jump to last post 1-5 of 5 discussions (7 posts)

I just saw a hub with almost the same title and content as one of mine. What ca

  1. LauraGSpeaks profile image97
    LauraGSpeaksposted 4 years ago

    I just saw a hub with almost the same title and content as one of mine.  What can I do?

    My hub is about nine months older, but much of the content is remarkably the same.

  2. Dreamhowl profile image97
    Dreamhowlposted 4 years ago

    Is anything cut-and-paste, or is it paraphrased? Since it's on HubPages, maybe you can try reporting it through the HubPages help page. If you scroll to the bottom of the page, there is a link to it. You can report a content violation, if you strongly feel your hub was copied.

  3. Uninvited Writer profile image82
    Uninvited Writerposted 4 years ago

    It's possible it's a coincidence. Some people do have the same ideas.

  4. Susana S profile image96
    Susana Sposted 4 years ago

    You need to look through to see if the other person has actually copied sentences from your hub or it's simply very similar. If there are sections that are directly copied then report the hub and include the examples of copied text.

    I had this happen to me a year or two ago. I found I had to be very specific about what text had been copied before HP would remove it. They won't do anything if it's just similar.

    1. LauraGSpeaks profile image97
      LauraGSpeaksposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      Good advice.  The content is not verbatim--no whole copied sentences, just VERY similar content with an almost identical title.

    2. Susana S profile image96
      Susana Sposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      Do you think they have "spun" your content? If so, you can try reporting it.

  5. tsmog profile image82
    tsmogposted 4 years ago

    Hi LauraGSpeaks. This is a complicated and complex question. The answer I offer may be taken in several hues of light. The rules HP complies with is both their own and those of additional organizations. Theirs are more "than" likely patterned from the more formal organizations.

    To give you a hint I looked into a poem I wrote once that seems to have been copied in a paraphrased format. It became a book and did well. The logic of order and the meaning of the poems stanzas are very, very similar. The quick of it is by the time I finished researching it became a 48 page paper. Copyright law is very, very complex.

    I submitted the paper to reliable resources who said they agreed with the concept & that the time line of both do correlate, however the cost to prove it was outweighed by the risk of achieving a positive result or a win in court. So, with the information gained I have it sitting on a back burner while that book does earn from what I feel is my poem.

    The crux is there are two or more means available. The first and easiest is to prove there is an infraction of being plagiarism. In essence plagiarism is simply fraud. A great resource for understanding this is plagiarism.org. Many learning institutions will dismiss a student from a class if caught willfully plagiarizing a work with a failing grade. The key word is "willfully." Some extend that penalty to expulsion. So, plagiarism is not treated lightly within academic & professional circles. Again, the keyword is "willfully."

    I know I have written a hub, posted it, and then within moments seen a hub very close to what I produced. My dander was ruffled for sure, especially since the comments and etc indicated greater success with the other hub. However, my score was high, my readership was acceptable, and accolades offered well received. Yet, I unpublished mine because the other hub was published first. I felt like others would "Feel" with "perceptions" I plagiarized that hub. It is a matter of ethical choices.

    The web, considering the web is on the internet, and there is more to the internet than the web, offers a plethora of both opportunities and the probability of the possibility of likeness. Kinda' like reporting on the presidents' speech is by hundreds of reporters. Many report from the news feeds too. Randomness alone offers similar will certainly ensue.

    The key is marketing your work & gaining a higher readership offering validity as first & foremost. If damages occur then proceed.