ArtsAutosBooksBusinessEducationEntertainmentFamilyFashionFoodGamesGenderHealthHolidaysHomeHubPagesPersonal FinancePetsPoliticsReligionSportsTechnologyTravel

Recipes for Making Paninis from Leftovers

Updated on February 24, 2017

Make Paninis out of your Leftover Turkey, Ham, Corned Beef, Hard Boiled Eggs and Lamb

Have plans yet for your leftover turkey? Here are some delicious panini recipe ideas to use up those leftovers from Thanksgiving, Christmas, Easter and St. Patrick's Day, - just about any holiday feast.  Turkey and  ham are traditional panini stuffers.  Add gravy, cranberry sauce, cheeseballs and stuffing, and you have the perfect ingredients for a scrumptuous post-holiday panini feast.  Lamb, corned beef and hard boiled eggs make fabulous paninis too! How about a dessert panini from chocolate bunnies and marshmallow chicks?

You can make these recipes fast and easy without a lot of extra prep of ingredients. The variations are bound only by your imagination.  Create your own variations of the recipes below by adding one or two of your own family's favorite holiday leftovers.

Image courtesy of Vegan Feast Catering hosted on under CC BY 2.0.

Turkey Cranberry Panini Sandwich

This recipe will rival your Thanksgiving feast


Turkey cut into bite-size pieces

Cranberry sauce

Cold leftover gravy

Sage or poultry seasoning

Salt & pepper

Softened butter or substitute spread

Ciabatta bread or leftover rolls

Preheat panini press, medium heat. Spread a thin layer of gravy on each piece of ciabatta. Layer one piece with turkey and cranberry sauce. Sprinkle with sage or poultry herb seasoning and salt and pepper to taste. Put sandwich together and butter outside. (Easiest to butter one side, place buttered side on the press, then butter the side.) Cook until browned.

Other tasty leftover additions include dressing or stuffing, spinach or lettuce leaves, cheese, and apple pie filling. Yes, you can use up leftover dessert too!

Turkey, Apple and Cheddar Panini

Great with turkey cooked on a grill


Whole wheat bread or Texas slice (thick) bread

Turkey cut into bite size pieces

Apple pie filling (or thinly sliced applies slices)

Leftover cheddar cheese sliced, or cheeseball spread

Salt and pepper

Romaine or spinach leaves

Softened butter or spread substitute

Preheat panini press. Layer one pieces of bread with cheddar cheese slice or spread, romaine or spinach leaves, turkey, salt and pepper to taste, then apple pie filling or slices. Finish with another slice of cheese or spreadmore cheeseball on the remaining slice. Butter one side of sandwich and place on panini press. Butter the other side. Cook until golden brown and cheese has melted.

The smokiness of leftover turkey that was cooked on the grill adds terrific flavor. Try pear slices instead of apple, or brie instead of cheddar cheese. Also good to make with leftover croissants.

Photo courtesy of Adesso Bistro

Low-tech Panini Grills - Buy one of these if you're pressed for money and space

Calphalon Contemporary Nonstick Panini Pan and Press
Calphalon Contemporary Nonstick Panini Pan and Press

Designed for use on the stovetop, this panini pan features a non-stick surface. You can move it from stovetop to oven, and it's great for grilling meats and veggies indoor too.

Rome's 1305 Panini Press Cooker, Cast Iron with Steel and Wood Handles
Rome's 1305 Panini Press Cooker, Cast Iron with Steel and Wood Handles

Use on the grill or stovetop. Comes apart for easy cleanup.


Ham and Cheese on English Muffin

A tasty breakfast panini sandwich recipe


English muffin, split

Sliced ham

Sliced cheese assortment or cheeseball spread

Spoonful of cold green bean casserole (even better with onion topping!)

Salt and pepper

Softened butter or substitute spread

Preheat the panini press. Spread green bean casserole on the bottom of the muffin, add ham, season with salt and pepper to taste, top with cheese or cheeseball spread.

