Teamwork and project management. (3rd ed.)
Buy the Textbook!
Peer assessments can strengthen a team by causing team members to evaluate each other when used in merit reviews for promotions, pay raises, or bonuses. Peer assessments when used under the premise of reviewing peers to identify a person’s strengths and weaknesses for individual improvement and team strength can be an awesome method of creating a team environment reducing negative conflicts at a peer to peer level. “Effective development results from a climate that promotes improvement. Peer assessments might help create such a climate, but it needs to be used with real care.” (Smith, 2007, Pg. 112)
Randy Pausch Last Lecture: Achieving Your Childhood Dreams
Our textbook indicates that
peer assessments are not appropriate when used as an individual’s personal grade, if you will. I cannot agree with this. Throughout this class and other classes discussing groups and teams, and keeping everything in context of an effective team, if one person receives a failing grade, everybody receives a failing grade there cannot be an inappropriate time for peer assessments. If honesty and trust is the foundation and cornerstone of building an effective team, if someone is not keeping up their end of the project they need to be dealt with in an honest and professional way, which is only achievable with peer to peer assessment.
Peer assessments are the better way
to evaluate team members and create an organizational team environment than having some manager who does not know what each individual team member contributed to the project outcome. This is especially true when an individual spends much of their time developing organizational intangible assets such as social capital and corporate intellectual knowledge, the non-intangibles, since managers have a tendency to measure only tangible results. Unknowing managers can also evaluate individual team members with personal bias; this is where the real care needs to be exercised.
A Final Word
I hope you found this article informative and content rich. Please feel free to leave your comments and share your own observations. Send me an email if you have a request on a topic of interest or just to say Hello! It’s FREE to join my Fan club, Subscribe by Email, my RSS Feed, or simply join me here on Hub pages with a click of your mouse.
Article(C)2009 - 2010 cluense, all rights reserved. Cluense creates articles and posts online. She creates articles on, accounting, entrepreneur, political issues, small business, society, relationships, taxes, work from home businesses, and Tutorials. She also has a strong passion for writing