jump to last post 1-4 of 4 discussions (7 posts)

"Organ Donation"

  1. threekeys profile image82
    threekeysposted 20 months ago

    What are your thoughts about if someone accepted a organ/organs from prisoner who was willy nilly executed for his/her organs?

    1. erorantes profile image51
      erorantesposted 20 months agoin reply to this

      For what I know about prisoners execution. When, they get executed; they electrocuted. The organs do not work after the electricity is all over their bodies. It is a sad topic but it is a reality in human history and present time. The trial is very important to people who do bad things and for those who are honest.It is better to live a righteous live. The United States has the best system. They protect human rights to every individual inside or out of jail.

    2. psycheskinner profile image83
      psycheskinnerposted 20 months agoin reply to this

      Well if they were killed "for their organs" that would be a crime and an illegal transplant and being accessory to murder. So the question is sort of self-answering.

  2. Kiss andTales profile image78
    Kiss andTalesposted 20 months ago

    Interesting but don't you think this has caused some kind of caos.
    Suppose this person has been mistakenly in prison based on human error.
    Suppose he was or she was framed and that is the outcome. Many times people have proven innocence and are released.
    So my point is you take their life away from society and family and now you want to say it's OK to take organs too. No you already took life now you want more the arm and leg sorta speak!  I just think people have grown despart and they now will just about do anything .they say canabolism is wrong.
    Well now people say its right in another form .
    I just think everything God's gives to us is precious . true people genetically get sick , because of Adam and Eve marked us that way.
    But soon all that will be ended .
    Re 21:4 And he will wipe out every tear from their eyes, and death will be no more, neither will mourning nor outcry nor pain be anymore. The former things have passed away.”
    no one will need Docs !
    No .people will just use that excuse to be Frankenstein !

  3. Aime F profile image85
    Aime Fposted 20 months ago

    I am 1000000% in favour of organ donation but I would never support executing someone specifically for their organs, prisoner or not.

    1. wilderness profile image97
      wildernessposted 20 months agoin reply to this

      I read a sci-fi short story about this once, where a public desperate for organ transplants kept voting in the death penalty to the point that the third traffic violation carried a death sentence.  Of course, everything was immediately harvested from the corpse of the "criminal".

      So yes, the reason was an unwillingness to follow the law but in reality it was but a rationalization to kill more people and get at their "parts".  And unfortunately I could see just that happening - we humans are a greedy lot and doubly so when it comes to being able to live.

  4. threekeys profile image82
    threekeysposted 20 months ago

    This is actually happening in a Asian country. It was on our news the other night. And westerners are buying these  organs. Its wrong. Its  inhumane.. And if I was a organ "donor" recepient I could not live with myself in knowing how it was obtained. Thats my personal opinion.