A sweet and spicy mustard sauce provides a different twist on this panini. Try leftover broccoli or brussel sprouts instead of green bean casserole. Also good with croissant instead of English muffin

Ham and Sweet Potato Panini

This ham and yam recipe appeals to those with a sweet tooth


Italian or other plain bread

Ham thinly sliced or cut into bite-size pieces

Leftover sweet potato casserole or mashed sweet potatoes


Leftover mustard sauce from ham or spicy mustard

Softened butter or substitute spread

Preheat panini press or pan. Spread a thin layer of mustard sauce on each piece of bread. Add mashed sweet potatoes, sprinkle with cinnamon, top with ham and another layer of sweet potatoes. Butter top of sandwich, place in press buttered side down, then butter the other side. Cook until golden brown.

Another tasty addition would be grilled pineapple - grill it on the press before you make your sandwich. Or use thinly sliced grilled pears or applies.


Holiday Ham and Cheese Panini Recipe

Garlic gives this one its twist


French, Italian or ciabatta bread

Thinly slice ham or ham cut into bite-size pieces

Mustard sauce or spicy mustard

Cheese of any variety - don't forget to use up the cheeseball!

Roasted peppers, tampanade, sun dried tomatoes, or any other appetizer spread

Olive oil

One clove raw garlic, slightly pressed

Preheat panini press. On one slice of bread, spread the mustard. Layer on the cheese and ham. Top with the roasted red peppers or appetizer spread. Finish with top slice of bread. Brush olive oil on top, place on panini press oiled side down, and brush oil on other side of sandwich. Cook until golden brown.

Remove from press and while the sandwich is still hot, rub garlic on one or both sides. Super yummy! If you can't handle the raw garlic taste, put the clove in the press next to the sandwich. Keep an eye on it and take it out before it turns brown. The cooked garlic has a mellower taste.

Image courtesy of Chefvet hosting on Wikimedia Commons under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Easter Smore Panini

Even the leftovers from your child's Easter basket can make a mouth-watering panini

The key ingredients for this tasty dessert include those leftover marshmallow chicks and half-eaten chocolate bunnies. Here's my take on this campfire favorite.

Cinnamon swirl bread

Broken pieces of chocolate

2-3 Marshmallow bunnies or chicks

Preheat panini press. On one slice of bread, place the marshmallows and chocolate pieces. Top with the other piece of bread and butter or spray outside of sandwich. Place on panini press and cook until melted, about 1 minute each side.

My favorite additions include peanut butter and slices of banana. I like to combine milk chocolate and dark chocolate if I have it. Graham crackers or plain bread work as well as cinnamon swirl. Hollow chocolate bunnies or eggs are best for this. If you have solid chocolate, use a potator peeler to shave thin slices so it will spread and melt easily.

Image by author

Easter Egg Panini

The perfect breakfast sandwich using those leftover hard boiled eggs


English muffin or bagel

Sliced hard-boiled egg


Sharp cheddar cheese

Roasted asparagus

Olive oil

Preheat panini press. On one slice of muffin, spread the mayo. Layer on the cheese and egg slices. Top with the roasted asparagus. Finish with top slice of muffin. Brush olive oil on top, place on panini press oiled side down, and brush oil on other side of sandwich. Cook until golden brown.

Eggs-ellent. Try leftover hollandaise sauce instead of mayo. Use a fried egg instead of hardboiled. Add ham or bacon slices.

To roast asparagus, place trimmed spears in a single layer on a baking sheet, season with salt, pepper and a little bit of olive oil. Roast in preheated 400 degree oven for 10 minutes.

Image by author

Easter Lamb Panini

Lamb and mint sauce with a twist


Ciabatta roll

Mint-mustard sauce

Slices of rare to medium-rare lamb

Thinly sliced cucumber

Edam or other mild cheese

Olive oil

Preheat panini press. Prepare mint-mustard sauce by combining tablespoon of mint sauce with tablespoon dijon mustard. On one slice of ciabatta bread, spread the mint-mustard sauce. Layer on the lamb and cucumbers. Top with the Edam cheese. Finish with top slice of ciabatta bread. Brush olive oil on top, place on panini press oiled side down, and brush oil on other side of sandwich. Cook until golden brown.

Try mint-yoghurt sauce instead. Combine tablespoon of mint sauce with tablespoon of greek yoghurt. Or pesto yoghurt sauce made the same way.

