ArtsAutosBooksBusinessEducationEntertainmentFamilyFashionFoodGamesGenderHealthHolidaysHomeHubPagesPersonal FinancePetsPoliticsReligionSportsTechnologyTravel
  • »
  • Politics and Social Issues»
  • North America Political & Social Issues

Could It Happen Here?

Updated on September 22, 2014

Breaking Away

The failed independence referendum in Scotland, the unsuccessful effort to get an initiative on the California ballot to divide that state into 6 smaller states and, what to me seem like simmering regional tensions in the United States got me to thinking about my home state of Pennsylvania.

This interest in breaking off appears to be mainly a conservative or reactionary phenomenon. As people in certain regions realize that they are being left behind. The fact that the largest support for secession in the United States comes from the states that make up both the former Confederacy and the base of the Republican Party could be evidence of this.

Held Back?

But why can't this work the other way. Some writings I saw on the Scottish election alluded that Scotland may have wanted to break away from the United Kingdom and create a "social democracy" along the lines of Norway, etc.

In Pennsylvania, I could see this happening as well. The urban centers like Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, and the Lancaster, York, and Harrisburg region, may eventually feel that they are not being heard or even blocked by the more rural regions between Philadelphia and Pittsburgh.


I could see Pennsylvania splitting into five regions, and perhaps ever joining with other states.

The largest of these regions would be the one centered around Philadelphia, perhaps even merging with parts of New Jersey and Delaware.

Pittsburgh and it's suburbs would be a second large region or state, this one may also extend into another state, even combining with the city of Youngstown, Ohio.

My home area of Harrisburg, and the nearby communities of York and Lancaster, would make a third area. Parts of Maryland could also be ensconced into this "state".

A final potential state would include Erie, and might look at merging with Southern New York.

What Would be Left?

After this, what would be left of Pennsylvania?

Pennsylvania would be a large, but fairly sparsely populated area. Dominated by small, homogeneous towns. The economy would be heavily agricultural, with resource extraction also playing a major role. The state would probably look more like a Southern State than a Northeastern state.

In a sense, what many would call "Pennsylbama" or "Pennsyltucky" would be a reality!


    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    • JamaGenee profile image

      Joanna McKenna 3 years ago from Central Oklahoma

      "Pennsyltucky" sounds like a winner to me! Better yet, how 'bout re-drawing the boundaries of ALL 48 continental states to reflect the beliefs of its current citizens. And while we're at it, move the capitol of the U.S. from D.C. to the middle of the country, i.e. Omaha or KC, or even OKC. Just a thought... ;D

    • cathylynn99 profile image

      cathylynn99 3 years ago from northeastern US

      i'm from pennsylchusetts. i'd end up in the pgh-ytown region. that wouldn't be horrible. never have to put up with the likes of corbett again.

    • Warren Curtis profile image

      Warren Curtis Daniels Jr 3 years ago from Buffalo, New York

      Nice piece! It is ironic that I am sitting in North Philly as I type this. Lol