I just now checked the indexing of one of my hubs and found that google has cached it with a "similar" notation.
It has a very similar name to an older hub on HP. Although of radically different content it is still about the same subject, or at least pretty much so.
Do I need to take action because of the notation by google? I could change the title (no need to change the content) but obviously can't change the URL so it doesn't seem that would do much good.
I'm a little surprised HP didn't notify me when I produced the hub; the only change in the title was the word "wood" instead of "hardwood".
I wouldn't worry. Everybody has different perspectives and altogether different 'voice' when writing about a similiar subject.
No. Both may be similar in topics but doesn't anger management at the big G.
My experience is a little different. Google seems to take a "first come first served" approach to primary keywords duplicated within a domain - it's not a rule, just a tendency noticed by some.
When a more recent article does as well with the same keywords, it's usually because it's MUCH better than the first.
This favoritism seems to be the case whether they're written by the same author or different ones. So in my experience, Google seems to like one authority article per keyword per domain.
Changing the title IS effective if it targets different keywords - at least in my experience. Even if the URL is different. You might wait and see if the hub gets good traffic. If not, try changing the title.
Or you could try to compete. I'm not sure you should worry about offending another hubber with similar keywords (and hardwood could be perceived as the same OR as different by Google - it's hard to tell). I've had similarly titled articles follow mine on a site, and if they were better than mine, I didn't mind.
If you search Google, you'll see the keywords you've chosen in your flooring article are similar to many others at HubPages on the same subject. It's a competitive set of keywords here. If you want to stand out, read the other hubbers' hubs and find out what they DIDN'T do that you could do better - and do it in your hub.
Hope this helps.
Good advice, Fiction Teller. I had tentatively decided to wait and see what happened with traffic, even though it will take some time.
Hadn't thought about rewritng to cover what other hubbers had not - that's maybe a good thought in any case as far as our readers go.
by chriscamaro3 years ago
41 hubs and 41 views per day? WTF?! What did I do to deserve this?I don't get it. Traffic has been dropping steadily now and I even added half a dozen more hubs. This is getting ridiculous. ...
by krissy726 years ago
How long did it take for your hubs to rank in Google?
by Sally Gulbrandsen20 months ago
My most recent hub was Snipped and given a new short title by staff which does not properly reflect the contents of the hub. Views have been negatively impacted and have not picked up after the change. ...
by Simon Cook6 years ago
I have quite a few old hubs that over a year or more have had less than 100 visits - it's not because they are poor hubs, but mostly because they are in a 'saturated market'.Will this have an impact on my domain as a...
by Susan Ream3 years ago
How does Google choose which Hubs to search?All of the hubs I have written say, "Well done! This high-quality, engaging Hub is Featured on other Hubs and Topic Pages and has the opportunity to be listed in search...
by Dr Mark3 years ago
In the few years that I have been on this site, I have heard that you can increase traffic by picking short titles. I have also read that you can get traffic by choosing a long title and including many search...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.