ArtsAutosBooksBusinessEducationEntertainmentFamilyFashionFoodGamesGenderHealthHolidaysHomeHubPagesPersonal FinancePetsPoliticsReligionSportsTechnologyTravel
  • »
  • Books, Literature, and Writing»
  • Comics & Graphic Novels

Evolution of the American spirit: From Columbia to Captain America

Updated on November 11, 2013

The idea of a national American myth is, in and of itself, controversial. Although clearly falling in line with myth as defined as “A traditional, typically ancient story dealing with supernatural beings, ancestors, or heroes that serves as a fundamental type in the worldview of a people, as by explaining aspects of the natural world or delineating the psychology, customs, or ideals of society”, the relative youth of the United States of America as a nation, the multi-ethnic nature of its populace and the resultant amalgamation of the traditional tales of both the immigrant and native members of the society would place any shared national ideas into the realm of folklore.

However, certain themes common among the immigrant, native, and slave – best embodied by these words from The Declaration of Independence: “all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”(US 1776) – have achieved an apotheosis of sorts, in that they can be likened to divine principles. As such, any embodiment – be it historical, philosophical, fictional, or otherwise – of those principles can be said to be a divine representation, equal in function (if not form) to the gods of ancient and contemporary religious cultures. Moreover, the continued anthropomorphication of those principles can be used to establish a link between each zeitgeist (for lack of a better term) which binds the national identity of the society to its populace just as solidly as religious ritual. Although there have been a great number of candidates over the past 70 or so years in the medium of my choosing, it is my contention that the figure of Captain America best embodies the national character of the United States and is the “spiritual inheritor” of the ideas of the American Spirit.


The embodiment of the “Spirit of America” as (essentially) an illustrated propaganda character is not a new concept. The first such figure to gain national significance was Columbia, “a goddess of freedom whose regal bearing projected America's positive ideals and poetic nature.”

“Though she usually wore a Roman-style metal bonnet and was draped in the stars and stripes of the American flag, kind-hearted Columbia reached out to immigrants and the poor. “(Columbia,

Initially appearing as a veiled reference to America, Columbia was first anthromophisized by the black poet Phillis Wheatley in her poem titled "To His Excellency George Washington" in 1776 (Columbia).

She eventually gave way to Brother Jonathan and Yankee Doodle, Lady Liberty, then Uncle Sam. As the country divided during the civil war, Uncle Sam was briedly replaced by Billy Yank and Johnny Reb, but Uncle Sam returned to primacy shortly thereafter (although it is worth mentioning that Columbia’s importance seemed to resurge during WWI).


In the years leading up to the US’s entry into World War II, there were a great many patriotic themed characters gracing both newspapers and the new medium of comic books. The most enduring and recognized of the comic book creations is Captain America (Superman wouldn’t be linked to fighting for “truth, justice, and the American way” until 1952 (CBR)). Like Superman, Captain America was (intentionally or not) an attempt to co-opt/reclaim the concept of the Übermensch from Nazi German Nationalism. Another shared characteristic is their ability to inspire not only the ordinary citizens of their universe but the heroes as well; each is the measure of what it is to be a “Super Hero”. Each one also shares the genre role of “The Tank” – the first to enter the battlefield, set to protect all others –offensively and defensively— first and foremost.

However, unlike Superman, Captain America is not superhuman. He was envisioned as a poor, sickly man unfit for military duty, chosen to take part in a program to develop the ultimate soldier and became the pinnacle of human potential. The propaganda value of the character being blonde haired, blue-eyed, physically and mentally perfect and staunchly on the side of the US cannot be overlooked; the perfect “Aryan” man punching Hitler on the cover of his first appearance was literally and figuratively a slap in the face. And, while Uncle Sam featured solely in recruitment posters, readers of all ages…but mostly kids…could directly witness the adventures of the soon to be dubbed Sentinel of Liberty.


After the war, Captain America’s popularity waned and his title was cancelled. Then, during the Vietnam era, he was reintroduced to the public and has maintained a steady presence in the popular culture ever since.

What is interesting about the character is that since his “reemergence” – particularly following the 2001 attack on American soil – he is being specifically written as representing not the US government or policies but rather as championing the American Dream: Life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. He is often conflicted with the practices of his government and the political beliefs of his people, but will stand in their defense regardless. He is, in the best possible sense, a character devoid of political motivation, to the point where he considers the beliefs of his alter ego as secondary to the responsibility of safeguarding the civil liberties of others. He is a symbol for all people, regardless of party, race, or nationality.


