30+ Coffee Creamers You Need to Try
If you have explored the world of coffee creamers, then you may have heard of these. But if you just stick to your same Sugar-Free Vanilla coffee creamer all the time, then maybe this ultimate list will help you branch out and try something new.
In this article, I will describe the flavors, where you can buy, prices, as well as links to buy. That said, availability and prices may vary from place to place.
#1 Coffee Mate Funfetti
This Funfetti Coffee Creamer is said to taste like vanilla cake with frosting and even hints of sugary sprinkles. Coffee-Mate teamed up with Funfetti® to create this new flavor. It is also lactose-free and dairy-free! Coming in at $3.99 per 32-oz, this is a perfect creamer for your morning cup of joe.
#2 Coffee Mate Cinnamon Toast Crunch
The Cinnamon Toast Crunch Coffee Creamer was released along with the Funfetti flavor shown above. For this flavor, Coffee-Mate has teamed up with Cinnamon Toast Crunch™.
It is the same price, $3.99 per 32-oz, and it definitely sounds delicious. It is basically described as the leftover cinnamon milk you get after eating a bowl of Cinnamon toast Crunch Cereal. Now, who doesn't want that!
#3 International Delights Peeps
This flavor is new for 2020 and it sounds like a childhood dream! The New PEEPS® reamer is marshmallow-y and sweet. As well as, yellow? Yep, you heard that right, this creamer is bright yellow just like PEEPS® themselves! Right now it is available at Walmart for $2.25 for 32-oz. Get it while it's still available this Easter season.
#4 International Delights Cinnabon® Classic Cinnamon Roll
Now every morning you can wake up to the smell of a freshly baked Cinnamon rolls with this Cinnabon® Coffee Creamer. The flavor is $3.18 at Walmart for a 32-oz container. Yay! No more hours of baking or going to the mall to get your taste of Cinnabon®.
#5 International Delights Almond Joy
Toasted Coconut, Almond, and chocolate sound like a delicious combination for coffee creamer, though sadly this flavor has been discontinued, it is still fun to look bad on this wild and wacky creamer. You actually can get this flavor in singles for or you can order a 2-pack for amazon for $20.49.
#6 International Delights Birthday Cake
This flavor is basically just like the Funfetti one above, except this one has more of a cake flavoring. The flavor description is vanilla cake with yellow frosting and plenty of rainbow sprinkles. It costs $3.39 for a 32-oz container at Target.
#7 Coffee Mate Ice Cream Shoppe Butter pecan
You can get a 2 pack of this creamer at Walmart for just $6.89. It is apart of Coffee Mate's Ice Cream Shop Line. Now you can enjoy your favorite ice cream in your coffee! Who would have thought!
#8 Coffee Mate Nestle Toll House Chocolate Chip Cookie
#9 Coffee Mate Cookies & Cream
Basically an oreo, but it's not. It is a little more on the pricey side coming in at $2.99 for 16-oz.
#10 Baileys White Chocolate Peppermint Bark
The baileys line comes in 4 flavors. This one is peppermint bark flavored, which sounds like a holiday in a mug to me.
#11 Coffee Mate Chocolate Toffee Truffle
Mmhh, now who doesn't love some delicious toffee! And toffee truffle! In coffee! Sign me up! this Chocolate Boutique flavor is available at Safeway for $2.89 for a 16-oz bottle.
#12 International Delights Cold Stone Creamery® Sweet Cream
I'm sure that any ice cream lover will absolutely love this creamer. I've never been to Cold Stone before but I am sure this coffee creamer will taste exactly like their ice cream. Vanilla-y and delicious! it costs $3.18 for a 1-quart bottle
#13 Coffee-Mate La Lechera Dulce de Leche
Dulce de Leche is a Latin American confection made by heating sweetened condensed milk until it becomes thick and warm caramel color. So if your looking for a tasty caramel-like coffee creamer this may just be the one for you.
#14 International Delights French Toast Swirl
This is actually a limited edition recipe so make sure to try it while it is still available. this flavor tastes like cinnamon, maple, and a hint of butter. Surely you can use this in your morning coffee while eating some french toast on the side. It sounds like the perfect combo to me.
#15 Coffee Mate Dove Dark Chocolate Almond
This flavor is dairy, lactose, and cholesterol-free. Which means its healthy right? Well, I don't know about that, but it sure does taste good! Perfect for any dark chocolate lover or DOVE® fan. Get a two-pack on Amazon for $21.69.
