I have used positive reinforcement with incredible results on aggressive/reactive dogs. They may take longer to take totally effect but the results are more durable.

    • profile image

      Yoursweetness 6 years ago

      Great post! I wish I read this sooner. I am now having some regrets. Recently, i enrolled my dog into a dog" boot camp" for severe dog aggression. She'll stay on premises for about 4 weeks. At this training facility they use all methods- from the clicker to shock collars. Although I did some research, I wasn't in total agreement with this "combo" method. My hubby believed that in order to rid of her aggression (which on a scale of 1-10, she was a 9), she needed "tough love" or "whatever method works for her". Because if the problem wasn't fixed soon we'd have to give her up... I think positive training may have been the better can't treat aggression with aggression, right?

    • alexadry profile image

      Adrienne Janet Farricelli 6 years ago from USA

      Thank you, happy you are eager to explore this training philosophy!

    • craftybegonia profile image

      craftybegonia 6 years ago from Southwestern, United States

      Very nice hub. Always wanted to learn clicker training for our very intelligent dogs! Useful. Voted up.

    • profile image

      jasper420 6 years ago

      very usefull hub. Great info im going to try this method with my dog!