Corned Beef and Cabbage Panini

This reuben wannabe makes the day after St. Patricks Day special


Rye bread

Corned beef cut into bite-size pieces

Thousand Island dressing

Swiss cheese or smoke gouda

Leftover roasted cabbage

Olive oil

Preheat panini press. On one slice of bread, spread the thousand island dressing. Layer on the cheese and corned beef. Top with the roasted cabbage. Finish with top slice of bread. Brush olive oil on top, place on panini press oiled side down, and brush oil on other side of sandwich. Cook until golden brown.

De-lish! Try dijon mustard instead of thousand island dressing. Experiment with your favorite smoked cheese. The smokiness of the cheese with the saltiness of the corned beef and sweetness of the thousand island dressing will make you think you're in an Irish deli. / CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

Making Paninis with a Press - Panini grills are the faster than stovetop griddles

What's your favorite panini sandwich recipe?

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    • profile image

      Samiullah 3 years ago

      Ever thought of using mayo on your bread? One of my frndeis told me that her grandmother spreads mayo on the bread before grilling it so it gives it a more rich flavor. Just a thought. I've never tried it so i don't know how it tastes, but my friend swore she's never had better tasting grilled cheese than her grandma's but of course it could be her being a bit bias.

    • profile image

      othellos 4 years ago

      Excellent lens. Your panini pictures are awesome. You gave me all the needed ideas to use leftovers. Your Easter section recipes though were the most helpful form me because during that time we have a problem with leftovers... Thanks for sharing:=)

    • beaworkathomemom profile image

      beaworkathomemom 5 years ago

      The pictures look so delicious.

    • GeekGirl1 profile image

      GeekGirl1 5 years ago

      I love all your panini recipes.

    • profile image

      anonymous 5 years ago

      I love your video. However, you do NOT look like you eat all of that lovely cheese :-). Just received my panini gril (a Breville Duo) and can not wait to use it!

    • JohnMichael2 profile image

      JohnMichael2 5 years ago

      all of 'en

    • sudokunut profile image

      Mark Falco 6 years ago from Reno, Nevada

      Great ideas for leftovers. I love paninis so this will come in handy after christmas dinner.

    • Beadsnresin profile image

      Beadsnresin 6 years ago

      they look so good!

    • bead at home mom profile image

      Teri Hansen 6 years ago

      Oh my goodness these look delicious, my husband has just recently started making these and will have new recipes to pass along to him. Thx for sharing, I've added this page to my Thanksgiving leftovers page.

    • QuinnWolf LM profile image

      QuinnWolf LM 6 years ago

      I love Paninis but they seem to be not as popular in the US as they are in Canada. Every other sandwich place serves Panini in Canada. It's mostly only Panera here. I love making them at home !

    • RetroMom profile image

      RetroMom 6 years ago

      This is very helpful. This sure is a wonderful way to use leftover food. Sometimes leftovers like roast-beef and Rotisserie chicken makes delicious sandwiches. Thanks for sharing these wonderful recipes, Love all of them.

    • crsalx19 lm profile image

      crsalx19 lm 7 years ago

      waste no more :)) ... good ideas,i like italian food :) 1+

    • Kiwisoutback profile image

      Kiwisoutback 7 years ago from Massachusetts

      My favorite is an Italian cold cut panini. It tastes much better hot than it does cold. Any of the ones you've featured sound good too. Mouth watering photos!

    • LouisaDembul profile image

      LouisaDembul 7 years ago

      Never thought of using the kids' sweets to make panini! think I prefer ham and cheese....

    • profile image

      anonymous 7 years ago

      I smiled all the way through after reading about using chocolate bunnies and marshmallow chicks in your intro and you did it! Fun, creative and delicious ideas!

    • Adriana Daniela profile image

      Adriana 7 years ago from New Market

      Mmmm... sounds so delicious! Never made my own panini, but I may just try now.

    • profile image

      anonymous 7 years ago

      Drooling....marshmallo and chocolate on a cinnamon panini! Sounds ultra decadant and delicious

    • Gypzeerose profile image

      Rose Jones 7 years ago

      Creative! I will definitely try some.

    • TreasuresBrenda profile image

      Treasures By Brenda 8 years ago from Canada

      These recipes look yummy and your page is well put together & blessed by an Angel this evening. Welcome to Culinary Favorites from A to Z Headquarters! Your lens is being featured under P is for Panini Sandwiches.