#16 Coffee Mate Eggnog Latte
Perfect for a Christmas morning coffee or any seasonal morning. Apparently you can get a 16-oz bottle for $1 at Schnucks! That's a pretty good deal if you ask me.
#17 Coffee Mate Frosted Gingerbread
This is a cinnamon-y and molasses-y flavor swirled with frosting to simulate the gingerbread we all know and love at that time of the year. you can get this flavor for $3.18 at Walmart but since it is February, it does seem to be unavailable right now. Maybe next year!
#18 Coffee Mate Girl Scouts Thin Mints
I did include this in a list of need to try because it was just to cool not to, but sadly, this flavor has been discontinued. The flavor did seem to be doing well, but that doesn't mean they can't discontinue it. So sorry!
#19 International Delights Hershey's Chocolate Caramel
Rich caramel and Hershey chocolate, this flavor is for anyone that loves Hershey or caramel! Available at Walmart for $3.18 for a 32-oz bottle.
#20 Coffee Mate Ice Cream Shoppe Mocha Almond Fudge
Another ice cream flavor in the Ice Cream Shop line. This flavor is chocolate and almond swirled together to create a sophisticated yet delicious flavor.
#21 International Delights Smore's
This limited-edition flavor will remind you of a summer night next to the campfire. Marshmallow, chocolate, graham cracker, and coffee sounds like a near-perfect combo. It costs $2.28 for a 32-oz bottle which is pretty good for a s'more in a bottle.
#22 International Delights Reese's Peanut Butter Cup
Probably one of the best flavors in this list is the REESE'S peanut butter cup flavor. Chocolate and peanut butter are one of those combos that everyone loves. Combine that with coffee and you will be excited about that Monday morning sip.
#23 International Delight Oreo
Everyone loves OREO®! How could you not want to try this flavor! It's like eating an OREO® that is already dunked. It is available for $3.18 at Walmart for a 32-oz bottle.
#24 International Delight Caramel Marshmallow
This fat and the sugar-free flavor is described as a caramel creamer with a delicious caramel flavor. Maybe this flavor is healthier, I mean it is sugar and fat-free, but it still is a creamer.
#25 Coffee Mate Girl Scouts Caramel & Coconut
Delicious just like the original Samoas cookies themselves. This flavor tastes just like a girl scout cookie with beautiful caramel and coconut flavor with that hint of chocolate that is drizzled on top of the cookies.
#26 International Delight York Peppermint Patty
If you are a mint liver, then this creamer is totally for you! This sweet treat will totally remind you of Halloween night sorting out all the peppermint candies and trading them for the Reese's
#27 Coffee Mate Snickers
Another one of your favorite Halloween candies, or America's favorite candy bars for a matter of fact. I have tried this and can confirm it does taste sort of like snickers. Lots of chocolate and caramel flavor. It costs $3.48 for a 32oz bottle at Walmart.
#28 Coffee Mate Red Velvet
$3.49 at Target for 32 ozs. This flavor will remind you of Red Velvet birthday cake. The delicious chocolatey flavor and pretty red color.
#29 Coffee-Mate the Cheesecake Factory Dulce de Leche Caramel Cheesecake
The Cheesecake Factory had a line of Coffee creamer!? Yep! They also have a line of ice cream too. This coffee creamer will give you that nice caramel and cream cheese flavor without driving an hour away for a slice of cheesecake. I believe it only comes in 16 oz bottles.
#30 Coffee Mate The Cheesecake Factory Strawberry Cheesecake
Next, the Cheesecake Factory's other flavor. Strawberry cheesecake. I'm sure it tastes just like your plain piece of strawberry cheesecake. But come on, if you want cheesecake why wouldn't you get a flavor full of caramel, chocolate, whipped cream, and nuts.
#31 Coffee Mate Frosted Sugar Cookie
Lastly, we have a nice holiday flavor, Frosted Sugar Cookie. It costs $2.98 for a 32 oz bottle so it is on the cheaper side. This flavor will remind you of sitting with your family on Christmas Eve while making delicious sugar cookies for Santa.
That is all the interesting coffee creamers I have found compiled into one list. I hope this can help you get out of your comfort zone and try some new and crazy flavors. at flavor would you try? Tell me in the comment section. I would definitely go for the Peeps, Reese's, and Thin Mints.
© 2020 Brooke Fustin