Recent years have seen Captain America under the employ of the global espionage agency, S.H.I.E.L.D., becoming a fugitive from the US government for actively opposing legislation to register and control superhuman powers and activities, “assassinated” as part of a plot to take over the American government and replaced by an old ally (himself a former cold war era assassin brainwashed by the soviets), resurrected and placed in charge of the organization that resulted from the SHRA (Super Human Registration Act). During this period, the narrative of the story – written by Ed Brubaker – focused on the importance of “Captain America” as a symbol and the need for that symbol to remain above partisan politics and the “interests” of the nation to best aid the common man. His “death” and replacement stirred controversy in both the left- and right-leaning facets the mainstream media, culminating in an uproar from the Tea party –perhaps rightfully so – in January 2010 when some of their slogans appeared in a storyline dealing with Cap and his sometimes partner, the Falcon, on the trail of a white supremacist, anti-government, survivalists group called “the Watchdogs” ( They were afraid that the character’s comments would cast their movement in a negative light in the minds of the target demographic of readers (14-18 historically) – despite the fact that the signage was incidental to the main story. Thus, even beyond the confines of his fictional universe, the power of the symbol carries a certain weight in the minds of the public.

Captain America: The Winter Soldier

It is true that the character has been shaped and redefined throughout the decades but there is no other single creation in the last 70 years that has exemplified the highest principles of the American spirit than Captain America and it is that depiction above all other modern hero myths – the billionaire playboys, demi-gods, and world-weary vigilantes – that best represent what the US as a nation can aspire to.

Works cited

Brubaker, Ed (w), Epting, Steve (i), Brevoort, Tom (e). Captain America vol. 5 #1-50 (Jan. 2005 –July 2009), Marvel Comics Group.

Columbia. (Feb. 28th, 2010). Conservapedia.

Cronin, Brian. Comic Book Legends Revealed #276 (Sept. 3rd, 2010). CBR. © 1995 - 2012 Comic Book Resources.

Pickett, Kerry. “Marvel admits to 'mistake' in controversial Captain America comic” (Feb. 10th, 2010). The Washington The Washington Times LLC.


    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    • pointblank009 profile image

      pointblank009 4 years ago from Buffalo

      It really doesn't affect Steve Roger's "purity," it affects the US government's purity. Those nitpickers need to read Harriet Washington's "Medical Apartheid," and they'll think the cap story revision is mild by comparison. I read the first four or five books, but it took a while for the rest to come out, so I lost touch. Planning to buy the whole volume however.

    • George L Stewart profile image

      George L. Stewart 4 years ago from Cleveland, OH

      I'm familiar with the story (via Patriot from Young Avengers), but I haven't read it yet. I do remember it causing quite a bit of controversy in the fandom at the time. Some thought it polluted the purity of the character, some thought it unnecessarily tacked on a legacy to the character, but (I think) most people were just unaware that the US government of the time was willing to use soldiers (let alone black soldiers) as guinea pigs. The victor writes the history books tho, so I'll just leave it at that for now.

    • pointblank009 profile image

      pointblank009 4 years ago from Buffalo

      Cap and SHIELD go way back to his beginnings as an Avenger. A complicated relationship over the years.

      As a Captain America reader from the mid-'60's this was a good piece. Are you familiar with the revisionist-Marvel black Captain America who emerged as a result of government chemical experiments on black men as guinea pigs for Erskin's Super Soldiers and therefore in actuality are the first Captain Americas?

    • whonunuwho profile image

      whonunuwho 4 years ago from United States

      Nice work. As in most symbols, there is much more that is part and parcel of truth and myth. The true essence if the American spirit is best symbolized by the cost of the freedoms won and sacrifice of lives over the years in wars, and what many take for granted. The Statue of Liberty is an American symbol that does show strength and and ongoing spirit, revealing roots of what the country was built upon.whonu

    • Rodric29 profile image

      Rodric Johnson 4 years ago from Peoria, Arizona

      This is one of the most beautiful pieces that I have read on hub pages. I voted it up and shared it. I almost did not read it because I thought it was frivolous, but the content is beyond anything I expected in the title. Thank you for writing such a great piece.